Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel

4.1
icon/ic_reviewCreated with Sketch.
2348 Reviews
icon/ic_price_rangeCreated with Sketch.
$30 and under
icon/ic_cuisineCreated with Sketch.
Seafood
Welcome to Mitchell’s Fish Market, located at Clay Terrace in Carmel, just 15 miles north of downtown Indianapolis. Our chef inspired menu includes items such as Cedar Roasted Atlantic Salmon & Shang Hai Sea Bass, Sam Adams Beer battered favorites and more. Come experience what an obsession with freshness tastes like at Mitchell's Fish Market...fish any fresher would still be in the ocean! View of menus online at MitchellsFishMarket.com!
avatar copy

Private Dining

Book your next event with us

View details
What 2348 People Are Saying
Overall ratings and reviews
Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant
4.1based on recent ratings
4.2
food
4.0
service
4.1
ambience
3.8
value
Noise · Quiet
78% of people would recommend it to a friend
Sort by
Filters
b
Indiana
1 review
Dined 2 days ago
Overall2food1service1ambience4

4 people came to our table stating they were there until our server came around. By the end of the dinner we still weren't sure who our server was. There was only about 5 tables sat in the restaurant at the time. The salmon and chicken came out dry and on the same plate because a server wrote it up as one dish even though it was two different people ordering. We are Landry Select members and were never asked if we were, points not added to our account for our visit and Landry's states it can't be added after. Don't care about the points but a $200 meal for 3 adults and two kids, was definitely not worth the price.

WM
Indiana
47 reviews
Dined 6 days ago
Overall3food3service3ambience4

We've been to Mitchell's many times since it opened in Clay Terrace. Unfortunately our experience this time was disappointing. Two of our orders were wrong which our server corrected. My husband got the stuffed flounder and the fish portion was smaller than the size of a playing card. The vegetables on my plate were cold. I got the fish trio and the salmon tasted like it had gone bad. I let our server know and the manager came by and apologized. We were celebrating two birthdays and we received 2 complimentary desserts which was nice. I hope they were just having a bad day and this is not a trend. There are so few seafood restaurants in Carmel and our prior experiences at Mitchells have been so much better.

C
Chicago
1 review
Dined 6 days ago
Overall1food1service2ambience1

The service was just okay. The bartender did not know how to make a dirty martini! I found this a little shocking when they have a full service bar.

KC
Chicago
18 reviews
Dined on November 23, 2019
Overall4food4service4ambience3

The food was wonderful and the service was very good....the restaurant was a bit chilly.

S
Indiana
7 reviews
Dined on November 16, 2019
Overall4food3service3ambience4

I had the Shang Hai sampler; 3 scallops of which 2 were over cooked. 3 shrimp, which were chewy and seemed old. The salmon was good, but every once in awhile got a musty taste. Not sure what that was. Husband had the crab stuffed flounder, said it was very good. Could have had a few more potatoes with it, and a few more asparagus spears. He also had a wedge salad, with blue cheese dressing. Needed salt. Calamari was good. Recommend more ponzu sauce with it. Service started off good, but then dropped just a bit. Overall, good place. Won't stop us from going again. Will make sure I order something else.

g
Indiana
8 reviews
Dined on November 15, 2019
Overall4food3service4ambience4

The food wasn't as up to par as usual. Disappointing.

s
Indiana
5 reviews
Dined on November 8, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

Good food and ambience

OT
Indiana
36 reviews
Dined on November 5, 2019
Overall3food3service5ambience4

We ordered from the Landry Select Club menu. The beef was over cooked and the potatoes were not hot. The wine was excellent, 14 Hands.

RK
Indiana
22 reviews
Dined on November 1, 2019
Overall4food4service5ambience4

We had a wonderful dinner even when my wife was not pleased with her cut of swordfish as it was kind of thin the chef came out spoke with her and within 10 minutes had a thicker cut thy was excellent!
Very good service and we would definitely return!

SM
Phoenix
6 reviews
Dined on November 1, 2019
Overall4food4service4ambience4

We always enjoy our meal at Mitchells. The server was very pleasant and helpful.

WB
Indiana
23 reviews
Dined on October 31, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

Another great experience. Excellent service and food quality,

OT
1 review
Dined on October 26, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

It was so wonderful experience. The waiters where very helpful. I’m very happy to return in the near future

OT
Hong Kong
4 reviews
Dined on October 19, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience4

Great meal, superb food and great service.

