Mitchell's Fish Market private rooms are available for any occasion! Work one-on-one with your Private Event Manager to create a truly customized affair. To host your event in one of our private dining rooms, contact us today!View Private Dining Details
I think their menu of their desserts need adjusting.Having just the same three desserts over and over and over again is very un creative. Otherwise the menu is very good and the special was special. The tables are pushed together too much so that when the waiter is talking to adjacent table , it becomes too noisy at our table. We miss the manager named Patrick.
But we bring in a group once a year in addition to how many times we go. But get on with better desserts!
St Patty’s day dinner. On time, not swamped, Food delicious... wine a bit pricey. Enjoyable evening.
It was fine. Good food. A little pricey.
We had a great meal & as always, Michelle took very good care of us.
Love that they take reservations on Fridays. As always, perfect shrimp cocktail and everyone's meals were delicious and service was spot on.
Fantastic food, fantastic service.
the meal was fine but we thought it was overpriced. There are much better values out there for a good fish dinner.
Food was great, service was outstanding. Thanks Sara!!
Service was great! The food was ok not sure it was worth the price we paid
There's nothing new here. This is a consistent performer providing high quality menu items with great service. Management is experienced and 'gets it' .. meaning that their hiring and training practices speak for the quality of staffing. On the Friday night visit we had this restaurant was mobbed and service was spot on perfect. But that wasn't just for our server - you could see it and tell that this was a finely tuned machine of staff and mgmt working together, playing off one another, helping one another service customers. And that's what most restaurants don't get - service is the name of the game - you can have missteps in quality but never in service. Good job Mitchells.
it's been awhile since we've been to Mitchell's. The place used to feel like you were eating in a cafeteria - large and plain. The food used to be average. On a whim we went back and were delighted to see the place full, the dining area more cozy, and the food outstanding. We both had the battered cod fish fry and we instantly agreed to put MItchell's in the top three fish fry destinations on the west side. The cod arrived hot, crispy, and tasty. The serving size was ample, and I have a good appetite. Fries and slaw both good. Service was excellent, even though the dining room was nearly full. I will return for the fish fry, but also want to come back and try their other offerings.
Crab cakes were excellent. Service was very prompt. Comfortable atmosphere.
Lunch was great and our service was excellent! I will be back.
Enjoyable get-together on a Friday! Excellent value, service and good food. The Cesar salad was DRENCHED in dressing, but crab cake was incredible!! Highly recommend Mitchell's but get the dressing 'on the side'!
Great restaurant for business lunches or personal dinners. Food and service area always great.
Love the lobster bisque. It's a must have for both of us.
Had a wonderful meal! The lobster bisque is a must. Nice seating. Great ambience. Would definitely recommend.
I was most impressed with the service! I made the reservation with his app and noted the occasion (birthday) and time constraint (hour lunch).
The menus were printed with a happy birthday message! Very nice touch! Our waitress was very thoughtful when it came to timing. She mentioned it right away and was prompt with the check. We never had to wait for her or ask for anything. She was perfect! And STILL brought out a birthday treat.
10/10 for service.
As far as food goes the oysters were overpriced. Presentation, taste, and dressings were eh. Lobster bisque was AMAZEBALLS!
I think the venue is a little overpriced for quality of food. The food was quite good, but overpriced. It didn’t blow me away. But service is outstanding.
Great seafood restaurant!! We were in Milwaukee for a sports tournament and selected Mitchell's as it was close to our hotel. The restaurant has a great feel... upscale food but casual. I had chicken, my husband had fish and our son had steak. We each really enjoyed our meals. The lobster bisque soup was one of the best I have had.
Wish we had a Mitchell's close to us in Illinois. Would be our "Go To" restaurant for great food and wide selection.
Overall we were very satisfied with our experience and the food was great. I also liked that they offered non alcoholic specialty drinks. My only complaint is that the waitstaff tries the hard sell on everything - wine, dessert, their rewards program. It got a little annoying at the end. We just wanted to enjoy our dinner and not get sold on something new every 15 minutes.
This is an extremely nice restaurant.. the service & food were amazing! My family and I will definitely be back again. Highly Recommend!!
Good menu and very good quality
The staff was excellent , the food is very good and the warmth of the food was excellent. We enjoyed the drinks and the dessert was on the restaurant for our anniversary. We plan on going back
We were seated in the bar area and I thought that was odd. There were plenty of 4 tops available in the dining area. It wasn’t worth complaining.
Has a reservation and was seated on time with no wait. Server was Adam and he was good. The crab dip and the crispy calamari was good starters. Meals included Filet & Shrim Scampi and the filet was cooked to order, The Cedar plank salmon was good and the crabs cakes were tasty. Sea Scallops were plenty and the lobster tails were on point nice and tender. The Moscato Sangria was very good. Overall had a great experience.
All of our meals were delicious and prepared as ordered. Our service was very good as well. I had the salmon balsamic Ann's it was nude and tender
Party of 3 and we all enjoyed our entrees. Good wine selection. My go to place for seafood.
Great overall experience and value. It was the perfect venue for my wife's birthday dinner out on Valentine's Day!
It was a very busy night being Valentines Day, but our server handled it well and did a great job!
We first had a drink at the bar before our dinner reservation. All bartenders were helpful and very pleasant. Waited on immediately. Food and service was awesome!!!
Awesome experience. Our waitress Michelle was awesome. Very attentive and helpful! I would definitely go again!
Wonderful evening - every meal was perfect and the service impeccable. Couldn’t have had a more lovely experience.
Very good food and atmosphere. Raven was a great server. The Sharkfin dessert was the coolest/best!
The best Fish & Chips ever, according to my husband and son-in-law! My daughter loved her twin lobster tails and my chicken parmesan was excellent!
The service was incredibly slow. I had the crab legs which were the worst crab legs I have ever had.
My husband and I dined here the day after my birthday. I had made a reservation elsewhere but discovered that I made it for the wrong day :( My bad. Fortunately we knew that Mitchell's was nearby and happened to have a table for 2. I had a really excellent scallop dish, my husband a seafood platter. And our server brought a generous birthday treat, which my husband and I split 90-10 :) Always quick service, whether for lunch or dinner.
Waitress Sara was excellent. Food was very good and the suggested bottle of wine was very delicious! Excellent experience!
As always we had great service from our favorite server, Michelle. She has been recommending dishes for me to get me out of my rut. That really helps me broaden my horizons. Brandon, the manager, explained what I was eating & how each ingratiate was made. I really am learning a lot.
This was our first time at the restaurant. The staff was very welcoming and when we had to adjust our reservation time, they were more than understanding. When we arrived they remembered the change of time and seated us right away. This made our experience very personal and enjoyable from beginning to end. The food was very good. I ordered a basic meal (fish 'n chips, type food), while my wife had the special for that day. There was no rush, but the drinks and food came in a timely fashion. Definitely a good choice for good food and available dinning. I also noted that there were some fairly large groups, which would make this a good option for larger families or groups of friends.