Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield
Book your next event with us
Enjoyed outside dining with friends. It was a beautiful evening and the food and service was wonderful. The bisque is amazing and must-try for anyone!
Susan always does a great job! Food was delicious also!
Husbands Birthday! Penny was great as usual! She even knew we would be ordering a bottle of wine with our lunch and had our wine glasses already for us!
Family dinner date night.
Always good seafood prepared perfectly
You can not go wrong with the walleye. We loved the way they just very lightly cooked the green beans.
Great experience as usual.
Anniversary for friends
The food is always wonderful. We had great service, and it was not very busy for lunch. I highly recommend Mitchell's.
Great staff! Great Food! Love eating out on the Patio!
I always have wonderful service at Mitchell's. The food is fresh and full of flavor.
I order blackened fish taco and personal I think the blackened fish I made at home was better. Not blackened or spicy at all.
Very friendly employees and great food! We love sitting out on the patio on a warm day!
It was a great lunch place. I recommend to anyone
At the risk of sounding like a foodie, the food while good just never hits the high notes. The clam chowder was interesting yet missing some of the traditional ingredients. My wife’s salmon was a large piece of fish but tasted a little fishy
This is my second time dining at this place and everything was exceptional. They made my husband birthday a night to remember. They even personalized the menu for us. The food was so good! I Love this place.
We always have an excellent experience here. Food is delicious and we always receive great service from Penny. We enjoy eating in the bar area or on the patio.
I ordered the Copper River salmon from the specials menu because it used to be "Copper River" salmon was the good stuff. King salmon you could eat nearly raw. Rich and buttery, melt in your mouth, to die for. That is not what I got. A piece of shoe bottom sockeye that could have been frozen at the dollar store. Over cooked so instead of flaking it crumbled. The menu did not list it as sockeye. The bill did, the check did but not the menu or the servers specials description.
The bastardization of our food labeling must stop. Restaurants call "no roll" rib roasts "Prime Rib". Chicken reared in a 40,000 sq ft building "uncaged" is "free range" and don't get me started with "organic".
Our waitress was very nice but what really upset me was no manager made any attempt to correct the situation. I was calm and rational and even comical about it A great chance for a "win" rather than hiding in the back of the house. My wife's dinner was fine as have all the other meals I've had hear over the last decade. Why the deception? Why the fear to interact with those that make your paycheck possible? This wasn't a swing and a miss...you hid in the dugout.
Waited and waited in the bar. Finally asked for a bartender. Seems unusual......also the new menu is not a favorite, too casual for this special seafood restaurant.
Overall a nice experience. Tasty food entrees, and wonderful warm baked bread. I would return to try additional menu items.
We all had a great time!! Delicious meal & great service!!
We had good food from seemed like an updated and revised menu. Nice atmosphere and our dinner was enjoyable.
Tried the Wahoo as it was one of the server’s recommendations. It was a great choice if you like a firmer fish. We all enjoyed our food and the server was fun and attentive.
I had the rainbow trout and it was cooked perfectly. Everything else was great including the bread.
Good food, but not great. Pricey. Our server was very friendly and helpful.
We had a wonderful meal at Mitchell's Fish market. Our food was delicious, service was great. Great value.
Patio dining was very comfortable
FANTASTIC FOOD. So fresh and flavorful
Always great service! Food is top quality and cooked to order.
Food was good. Had the Calamari, Lobster bisque, Lobster stuffed cod and Crab stuffed Flounder. It was our Anniversary with a personalized menu and a free creme brulle. Nice for a special meal. Waiter was very attentive and nice.
It’s good. Not great, but good. Ordered the wahoo and sadly it was over cooked a bit making it dry. Bacon wrapped bbq shrimp appetizer was the star of the night.
all good...I do not have time to write a 50 charvter response..........
After a lot of research over the years we count Mitchell's fish fry as one of the very best on the west side of the metro area that includes Waukesha county. And that's in addition to a very nice menu of other fish and seafood.
I usually love Mitchell’s but on this occasion, Mother’s Day they must have been understaffed- the shrimp cocktail tasted like it was just thawed and rubbery- they brought me the wrong dinner which my family insisted I just keep since we waited 30 min just for drinks and they knew if I sent it back I would be eating alone!
Despite it being a very busy Mother’s Day, our server Bridget explained the menu in detail to our table. She was charming and very attentive. Our meal arrived promptly and was delicious! Our mothers were very impressed with the service, food and cleanliness of the restaurant.
Friendly staff with great service. All of our meals were excellent!
On Mother's Day we experienced great service and a great meal enjoyed by all. Our food was fresh and hot when served. Service was prompt and pleasant. We will visit Mitchell's Fish Market again.
The restaurant was busy I’ll give them that. Our server forgot about us for about 35-40 minutes. Food came out cold. Manager had to keep interrupting dinner to grab wine from behind us. Bathrooms (women’s) were disgusting. Then to top it of the manager charged someone else’s card for our dinner. We got free desert out of the deal, but I will not be going back here. Terrible Mothers Day experience.