Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Mill Creek Tavern
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
Beautiful dinner specials, and Ala carte dinner menu
Great customer service and the dishes were delicious!
Thank you so much -Rich
Good atmosphere and service were all perfection, can’t wait to go back
Really nice gem of a place, with great atmosphere, service, and food & drink
Thank you for the kind words. Cheers -Rich
The food is so delicious and the staff was very attentive. Will definitely go back. Only wish they had a parking lot.
Thank you Susan -Rich
The servers were friendly and made us feel at home.
can not go wrong at mill creek from the time you walk in until you leave everything was spectacular
Thank you so much Marcos for the kind words, and five stars. We are most grateful. -Jimmy
We come here often and enjoy the food. Some of the appetizer portions could be bigger than they are but the food is consitently good.
Thank you for posting. -Jimmy
Everything was great, food was delicious, server was really patient and kind, the only thing was, since I work in the restaurant business, I found it a little odd that our server called out my friend for not leaving 20 percent as a tip, some people don’t always have the money to be able to spare, it’s understandable since that is his living, but to mention something about a tip to the customer is a little uncalled for.
Local and the food is always good.
Thank you for the kind words, and five stars -Jimmy
Mill Creek never disappoints. My cousins were visiting from England and loved the food. This is our ‘go to’ place for any occasion.
Thank you for the kind words, and five stars. Cheers -Jimmy
The waiter was very attentive!! Drinks were great and so was the food!!
Thank you so much for the five stars, and kind words. God Bless -Jimmy
This was a last minute reservation and I am so glad we found Mill Creek Tavern. Food was delicious!! The waitress was a sweetheart.
Thank you for the kind words, we are most grateful -Jimmy
Food was average. Service was fine. No complaints. Nothing out of the ordinary. On par with other comparable restaurants.
Food & service very good! Will definitely go back!
Thank you so much for the five stars, God Bless -Jimmy
Fantastic meal and great service as always. This is our go to restaurant. Brought my parents and they thoroughly enjoyed it as well
Food was delicious, but took a long time for it to come out. Had some lobster shells in the special lobster sliders. There was a lot of sauce on the fish tacos. Had to wipe some off but it still tasted good. Enjoy !! Always a good time !
Thank you for posting, and leaving a honest review. We are terribly sorry for the mishap. We hope to see you soon -Jimmy
Server Kyle was awesome, food was well prepared. Three of us enjoyed our dinner and will return.
Thank you for the kind words -Jimmy
Always a great meal with great service.
Thank you for the kind words, and five stars -Jimmy
Kathy is the best Bartender and hilarious. In fact the entire crew is very attentive and sweet. The food is fantastic and highly recommend going with friends.
Great local restaurant. We’ve dined there in the past. Never disappointed. Food is always on point. Great service.Ice cold beer I would definitely recommend.
Thanks Phillip for the kind words. -Jimmy
The place is amazing. great food and outstanding service.
Thank you so much for the kind words. We are most grateful -Jimmy
Brought out wrong side dish drink was with ice that I never use dirty fork not happy dining on our Anniversary
Brought friends who had never bee to MCT. They are foodies and have exceptional taste. They absolutely loved it. Could not stop going on about how delicious the food was. The service with Sue was exceptional. Thank you for another amazing meal!
Thank you so much Marie for this awesome five star review -Jimmy
Food was ok. My side of risotto was a little skimpy, they could give a little more. Music was way too loud. Waitress was amazing (Alexandria).
Thank you for posting Kelly. -Jimmy
Quaint atmosphere with an enjoyable overall dinner experience
Thanks Theresa -Jimmy
Happy Hour at Mill Creek is like walking into an episode of Cheers especially when Kathy is Bartending who is an excellent mixologist and hilarious sweetest person. Highly recommend a dinner the food is fantastic. Thank you to the founders of Mill Creek for bringing this great establishment to Bayville.
This was our first time dining at Mill Creek Tavern. Our son had given us a gift card. The entire experience was excellent. The menu had many different options from steaks to seafood to pasta. The noise level was low. Lighting was perfect. Parking lot was small, but there was plenty of on-street parking. Would definitely come here again.
Awesome neighborhood spot
Thank you for the kind words, and five stars. We are most grateful -Rich
Excellent meal, excellent service…as always!
Thanks Marge. You Rock -Jimmy
Went for my daughter’s birthday. They couldn’t have been more accommodating. We were looking for a local casual fun place and they didn’t disappoint. They had a table last minute and went over and above in every way from helping with difficult parking to touching up my margarita with a drop of simple syrup. My burger was amazing and everyone loved their meal. Thank you so much!
Thank you for the five stars Robert -Jimmy
We are from Queens and our friends that we were meeting for dinner we met for are from Dix Hills. We tried to pick someplace between us and go somewhere different.
I found this place on line and made an open table reservation for the 4 of us for 5pm on Saturday.
When we arrived it was pretty empty as they open at 4:30. We all ordered drinks, appetizers, meals, coffee, tea and cappuccino and 2 deserts.
Everything was really good and our waitress Jean was very attentive, accommodating to our needs and done all with a smile.
We had the baked clams, Kung Pao cauliflower (surprisingly delicious!) and fried calamari as the appetizers. All were excellent.
2 of us had the lemon sole which came with shrimp, mussels, tomatoes, spinach on a bed of angel hair pasta, yummo! One person had the chicken with Granny Smith apples and sweet potato in a Riesling sauce, and one person had sesame encrusted tuna, both were delicious.
For desert we had a key lime pie and a hot brownie with ice cream and mini M&Ms.
We all said we’d definitely go back there again.
And by the time we left the place was packed.
Thank you for the five stars and kind words. We are truly grateful for this amazing review. You Rock
Like to always get table 3 instead of giving it to someone who didn’t have a reservation
Thank you for the five stars
Always top notch dining. Especially love the sea scallops risotto and the friend chicken.
Thank you for the five stars and kind words. We are truly grateful
My waiter/server was Kyle and he was friendly, prompt, and overall excellent!
Thank you Chelsea
Food was very good. Nice selection. Service was fast but too fast. Runner put all the entres and salads on our table, all at once, stacking things up while we were still eating the appetizer. No one cleared the table. Trying to be understanding because I know there's labor shortages but these are easy fixes. But if you're not fussy about the experience the food was very good.
Went specifically for the lobster special: 1 1.5 lb lobster with choice of salad and choice of side
Hope you enjoyed! We will be having the lobster special all summer. Cheers -Jimmy
We Love Mill Creek. Great Service and Ritchie the owner, very personable and runs a Great Place
Thank you so much for the kind words, and five stars. -Jimmy