AV
Indiana
7 reviews
Dined on October 17, 2019
Overall2food2service3ambience3

Server was not knowledgeable about menu items.
Food was overpriced.
The crab stuffed flounder was gooey and flavorless.
Won’t be back sadly
When we were greeted we were asked about the Birthday and our party.
Our waiter assumed no dessert and just delivered our bill.

M
Indiana
2 reviews
Dined on October 16, 2019
Overall5food5service4ambience4

Food was great and so was the service. Great place to eat and we will return!

CW
Indiana
1 review
Dined on October 12, 2019
Overall3food3service4ambience4

Wife’s fish was served raw incorrect change was given

OT
Indiana
1 review
Dined on October 6, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

It was a great experience the wait staff was awesome the food was great the prices were very reasonable a great place to take a first date or a romantic date night with your significant other

P
Naples
24 reviews
Dined on October 6, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

We had a great experience with our friends.

OT
1 review
Dined on October 5, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

Brittany was a amazing waitress & made sure we were very well taken care of!

p
Indiana
6 reviews
Dined on October 5, 2019
Overall3food3service3ambience3

My husband and I always enjoy dining at Mitchell's. We have sat outside the last 2 times we've eaten there and experienced a lot of waiters/waitresses at our table. We had 4 this time. It's really hard to know who the main server is. I'm not sure if it's an outside thing since we have not experienced that as much when dining inside the restaurant.

AT
1 review
Dined on October 5, 2019
Overall3food3service4ambience5

mostly the food was really good but my lobster tails were mushy

FS
Indiana
22 reviews
Dined on October 5, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

We had a great time. Dinner was fantastic & so was the service!

M
Indiana
15 reviews
Dined on September 29, 2019
Overall3food3service2ambience3

We've enjoyed Mitchell's the few times we've gone over the years, but we were disappointed this time. It took more than 10 minutes for the hostess to return and take our drink orders, and another almost 10 minutes to get the drinks and have a server approach us. Yet, the place wasn't very busy. The food took a while and was nowhere up to it's usual high caliber. The server complained a bit about being harried, but many tables were empty. It is definitely not worth the price anymore.

OT
Indiana
2 reviews
Dined on September 28, 2019
Overall2food2service3ambience3

My food was cold. The appetizer came after our soups and salad. Our waiter did not bring butter for the lobster until she was asked. The quality of the food has decreased since we were there last.

JR
Indiana
1 review
Dined on September 28, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

Great atmosphere, service, and food. We will definitely be back!

KM
Indiana
3 reviews
Dined on September 26, 2019
Overall4food3service5ambience4

We had great service and the food was good but I feel like it was over priced for what we received.

OT
San Francisco
5 reviews
Dined on September 21, 2019
Overall1food1service1ambience1

Terrible experience!!! Left the restaurant 15 min after having arrived. I was sit in a dirty table and after 15 min nobody had come to my table. Tried to call the waitress and I was ignored twice.

TC
Indiana
12 reviews
Dined on September 21, 2019
Overall5food5service5ambience5

Great food and service.

OT
Indiana
3 reviews
Dined on September 20, 2019
Overall2food2service3ambience2

Mitchell’s has gone way downhill in the last year or two. It used to be fresh, perfectly cooked seafood, with great service, but now everything is mediocre. The prices are too high for a mediocre experience!

MF
Indiana
32 reviews
Dined on September 15, 2019
Overall4food5service3ambience4

We frequent Mitchell's in Carmel quite a bit and the food is consistently good. The service on Sunday night was slow and it wasn't that busy. Maybe they were light on personnel?? New server? Not sure what the issue was. We will return because we love the food but it's a bit disappointing when the service is not up to their usual standards.

C
Indiana
9 reviews
Dined on September 15, 2019
Overall3food1service1ambience3

Three of us at dinner, all overcooked - way overcooked. Took so long to get a glass of wine, I sent it back (everyone was done eating). When she arrived with the bill she made a point of telling me she had it taken off. I didn't drink it, or even touch it, yes it should be taken off.

