Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel
Get it delivered
char-grilled, mashed redskins, asparagus
Excellent food, attentive wait staff. My husband and I really enjoyed our visit.
Celebrated my husband’s birthday. Food and service was great! Great time!
Lobster didn’t have any flavor. Shrimp was good. Shrimp and crab stuffing was forgettable.
The food was great. The service was outstanding. T
Birthday dinner was just delicious!!! Loved it!!
Our waiter was the best!! We really appreciated his great service!!
We had the lobster tail special and it was DELISH!!! Service was outstanding.
Enjoyed the blackened mahi mahi.
I would definitely recommend for fresh seafood. It is a good casual dining experience with really good food.
Justin our waiter was excellent
Very small side portions
The food and prices are fine. We have few seafood options around our land-locked metro. Our server seemed to be new to the restaurant industry. I expected a bit of a higher level of service for this price range.
Overall we enjoyed our dinner and would probably go back. The party rooms looked nice.
Good meal, with execution at a high level. It had been 8 or 9 years since I had been to Mitchell's and I won't wait that long to be back!
Service poor, had to ask for water then had to ask for refills.
Took forever to get food, then it was without vegetables, said they would bring them out but never did.
My husband and I went here for our Valentine's meal. The service was excellent with even our water being filled before we had drank half of it. The food took a little longer than expected to come out but it was very busy. The food was very good and I would definitely go back!
Our waiter was very professional. He apologized many times for the over 30 minutes we waited for our food. I understand kitchens get backed up, but that isn’t the customer ‘s problem. The manager needs to figure it out or risk losing customers. We normally have a good experience, but had our last visit been our first, I wouldn’t return.
Fantastic food, crappy table. had to ask to be moved. Waiter not very friendly.
We sat at the bar actually and it was the best first date we ever had! We will always remember thst special night we went for drinks and dinner at Mitchell’s!
Would not recommend for any special occasion like Valentine's Day! Not staffed appropriately - our service was poor and our food was cold and not cooked properly. The manager did however credit us for one of our entrees. Very disappointed - especially since we had made a reservation.
It was for Valentines night! Everything was amazing!
Excellent service, food was good
Love Mitchell's will eat there many more times!! the only issue I had was how packed the tables were- makes it hard to move around.
The service and atmosphere are a 5. The food was a 2. We ordered the superfood salad with salmon. The salmon was excellent. The salad was poor.
3 of us only ordered water, 1 had tea. I really think, for most restaurants, if you don't order alcohol to boost the price of your check you don't get great service. Tea was refilled once, no ice. Water glasses weren't refilled at all. Needed more dressing on the wedge... for $9 plus, they could have at least had enough dressing on it to be able to taste it. Entrees were good. Could put a few more potatoes on the plate for the price. Potatoes are pretty cheap. 4 of us at the table, only one plate of bread. If there are only 2 of us at the table, we get the same size plate of bread. Hmm.... Someone can't count.
On a good note; reservation was ready, no wait for the table.
Birthday dinner... not acknowledged. Wrong wine served, food late and not warm enough. Didn’t want starch and asked for another vegetable that got to table after we had eaten entree. Some food comped but took dessert home.
We received a rather luke-warm welcome by the hostess. I mentioned that we had a reservation & gave her our name. I also mentioned that we had requested a booth since she gave no clue that she was aware of it. I ordered the pecan crusted trout & my husband had the shrimp & lobster stuffed cod. Both came with delicious mashed redskin potatoes, one with green beans & the other with grilled asparagus. My husband also had a cup of the seafood chowder. All of the food was very good. When I made the reservation I had noted that it was my husband's birthday. Our waitress had left the dessert menu & said nothing. When she returned to take our dessert order, I mentioned the occasion & she seemed surprised, then explained that anything up to $6.50 was complimentary. Over that, we'd be credited the $6.50. We shared a massive slice of carrot cake & enjoyed the evening. The following morning I received an email from Open Table requesting an explanation for our "No Show" the evening before. This confirmed my impression that the hostess/waitress was unaware of our reservation, initially, & did not look for it later to confirm our arrival or any special requests. I don't know the details of the system, but something is clearly missing in terms of Mitchell's awareness/follow-through of Open Table reservations.
great food and great service. Decided to go here for devour Indy. It did not disappoint.
The food was fantastic, the service was a bit on the slow side. My 8 oz filet felt like it was only 6 oz.
The food was really sweet. Ordered the bourbon salmon and it basically tasted like a dessert. Was hoping for more of a smoky bourbon flavor. Friend ordered seared scallops but they came out like they were broiled and were extremely overcooked. The only redeeming part of our actual meal were the fresh oysters and kale salad. Service was wonderful at least
Trying it out during Devour Indy
Not worth the drive from downtown Indianapolis.
Appetizer was barely warm. Super slow service and food delivery - even the manager came over to apologize yet nothing was done outside of this to compensate for the length of time we waited. There will not be a return trip in our future.
Great service and food
All was good
Been here many times but it has been a couple of years....was looking forward to a change of pace from our usual dinner places but left disappointed. My scallops were dry and tough, my husbands salmon was mealy in texture. The server never did ask us how our food was....just if we wanted dessert. Very expensive and poor quality. Will have to go somewhere else for seafood.
Food was great. Service was good
The mussels were the best I’ve had in this area in years!
Great time for New Years Eve. Food was awesome and the service was on point.
Great service food was delicious
Our service was terrible. All of the tables around us were seated after us but were served first.
Long delays on checking on us. No refills on water. The manager even came over to say our food would be out in 30seconds and it ended up being 15 more minutes. The food ended up coming out all at different time and was cold. Extremely disappointing especially after seeing what we paid.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 848-3474.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel is rated 4.2 stars by 2403 OpenTable diners.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.