Mitchell's Fish Market private rooms are available for any occasion! Work one-on-one with your Private Event Manager to create a truly customized affair. To host your event in one of our private dining rooms, contact us today.View Private Dining Details
Great fresh seafood, wonderful service and consistent quality- hard to ask for much more.
excellent server. very pleasant. food was excellent and fresh.
Exceptionally well prepared cuisine, Excellent presentation, and Exemplary service—Kudos to staff and management in helping make for an Exquisite time of celebration for us together on this special occasion!
We arrived about 5 min before our time. We were seated right at our reservation time. It took about 3 min for server to say hello. We knew what we wanted so we just gave him our whole order without the typical wait between drink order and delivery. I ordered a Moscato. Once it came to the table it was pretty much room temp. To me Moscato should be really cold, I broke wine etiquette and put a piece of ice in my glass. The salad was delivered in a timely manor and gotta say the croutons on the salad may have been the best tasting part of our meal. It took an hour to get our main dish. I ordered the Holiday Surf and Turf. A 6oz Fillet Mignon and Lobster Tail served with smashed red skin potatoes, asparagus and hollandaise. My lobster tail was either frozen at one time or over cooked or both. The fillet was just barely warm. The asparagus was absolutely over cooked and I didn't get hollandaise. My husband ordered the 8oz fillet served with mashed redskin potatoes and asparagus. His steak was well well done not med well. His asparagus was cooked right and he had my hollandaise which was cold. Instead of complaining about the food we ate since we had already waited an hour. We went ahead with dessert. I ordered Banana Bread Pudding and husband ordered the Chocolate Bundt Cake. They were out of the Banana Bread Pudding so I changed to the Crème Brûlèe. The Bundt was dry and over cooked. The Crème Brûlèe was good but barely set. When paying our bill the manager ( assuming she was a manager ) brought us our credit card slip since we used Landry Select points on our meal. She asked how everything was. Typical I say everything was fine. But after a 2 hour meal I told her everything above. She used the excuse that they did have timing issues tonight and this was one of their busy nights of the year. Obviously someone didn't plan well. You don't give horrible service and food on a busy night, that is when you should shine.
Service was worst I’ve had in Indianapolis in the 5 years we have lived here
The food is excellent, the waiter we had was a gem, there is plenty of space, we were seated at reservation time, adequate parking, you carry good white zinfindel, waiter answered all questions with ease and followed through on special request. Will we be back, certainly but can't make it a routine stop due to pricing testing our limits.
We go here often and have always been very happy. The food was very late arriving from the kitchen, the restaurant wasn't super crowded. We are not sure why this happened but the manager comped one of our meals. The food was delicious as always and the server tried his best with the situation. We will go back as this has never happened before and they handled it satisfactorily.
This is a difficult review. Overall I can't complain. There seems to be a clear management issue. We were there at 1:30 and not busy at all. We were seated at the time of our reservation. Here is where I think management is weak. We sat there for quite a while before our young man came to greet us. He was a nice young man. It's like the restaurant is operating in slow motion. Appetizer was good, but took way to long for what we got. We placed all of our order at once, which seems to upset many restaurants for some reason. We weren't in a hurry, but we could tell this was going to take a while. Let me say that the food we ate was very delicious and hot when served. I guess my suggestion is, speed things up some. I
Service was great, Appetizer and Main Entree's were great. Only thing missing was the salad. The lettuce on both the iceberg blue cheese and Caesar salads were not crisp and fresh. Lettuce was old.
Great as always.