Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Mill Creek Tavern
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
¼ BBQ Chicken
Amazing sauerbraten short ribs.
One of our favorite places for dinner. Menu has a little bit of everything and the ambiance is always relaxing but active. This is our go to for a weekly date night
Thank you Paul for taking the time to post -Jimmy
Everything great would go here again trust me it’s amazing
Thank you so much for the kind words, and review. -Jimmy
Amazing as always. Reservation was changed for us, hostess, waitress and food was absolutely amazing for 9 people.
You Rock -Jimmy
Excellent as always!
Thank you so much -Jimmy
Great service, excellent food!
Thank you so much Paul for you rating. -Jimmy
The food was excellent as was the service
Thank you so much Paul -Jimmy
We loved our experience at Mill Creek. Have been there many times and we are never disappointed. The food, service, and atmosphere were wonderful. Our server was very attentive and kind. The bar staff was top notch making a difficult martini for me which was amazing. Thank you to all the staff on working Christmas Eve and making a family dinner a wonderful experience.
Thank you so much for the five star review, and your kind words. We are most grateful. Happy and healthy new years -Jimmy
Really enjoyed the Osso Buco with Risotto which was a special last night. Cooked perfectly in a delicious sauce. That’s why we keep coming back.
Thank you so much for the five star review, and your kind words. Happy and healthy new years -Jimmy
Such a good menu it’s hard to choose! Cozy and never rushed. Very good service team
Thank you so much -Jimmy
The food was excellent, thee service was excellent, our waiter was very attentive and the food was excellent . The fireplace was going and it was just a lovely evening.
Always enjoy eating here. The Orecchiette pasta with blackened shrimp was outstanding. I ordered extra shrimp and couldn’t have been happier with the amount of shrimp they gave and the price. The pumpkin bread pudding dessert was delicious. Overall rating last night was A+++. Will be back soon.
Thanks Jeff for this awesome five star review. Happy holidays -Jimmy
We were seated in the back room with bright lights so we asked to be put in the main dining room. The hostess was very accommodating but the table was very small
And very close to another table behind us. I couldn’t move my chair back. The food wasn’t tasty, I was very disappointed. Waitress was very nice however. Don’t think we’ll be back
I have been going to Mill Creek Tavern for many years. It never disappoints. The food is delicious and staff is attentive. You leave full and satisfied.
Thank you for being a loyal Mill creek guest Tara. We are very grateful for your kind words. Thank you for your support. Cheers -Jimmy
Restaurant was subpar, food was a bit cold and drinks were way too strong.
Thank you Lauren for posting. I am so sorry you did not enjoy your dining experience with us. We hope you give us another shot. Happy holidays -Jimmy
Food was delicious, our waitress was wonderful and it was an all around wonderful experience.
Thank you so much Jill you Rock -Jimmy
Had big expectations for MCT - a bit disappointed.
The menu is very large. Almost like a small dinner. The lobster bisque had only small pieces of lobster, and not a lot of flavor. Onion soup had some bread at the bottom, soapy and and indiscript cheese on top. Broth tasted like it was out of a can, not really fresh.
The parmigiana meatballs that one of our friends had were enjoyed very much.
Pasta with seafood was uneventful. Lots of seafood, but again low on flavor. Double cut pork chop was a good choice and enjoyed.
Skip the Shepard’s pie. Again lacks flavor and just some mashed piped on top. Needed lots of S&P.
Coffee was good. Desert was better then the mains.
Service was very good and reliable. Definitely a local place with a very busy bar. Unfortunately a one and done.
My friend snd I always celebrate our Birthdays @MillCreekTavern
Thank you for your support, and for being a loyal guest. God Bless -Jimmy
There were 4 of us. We all ordered something different and all dishes were delicious. Our waitress, Jean, was great. She was efficient, informative about the menu and funny. We will be back soon to try the rest of the menu.
Thanks Karen. Cheers -Jimmy
Our favorite local spot. Great food! Specials were delicious. Wonderful spot to celebrate a special occasion or any occasion at!
Thanks Lindsay -Jimmy
Great food, lots of choices, and our server Kyle was wonderful. Our first time here, it won't be our last.
Thanks so much for the kind words. Welcome to the family. Cheers -Jimmy
The menu had so many choices. The cocktails were good and our server, Kyle, was so attentive.
Thanks so much :) -Jimmy
Delish food and cozy atomosphere…
Thanks for the kind words. Cheers -Jimmy
Food always good. Our waiter was super friendly. Always happy with Mill Creek
Thank you Angela for taking the time to post and for being a loyal guest. We are most grateful -Jimmy
Good food, service, atmosphere!! Very enjoyable!
Thank you for the kind words Pat -Jimmy
Ordered the goulash, which I expected to be a soup or stew with noodles and the dish I got had no sauce. Seasoning on the noodles tasted like it came out of a packet. I was extremely disappointed.
Cozy atmosphere. Wait staff couldn’t have been nicer. Delicious meal.
Thank you so much :) -Jimmy
Wait Staff was helpful and pleasant. And Vanessa is someone I look forward
to seeing. She is the face of Mill Creek Tavern and you are lucky to have her.
She is always professional and pleasant and helpful.
Great night. Great dinner.
Thank you so much Sharon for this awesome five star review. Yes we are truly blessed, and grateful to have Vanessa on our team, she is a true asset. God Bless Cheers -Jimmy
Great customer service and the dishes were delicious!
Thank you so much -Rich
Good atmosphere and service were all perfection, can’t wait to go back
Thank you so much -Jimmy
Really nice gem of a place, with great atmosphere, service, and food & drink
Thank you for the kind words. Cheers -Rich
The food is so delicious and the staff was very attentive. Will definitely go back. Only wish they had a parking lot.
Thank you Susan -Rich
The servers were friendly and made us feel at home.
So glad you enjoyed your dining experience with us. God bless. -Jimmy
can not go wrong at mill creek from the time you walk in until you leave everything was spectacular
Thank you so much Marcos for the kind words, and five stars. We are most grateful. -Jimmy
We come here often and enjoy the food. Some of the appetizer portions could be bigger than they are but the food is consitently good.
Thank you for posting. -Jimmy
Everything was great, food was delicious, server was really patient and kind, the only thing was, since I work in the restaurant business, I found it a little odd that our server called out my friend for not leaving 20 percent as a tip, some people don’t always have the money to be able to spare, it’s understandable since that is his living, but to mention something about a tip to the customer is a little uncalled for.
Thank you Bert for posting. God Bless -Jimmy
Local and the food is always good.
Thank you for the kind words, and five stars -Jimmy
Mill Creek never disappoints. My cousins were visiting from England and loved the food. This is our ‘go to’ place for any occasion.
Thank you for the kind words, and five stars. Cheers -Jimmy
The waiter was very attentive!! Drinks were great and so was the food!!
Thank you so much for the five stars, and kind words. God Bless -Jimmy
This was a last minute reservation and I am so glad we found Mill Creek Tavern. Food was delicious!! The waitress was a sweetheart.
Thank you for the kind words, we are most grateful -Jimmy
You can order delivery directly from Mill Creek Tavern using the Order Online button. Mill Creek Tavern also offers delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Mill Creek Tavern also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 628-2000.
Mill Creek Tavern is rated 4.7 stars by 673 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.