Milagro Restaurant and Bar

A great little spot with amazing food. if your looking for an appetizer , a piazza or a delicious gourmet meal this is the place

Great Food and great atmosphere. Gets a little busy, make reservations.

We generally use lunch for sandwich style eating but for dinner we like something more and does Milagro fit the bill. It’s a cute place off the highway As we try to be Covid responsible tend eat outdoors but here it’s only indoor dining but the staff wears masks and the tables are socially distant. Started out with a couple craft cocktails I had a brown sugar maple old fashion snd my wife had a mai tai. Both were excellent. Next we tried their meatball appetizer. Five small but tasty meatballs with a tomato salsa. They were different in a good way from an Italian style meatball more like greek meatball in consistency but with the salsa they were completely different.
On to the salad course my wife tried their milagro salad greens vinegarette and blue cheese crumbles. I went with their traditional Caesar salad and both were great. For our main courses I tried their evening special swordfish with a buerre sauce and risotto and my wife went with their yellowtail snapper. My swordfish may have been the best i’ve ever had and the snapper was spot on. Both were great.

Service was spot on! Excellent food! Made another reservation for this weekend. Prime rib is exceptional! Can’t wait to try another menu item.

We love this place!

Love this place. Food and service is amazing. It is not cheap but well worth the money.

We always have a good meal when dinning at Milagros !

Great food and service. Always consistent. We have dined there many times and always very pleased with the quality.

It was closed at the time of our reservation!

Food was delicious and presentation was great. I can’t wait to go back.

I thought the food was delicious. I had the wood fired octopus, I loved the tomato jam with it. I had the blackened fish tacos, also wonderful, with lots of tomatillo, pico and all the flavors. And the bread pudding is the best dessert I’ve had in a long time. I’m still thinking about it. Mmmmmmmm. The place was quiet, romantic, clean and beautiful. I really enjoyed it!

This was a great experience. Our food was excellent and service was great. We will definitely be back!

Excellent food and staff - Very good drinks as well - will definitely go back again

We were there with a dinner group (12-16) from Key Colony last year. We liked it so well we knew we’d be back. It was our anniversary and I knew I wanted to go back. We’ll be back again. The food was outstanding ❤️❤️

The food is consistently good at Milagros . Love the fish specials!!

We love this restaurant and visit frequently from Marathon. The Sazerac and other drinks, wedge salad with blue cheese, hog fish special and crème brûlée made my birthday dinner very special. This is the most consistently delicious restaurant for years now in the keys. This is a hidden gem in Big Pine Key.

Excellent food had the burrito and snapper. Ate there a few times never unhappy.

Hidden treasure. Food was amazing. Definitely try the grilled octopus. I’m not a squid kinda girl but this was amazing! Service a little slow which was fine by me. Want to try the bar menu next.

Best restaurant we went to while staying in the middle Keys! Octopus and shrimp mac and cheese were incredible! Just thinking about it makes my mouth water!

Milagro is a hidden gem in the keys. Food is superior in both presentation and quality.

This is one of the absolute best places to eat in the Keys. A must try Wood Grilled Octopus - exceptional!

Cute great food!

Julio was awesome. So was the food! Loved this place.

The short rib burrito is large enough to share..very tender meat. Hogfish was very tasty also.

Fresh gourmet food, excellent wine choices, wonderful ambiance and great folks. One of if not the best places to have a wonderful dining experience in all of the Florida Keys. It’s worth the drive and even better for those of us that live here. The best crab cakes I have ever had.

Delicious food with great service every time we visit from Marathon.
Thank you!

This is a great place. Food is awesome and so is the service. Nice bar, great specialty drinks. If you want a quality dining experience that rivals any fine dining Key West has to offer, then you will love this place.

Always a wonderful dining experience. So lucky to have Chef Kevin and Maggie Montoya on Big Pine Key.

One of the best meals I’ve ever had from the salad, to the swordfish, to the gnocchi, and finally the key lime tart. This is a gem for Big Pine Key!

Milagro is one of the best restaurants in the middle keys. The food is outstanding with creative and delicious specials. I had a special craft cocktail suggested by our server Julio, it was absolutely delicious. Service is excellent. The owners Maggie and Kevin are the consummate hosts making each guest feel welcomed and comfortable. Love this place.

The octapus appetizer was worth going back for (3 times) so far on our month long vacation.

Best restaurant in the lower keys. The owners and staff go above and beyond to provide a fabulous dining experience. Highly recommend.

Wonderful food and fantastic service!

It is our go to restaurant in the Keys! Wonderful food and fabulous service!

Dinner was wonderful as usual. We really love the prime rib night and it did not disappoint. We called ahead and they had saved our desired cut.

Great owners

Fantastic!

We have been to Milagros 3 times now and always outstanding.

Excellent food and service! We had the best waiter and it was a very pleasant experience

Waiter was fabulous! Food was exceptional to my surprise. Best meal I’ve had in twenty years in the Keys. Unfortunately too far from us to visit often.

Very underrated restaurant in the Lower Keys. Very good food. Have eaten many different things on the menu and everyone of them is excellent. Highly recommend.