Mitchell's Fish Market private rooms are available for any occasion! Work one-on-one with your Private Event Manager to create a truly customized affair. To host your event in one of our private dining rooms, contact us today.View Private Dining Details
We have dined there at least 15 times over the last 5 years and every meal & service has been excellent. The impressive menu offer many different choices and specials very reasonably priced. Also not so loud that you can have a conversation.
We asked for a quieter place to sit due to hearing concerns. We were seated in a comfortable booth and served by an excellent attentive server, Alex. The food was served hot and was delicious. We all agreed that we would go back for another try. Since this was a birthday celebration, our birthday friend was given a delicious dessert, which we shared.
Our family really enjoys Mitchell's. My son loves the tuna and my daughter enjoys the shrimp dishes. The fresh seafood has a great variety for the parents too.
One of my favorite places to go and eat for any occasion!
Very good sea food selections
The meal was one of the top five dinners I have had in 35 years of dining. Excellent from beginning to end. I would rate this as one of the finest restaurants in the greater Indianapolis area.
Our family get together with out of state relatives was great. The waitstaff were very attentive without being intrusive. Every one of us enjoyed our food.
Really good service & fresh seafood. Worth the 45 minute drive
It does not get any better than the food and service at Mitchell’s. They just do things right and pay attention to detail. Wonderful fresh seafood experts prepared and service equal to some of the finest restaurants in the city. Our server Ben went above and beyond to make our dining experience perfect. For, example when he served our iced tea he brought an extra glass ice. The little things count! Also the food and service are consistent which is why I dine here a lot!
Went for $5 crabcakes which were very nice. The half dozen oysters on the half shell however were very small. Usually much meatier when we've ordered in the past. Server was on the ball.
Start to finish everything was way above average! Host, wait staff and food excellent!
First time visit. Table was ready at exact time asked for. Waiter was friendly, well informed, efficient, and quick to please.
When I make a reservation on Opentable and don’t get credit, I can’t give a good review. Simple.
We came feeling "Crabby" - because of the Crab Cake Special ! Nice sized crab cake added to our dinner for a great evening. William was our host - not a server, but a good friend through dinner - he is to be complimented
We asked the waiter (after we were seated) if he could move us to a different location, and he was very accommodating. Our food was delivered timely and was delicious. We never have any complaints.
Always excellent food
Waited to long for the bill
Service slow waiter new and overwhelmed others stepped in later in the evening to help.
Food was great.
We loved the food. The service was a little slow, but when the waitress did come by she was attentive.
We prefer the ambiance of the bar area for dining, and requested same, a couple days in advance on the reservation. The hostess, who seemed over-run on a busy Fri night, told us that Mitchell’s will only reserve a table, not a location. We were willing to wait, and eventually got our requested seating, but with a 20 minute wait, due in large part to insufficient staffing for bussing tables.
Our meal was good. The hospitality was mediocre.
William provided exemplary service and the food was excellent as usual.
We love Mitchells and have gone there for many years. We were disappointed when our four year olds chicken tenders were delivered to the table raw on the inside. A new plate was brought, but it was not removed from our bill.
We have eaten at Mitchell’s several times and had wonderful experiences. This time not so much. It was my sons 17th birthday dinner. He ordered king crab legs. It took an extraordinarily long time to get our food. His crab legs were cold and had to be sent back. The amount of crab was less than last time. Most of our meals had the look of plates that had been either microwaved or had been sitting under the warming lights for quite awhile. Our drinks were refilled only once, and most of us finished our meals with nothing to drink. The waitress did not come around much at all to check on our table. She seemed unfamiliar with most of the menu. We tried asking about several of the dishes and she had no answer. I’m not sure if she was new. I guess we were disappointed because we’ve always had such great experiences at Mitchell’s. The food isn’t cheap, and we don’t feel like we received quality meals to match the price.
Our dining experience was outstanding! Our waiter, Nick, was awesome! Highly recommend this place. We will be back soon.
Greatest ice good food
I’ve heard good things about this restaurant. However, my brother and I were not impressed. Oysters weren’t shucked properly and tap beer ran out. Seafood Cobb salad was flavorless. I’d like to give them another shot.
We had a nice dinner. The salmon (with goat cheese and sun dried tomatos) was fantastic. My wife got the tilapia, which was just fair. But the apps where great. We would go again.
Service and food good as always
Always consistent first class restaurant. Wonderful fish cooked to perfection and attentive and friendly servers. The management team should be applauded for their leadership of this wonderful team.
Food delivery was slow, service indifferent to rude
Spicy crispy shrimp and ahi tuna appetizers were very tasty. Had the tuna and it was pan seared to perfection.
High end place with a diverse menu, good wine selection and great ambiance.
The only complaint I have about our experience at Mitchell’s was with the hostess. We arrived on time for our reservation and were told there would be a brief wait while the table was prepared. The entry was a little crowded, so most of our party stepped off to the side to be out of the traffic. My father, who stayed by the hostess stand, was asked after a few minutes of waiting if he had a reservation. He said yes, gave the name, and was informed that the party had already been seated. He glanced over to where we were all standing and told the hostess that we had not been seated. Another party ( of two) had been given our table (for four) and our reservation had been crossed off the list. If he had not been standing there, we would have been waiting a very long time! Then, when they tried to seat us, we were taken to the very back of the restaurant, only to find the one vacant table had not been cleaned. We were left to stand in the middle of the dining room while the host went back to find another table. Once we were finally seated in a wonderful cozy booth, everything was up to the quality that I have come to expect from Mitchell’s. I realize that it was Valentine’s Day, and probably busier than usual, but I felt that the situation could have been handled better and sincere apologies for the inconvenience would have helped as well.
Booth requested in Open Table reservation was great and on time during a busy Valentines Day evening. All staff and managers very friendly and efficient. Excellent food and service.
Fantastic experience. Food was great, service was great. Our table was in a weird spot shoved in the back so not the greatest seat but with it being so busy, understandable.
Our waiter Ross was wonderful. Kind, knowledgeable, polite, friendly and funny. He was enjoying his very busy Valentin’s evening.
This was my first time at the restaurant. The food was wonderful and my server wear great.
I would give this restaurant and Average rating. Just ordinary. Slow taking drink orders and food order. Wedge salad was good when the table was cleared waitress took eating utensils, so when the main course did arrive we had nothing to eat with. Waited on the waitress to come around; 5 minutes later we asked for knives and forks. She brought my fiance and knife and fork; I got just a knife. 5 minutes later, I got my fork. The waitress had a hard time staying focused.
Service was slow and food was less than expected for the menu price
food was good steak not cooked to temp, and not as good as can be bought from a grocery store. service was good, waiter extremely knowledgeable and outgoing. we eat at mitchells quite frequently
Great food & service!
Awesome food that's well worth the cost. You can taste the freshness and you get a sense that the chef(s) truly care about what they're serving you. The atmosphere is always relaxing but you don't feel stuffy. It's a place where you can wine and dine but you're not afraid to laugh out loud!
Average food. Way overpriced.