Mill Creek Tavern
Lots of great choices on the menu. Excellent attentive service.
Nice restaurant, great food, we were lost by the staff after being seated for a few minutes. Terrific food once served. The manager was apologetic without prompting. I would recommend to a friend.
We live about 15 miles from thr Mill Creek and we made a special effort to go because it’s so great. The food and service is excellent. We are always recommending it to people.
very disappointed this visit food was no more than avg baked potato cold chicken pot pie very watered down long wait after ordering
Lots of options for a family of selective eaters. Nice drink menu. Helpful wait staff and ambiance.
Thank you so much -Jimmy
Dining out on a Friday, especially during restaurant week can be challenging but this was a very enjoyable dining experience.
Great food, service was very accommodating & ample portions. Also good choices on the menu.
Definitely going back, even w/out restaurant week.
Thank you so much for this terrific detailed five star review. -Jimmy
One of our favorite restaurants, varied menu, updated wine list, highly recommended.
Thank you so much for the five stars! We love you. -Jimmy
overall very good - our hostess was odd she asked us if we'd like to wait for a booth. We waited at the bar, when our friends arrived we told her we were ready and we had to wait 15 minutes longer because she claimed she had told us the table was ready 15 minutes ago with a tone. She was a turn off
Thank you for the honest review. I am sorry about the hostess situation, we will have a talk with them. Thank you for still rating us four stars. -Jimmy
I love this restaurant and have never had less than a five-star experience. The only fault is it’s a long drive but I still keep it as one of my favorites and the place to go with friends and family.
Thank you so much Jane for the fantastic review and the kind words! We love you too. -Jimmy
Wonderful food, sweet hostess and waitresses. The manager was attentive and patient. Even though the restaurant was full, it was quiet, nice glass panels between the booths really were nice.
Thank you so much for the terrific review! -Jimmy
Nice neighborhood restaurant with good food and great service and reasonable prices.
Thank you so much for this great review! Jimmy
The food was excellent, the service was outstanding and the staff were very friendly. The owner came over to our table and introduced himself and asked us how everything was. This is probably a hidden gem in the Bayville and surrounding area. Very “down to earth” and unpretentious. I travel a lot and eat in many many restaurants all over the country and the world. I highly recommend The Mill Creek Tavern.
Thank you so much Bob for the great review, kind words, and compliments! Hope to see you soon -Jimmy
The food is always delicious and the service is impeccable!
Thank you so much for the kind words -Jimmy
Both food and service were outstanding. Would definitely go back again.
Thank you so much for this terrific review, and the kind words. Cheers Jimmy
Everything was great. Service, food, everything.
Mill Creek is our go-to spot. We love Vanessa and the staff. We always feel at home.
I LOVE Mill Creek Tavern! Their food is always delicious, service is always good, and it’s always just an enjoyable time
Great as always
Allison was winderful
This is one of my favorite restaurants. The menu is extensive and everything on it is great. The service is always excellent.
We dined Mill Creek on St. Patrick's Day. My family ordered the specials for the holiday - delicious Corned Beef & Cabbage and loved their Salmon special as well. Bread pudding for dessert was scrumptious.
My mom and I frequent Mill Creek on Sundays and enjoy their 3 course price fix menu which is a bargain at $27.99. My mom gets their muscles every time, she says they are the best she has ever had in her life, she wishes she could just drink the broth, but we both enjoy dunking our bread in it. I love their apricot salmon, it is delicious!
The atmosphere out did the food. Nothing interesting or inspiring on the menu. Had fish tacos which were quite bland and uninteresting. With three others. No one’s meal was well prepared. All entrees boring an relativity flavorless.
Love Mill Creek Tavern, but service was really slow on my last experience.
I hadn't been there for a while, and know I remember why! There's a lot of noise from the bar area, and the food is so so. Linguine with white clams had chopped clams that were so dry. I never experienced that texture is a clam before, and the pasta way overcooked. Strange that there was a lot of garlic in the dish, but absolutely no flavor. Oh well. The service was A+, so there is something to be said for that!
Thank you so much for the review! I am disappointed to hear that you did not enjoy your meal. I have sent you a private note. I hope to hear from you soon. Regards -Jimmy
All of the portions were rather small but the food was good. Excellent service.
