Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Lobster Cod Oscar
Fresh lobster meat, hollandaise, mushroom & potato hash
Maine Lobster Bisque
Sea scallops, cajun shrimp, spinach, mushrooms, shellfish cream sauce over roasted redskins
Couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Great cocktail and wine list. Superb menu ... all very fresh. Will be back for sure.
Excellent server. Food was very good. Great 50th Birthday celebration.
We love this restaurant and took my daughter there for her 35th birthday. Overall everything was good.
I do have two small complaints. Even though I noted on my reservation that it was a birthday celebration, nothing was done to acknowledge it. In the past a complementary dessert with a birthday candle was provided.
My two grandchildren also came and we ordered off the children's menu. I was shocked to see they were served Kraft macaroni and cheese and charged $8 for what was half a box serving with a cost of $.75 max.
Absolutely phenomenal food and drinks. I can’t wait to go back
Our server was spectacular. She had our drinks and explained some items on the menu for us. The salads were fantastic and brought out soon after we were able to have a bit of our drinks and bread. As soon as our salads were finished the entrees came hot and very appealing to the eye. We both had salmon and it was cooked to perfection. Our server checked on us periodically with a smile and showed she cared about our experience. We were able to have dessert since we had a deal of salad and dessert for $10. The desserts were sooooo good. Not your run of the mill cheesecake and key lime pie.
The whole experience was excellent. It was our first time to Mitchell's, and we will be sure to come again and let our friends know.
Food and service was good. It’s a great location for a nicer meal.
Took our daughter home from College for dinner. Food was amazing. No concerns with how We where spaced out for COVID as well.
My only complaint was the oyster bar is no going on and that was the #1 reason I went there. It is partly my fault for not calling but I do feel it should be made clear in their web page but it is not. Other than that it was a good meal.
Enjoyed our New Year’s Eve meal, great scallops and calamari!! Our waitress was nice, attentive, not hovering!!
New Year’s Eve dinner. Service and Food was outstanding as usual. The team at Mitchell’s is always GREAT.
Every time I come here, I am impressed with the food and service. They are consistent and treat all diners so well.
As usual, we had a great experience at Mitchell's Fish Market. A good variety of food and always taste great. After our luncheon we stopped at the bar to visit with Penny, the bartender, and had a nice glass of Port. We will be back often.
Ryan was our server - excellent service and personality
King crab legs were about the size of snow crab if not smaller. Everything was luke warm at best.
Great food, and we had a really nice server. Its a really great place for a xmas dinner
Even though the manager bought us dessert. My steak went back because it was raw not medium rare. Lobster went back twice. Raw and cold the first time and not cooked through the second time. Service was good and the calamari app was great.
Our food was delicious. Our waitress was very accommodating. She came back to check on us but didn’t rush us which we really appreciated
We went for the 2 Lobster Tails for $25 Tuesday deal and were very favorably impressed!
The value was fantastic, given the quality of the food and drink! I highly recommend Mitchell's and the deal!
Fish was severely undercooked. Sent it back and waitress was apologetic but there were few diners and kitchen should not have been rushed.
Rather expensive for the quality of the food served. Most dishes were bland.
This was our first time eating at Mitchell's Fish Market. It was outstanding, we had Chilean Sea Bass, a crab cake & shrimp. Drinks were very good, staff was great & helpful when we had questions about the menu items. We will soon return to enjoy again. The bar looked wonderful & inviting, but we did not have a drink there. And for those who are concerned, social distancing was very good.
We like this restaurant but really hope they will put their shark fin pie dessert back on the menu.
This is hard for me because I took a chance on a seared grouper. I asked a lot of questions and was assured that the fish was cooked all the way through with this method. That didn't turn out to be the case. I would have been able to live with that if the fish hadn't been cold in the middle. By cold I mean that, while it was not frozen hard, it was about that cold.
We sent the remaining fish back to be cooked through. The chef did warm it up for us but the whole experience was disappointing since I specifically asked about it not being thoroughly cooked. You pay too much at this restaurant for a basic issue like this to be a problem.
Great service.Food was very good
if it was about half the price.Never gave a discount for happy hour items either.We are Landrys members..have always had a manager check on us..didnt happen here.Very good..but $108 is too much for this restaurant
Their lobster bisque although still quite tasty has thinned out somewhat. They also need to add the remoulade sauce back to the crab cake, which was pretty tasteless.
The food was outstanding. The atmosphere was very pleasant. Our waitress was great.
Our server Raven was terrific & the food was great as usual!!
One of our favorites!
Very Covid friendly and tables were distanced. Awesome service and food was excellent.
Another very good meal as we have always experienced. Appreciate the attention to safe dining protocols for your customers.
Nice meal and friendly service. Was a little slow getting our check, but otherwise was a good meal.
Great Lobster & Shrimp Stuffed Cod seafood month meal special was large enough for both of us.
Celebrated birthday, sweetest day and job promotion. Service and food was excellent.
Great food and good service. Nice date night out
Had reservations and we were seated immediately. Lobster bisque and clam chowder were both good and flavorful perhaps a little thin. Wedge salad with egg, blue cheese crumbles and dressing also good. Scallops cooked well, served on two spears were good but have had better. Cedar plank tilapia with goat cheese and sun dried tomatoes different - but also good. Market platter was OK, crab cakes nothing to write home about. Cheesecake worth splitting. Good selection of wine and cocktails. Service was attentive and gave us time as we were not in a hurry. Somewhat pricy, but overall a good experience.
Our experience was absolutely great. Great food great service
Everything was great good food and great staff
The staff is great and the food was delicious as usual
Great food and good service overall.
Went there for a nice meal with my wife and was overall very happy with our experience. The waitstaff was nice, all the food was very good except that my cod was just slightly over-cooked. The calamari was very tender and not at all rubbery as it often turns out in the midwest ;) . I would recommend them.
Great food, great service, great atmosphere, great selections, great prices……well worth dining here. I will be back.
You can order delivery directly from Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield using the Order Online button. Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (262) 789-2426.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield is rated 4.5 stars by 1976 OpenTable diners.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Brookfield does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.