Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel
Book your next event with us
Service was a little slow Saturday night, but they were quite busy so I can understand that. Food was delicious as always.
Our daughter treated us to dinner after we helped her pay off a big student loan debt. She was very appreciative and took us to one of our favorite places. We’ll be back!
I typically love this place. But the apple has was not good. I also have a club card. I coordinated a business meeting but they said I could not use my club card if the credit card was not mine being used. That seemed silly.
Normally good service and food but this time our meal took way too long to get to us!! Excuse was a large group that ordered before us....not a good excuse at all. Our server did not keep us informed of what was going on...manager apologized and comped our food but it was not a good experience. As I said, not our normal from Mitchell’s!
As always, the food was very good. Service and overall dining experience was good. Mitchell's is definitely one of my favorite dining places.
Food returned because not cooked properly the first time.
The shrimp and scallops were a bit overdone. The salmon was nicely cooked....
We felt crowded in the dining room with another table too close.....
Waiter was not well versed in the food selection....
Food was tasty enough, but far too expensive given the amount of food for me to feel justified in returning.
Great selection of food and drinks! Food was wonderful and they did a great job accommodating special requests. Will definitely be back soon!
Food was good but pretty salty
Lauren was a great server and added to the overall experience. We came for the Lobster bisque which was excellent as usual. Thanks!
We had very good service; were seated in an area with only 2 other tables occupied so we were able to hear and converse easily; the food was delicious! Thank you.
We had excellent service good food. Very friendly welcome when we arrived and a fun informative server
We have been there about 4 times in total and this visit was one of the best. Our server was very attentive, the food was good! I would go again and I would recommend it. Expect 50+ per person for a meal and a drink or two, but the portions are enough to satisfy and there are enough choices on the menu to find something you like.
Food was good and seafood was fresh. The mussels were very delicious and I dipped the rest of the wine sauce with bread. My main entree was the crab stuffed cod. The cod was very good but the crab stuffing was okay. The dish was paired with 3 asparagus and mesh potato. The asparagus were over cooked, and it’s also very big. The presentation was lacking also.
I also had the featured Manhattan cocktail on the rock. It was nice and smooth. But the old fashioned that my husband got was just so so.
Service was nice and the server was very professional. He took care of us along the way.
Late Valentine date
Love this place...visit everytime I am in town. Wish there was one in Northwest Indiana...Live in Crown Point and we could use a Mitchells here..
Great service and perfect table.
Meal wasn’t prepared as ordered.
Service was a bit inconsistent. Drink orders were wrong and I think the server was fairly new. No big deal.
We were dining for Valentine’s Day. Our server, Terry, was great.
Shrimp cocktail was delicious and my entree was very good. My wife’s filet was extremely tough but the manager quickly got her a new one that she really enjoyed. Nice dining experience
Great food. Valentine’s Day was very crowded so service was slow, usually not
Lauren our server took care of us. Fod was awesomr
The place wasn't too busy but the service was very very slow. It took more than 45 minutes for our main food to be delivered.
Once again disappointed with the service. Having to ask for bread for example, or better yet, the server coming to the table to close out the check with his coat on so he could go home.
We were celebrating a 70th birthday and it was not special at all. I could have spent $300 anywhere.....
This is the second time in a couple of years we have had lousy service (out of 3). We won’t be back and we will tell people there are much better seafood restaurants in our area and not to go there.
When the birthday “girl” says we should have gone somewhere else, and was correct.........that is not good-they gave us a rookie server, they were aware of the birthday-and basically failed. No more.....
The Bourbon Salmon is amazing! Service was good, but I’ve experienced better at Mitchell’s. But the food is so good I will continue to dine.
Delicious food, great date night, large table near by too loud.
Service was great, food was great! First time here and we will be back. Took advantage of Devour Indy and it will pay off for Mitchell’s with more visits p
Have been a loyal customer
They have now dropped their Ginger crusted Salmon
The waitress was clueless why? The Chef Joe cam over and said there is not much he can do- but-if we call ahead he will try to make it
Seems to me this was poor management
We will not be back for awhile unless they put it back on the menu
National management needs to hear the locals
Great service, food was ok. There were other things on the menu that I would like to try. Will likely go back.
Good overall restaurant, will be back again. It was a little cold setting next to the door.
Mitchell's is a special event place for us, and it never disappoints. The attention to fresh and quality ingredients is professional and the recipes are well thought out. The menu is faithful to their name "fish market," so don't bring your steak and potatoes only crowd. Open your eyes and palates. The high quality about balances the moderate serving size, so we were plenty full, but didn't salvage any to take home for later.
Service was extremely slow and there weren’t many diners in the restaurant. Soups and salads were good, entrees and sides just ok.
Had a great experience at the bar before dinner. Friendly bartenders and great service serving wonderful cocktails. Our dinner experience on the other hand was not good. Neither of our meals were hot and were under seasoned. One of the meals made especially for my dinner guest was inconsistent. It was supposed to be two vegetarian tacos with an avocado salsa verde. One has the salsa and the didn’t.
We sat in the bar at a booth. It took 10+ minutes for the server to come greet our table and take our drink orders. Even after repeatedly asking for water refills (in addition to wine), we never got it. Dessert took 30 minutes after our meal and we were told it was due to the kitchen being backed up, but it was cold. Very disappointed, as this place is normally great.
Food very good， service great- we enjoy dinner here