Hey Paul. Thanks for the complements and constructive feedback. It is well taken. Have a great day - Rich
Always a pleasure having dinner at Mill Creek Tavern. I have never been disappointed!
Thanks Michele. We look forward to seeing you soon - Rich
as always everything was up to my expectations , a great casual place for good food close to home
Were so please that we lived up to your expectations. look forward to seeing you again soon. With gratitude - Rich
The food was amazing. Atmosphere was lovely. It was such a great evening the staff was friendly and accommodating. Super impressed
Sincerely one happy canadian
Hi Deb. We think that YOU are amazing!!! Cheer's - Rich
The food was delicious! The staff was very friendly and our server took good care of us. We will be back for sure! 😊
Thank. Look forward to welcoming you back - Rich
It has been some time since I updated my review on this terrific location and my family's dinner last Friday gave me the perfect excuse! As usual, we were delighted! All the little details were there.......reservation respected and a lovely table held for us: immediate and courteous attention; food brought quickly and every bit as good as we had hoped; attentive service and perfect ambience (for us........enough "buzz" to provide lovely "energy", but quiet enough for us to talk, laugh and enjoy family time! ). The Mill Creek Tavern continues to be one of Long Island's true "gems"! Great food, great environment at reasonable prices. Indeed, the whole package is a bargain!
Thank you so much for your great reviews and continued loyalty. Look forward to seeing you again soon - Rich
Went to Mill Creek last night for dinner. I was greeted by a hostess rt away. My server Jean was attentive and knowledgeable. The menu was extensive, but I went with a classic hamburger (pic below) it was delicious
Thanks for the great review and thanks for acknowledging Jean. We appreciate it and will let her know. Love those MCT burgers!! - Rich
Great dinner date with my oldest daughter, love the early price fixe!
Thank Travis - Rich
Great dinner. Waitress and owner were wonderful. We waited for our reservation but the owner made right. Will definitely be back!!
Thanks Shari. We try : ) Have a great day Rich
Food is great! Always have a good meal and love the ambience. Servers are friendly and helpful. Saturday was very crowded so service was slower than usual. Handicapped accessible and accommodated my 2 young grandsons. Everyone enjoyed the evening.
Thanks Terese. Hope to see you soon - Rich
Great food. Never disappoints. We will definitely go back again.
Thank you so much. - Rich
Came in for restaurant week. Menu was varied. Service and food were great. Will come again.
Thank you for the five star rating Joyce, I am glad you had the opportunity to participate in Restaurant Week. See you soon. Cheers -Jimmy
Food and service were very good. The food was a little slow out of the kitchen but appreciated our waitress letting us know the kitchen was backed up. Will definitely return
Thank you Martha for the four star review! I am glad you enjoyed the food, and service. I can assure you the kitchen being slow was a isolated incident. See you soon. Cheers -Jimmy
We have been here a few time before this last visit and have never had a problem. The food is quite good and basically the same menu as their sister and better restaurant "Mims" in Roslyn. Our experience tonight was not that good. We had a 7:15 reservation made on OpenTable with a request for a booth. We arrived on time and checked in with the hostess who told us that it would be just a few minutes for a booth and invited to go to the bar for just a little bit. We ordered a couple of drinks and 15 minutes later I checked back and was told that they were very busy tonight and it would just be a bit longer. At 8pm when we were still not seated I went back to the dinning room and saw the hostess who told me that they were setting up a booth right now. I looked over and saw someone who came in after we did talking to the manager setting up the booth. The hostess then tells us sorry I am going to have to seat you in the back dinning room at a regular table. I told her that was unacceptable and went right to the manager who told me he did not know that the hostess told us that the booth was for us and allowed us to sit there. We ordered our salads which arrived rather slow and realized we only had one place setting. It took a while to grab someone's attention and get another place setting. Then my wife realized they never gave her a napkin. Again we had to track someone down for a napkin. It took a much longer time than usual to get our main course which certainly was not our servers fault. In fact she was very friendly and did her best under the circumstances.shout out to the server with blond hair who is opening up her own Yoga studio. All in all it was not the best experience tonight but the food is always good at Mill Creek. Just wish it was run as well as Mims in Roslyn. We will still go back.
Hi there, I am so sorry to hear about your poor dining experience with us. I can assure you this is a isolated incident. Thank you for bringing this to my attention. With Gratitude Jimmy