IS
Indiana
43 reviews
Dined on September 14, 2019
Overall2food3service1ambience3

We had a large party of 11 for an informal birthday dinner celebration, and although it was not part of my request, we were put into a private room which was quite nice. Unfortunately, the result was more 'out of sight, out of mind' as far as service was concerned. Getting drink orders taken after seating was quite delayed, and then receiving the drinks was even longer. Ordering appetizers then took another delay, and when they came they were wrong. Dinner ordering seemed straightforward but not all of the soup/salad orders were processed such that those who were served and waited for the others to come ended up having soup (gumbo) get cold waiting for the others' orders which didn't come until we had to prompt for them. Lastly, this restaurant is rated as a moderate/high price point, but for my share of the bill (4 people including 2 school aged kids) the total was more than I would have expected for my full family size of 6. The food was good but I would not describe it as fine dining commensurate with the cost. There are several other more affordable and enjoyable options in the Clay Terrace location we will go to before coming to Mitchell's again.

A
Indiana
4 reviews
Dined on September 13, 2019
Overall3food4service5ambience3

Patrick, our server was awesome! The food was very good and served quickly! Only complaint is the quality of the cocktails served. The cosmopolitan tasted like Kool-aid and wasn't chilled at all. They also served it in a margarita glass.

OT
Indiana
3 reviews
Dined on September 12, 2019
Overall3food3service2ambience4

A bit disappointed ... the service would have changed the rating. Ordered lobster bisque soup which was actually excellent, but the wonderful sourdough bread was brought long after the soup was gone at our table. I had the lobster and crab stuffed fish and it was disappointing. The mashed potatoes were very good however. The drinks were excellent, and I had a variety of them :) but the service was really very slow and I don’t know why because there were hardly anyone customers at an early dinner during the week.

Pretty high bill for an experience that really fell a bit short from it’s potential.

M
Indiana
63 reviews
Dined on September 6, 2019
Overall3food2service3ambience3

The sockeye salmon was far from fresh and pretty tough and tasteless. I’d guess it’s been around a while. It was a pretty small fillet too. The cedar plank prep did little to improve the taste. The vegetables (zucchini and peppers) were tasteless and in very small in size. In the past these had been served up in ample portions with the grilled Tuscan treatment and were quite good.

The Managers’ presence was seen and felt, but they probably need someone to watch over the food selection and prep more closely. My glass of wine (Meomi Pinot Noir) was quite good.

No complaints on my wife’s fried shrimp dish.

SR
1 review
Dined on September 3, 2019
Overall1food2service1ambience3

We went in for my fiancé’s birthday dinner as we had been there before and it was pretty good. It was dead Server was great at first with our little one then suddenly disappeared. She came back 20 mins after we had placed our orders and asked what we ordered as if she was just checking. 40 minutes after that we STILL had not received our order. We let the manager know and she went into the kitchen. The server came out all frazzled with no explanation other than she was sorry. He manager then came over with a huge lie about how a 9 top came into the bar and their order got put in before ours. Our food came out and our toddler had had it with waiting ( she also promised his food out first which took 40 minutes.) While we were walking out we asked the manager who just happened to be standing at the door with no apology where this 9 top at the bar was, as it appeared empty, and she CONTINUED to lie saying they were in a private room. It wouldn’t have been so bad if they would just h e been honest instead of lying... and they couldn’t even keep that straight! Never again!

S
Indiana
19 reviews
Dined on September 1, 2019
Overall4food3service3ambience5

I have been to Mitchell's 6 or so times and always received an excellent meal and excellent service. The fish is typically fresh and their service has been consistently timely and elegant. That is why my overall rating is 4 stars instead of 2 or 3. My meal, lobster & shrimp stuffed cod, was very average. The cod should have been light and flaky, but was hard to cut. It seemed like a frozen pre-prepared dish that had been microwaved. Moreover, the service was exceptionally slow. Our server was great - one of the best I have ever had there, but we waited too long for our salad, then we waited too long for our main course, then we waited too long for our dessert. Hopefully, our experience was the exception. Maybe they were short handed for the holiday weekend, but clearly there is room for improvement.

JL
Indiana
1 review
Dined on September 1, 2019
Overall3food4service3ambience4

This was our first time to eat at this restaurant. It was Sunday evening and they were not very busy. The waitress was friendly and attentive but it took 1.5 hours for us to complete our meal because the food arrival was so slow. We thought by going during a time they were less busy we could get in and out faster but, unfortunately, it took much more time than we wanted.

KL
Indiana
1 review
Dined on August 31, 2019
Overall5food5service3ambience4

The food was very good, and greeters were very nice and professional

JC
Indiana
17 reviews
Dined on August 31, 2019
Overall5food5service4ambience4

Very nice atmosphere. The service was excellent and the food was appetizing.