Mike's York Street Bar and Grill

We had a reservation. We got there and it was fine. Got placed right next to the music that was setting up. Not ideal but they did not start yet. We left after 12 mins. Not once did the server look up from her phone. No drink order was taken. No hey guys give me a sec ill be right over. Nothing until we got up to leave. So we did not feel like she would have taken care of us at all. Was looking forward to it but was not a good first impression.

We had a reservation and they didn't know where to put us, so they threw us in this downstairs area. The table was wobbly and we couldn't see a t.v. and the playoff games were on. The area looked like it wasn't going to be used and we felt forgotten. Never had a waitress come over, so we left. I usually like this place.

Overall good experience but service after meals were delivered was lacking. We noticed there was only 1 server in the main dining room and she had many tables to serve. We did not get refills on waters until she came with our checks. She appeared over worked. An additional server appeared as we were finishing.

Pleasant experience. Food was good and service was great. I was very happy to be able to get a reservation last minute.

We were seated right away, then left after waiting 20 minutes to be acknowledged. We should have listened to the other reviews!

Great atmosphere, 6 people at our table and the service was great also.

Loved the new design/decor. Nice atmosphere. Food was very good.

Beautiful building!! Service and food were good! We will definitely return!!!

First time back here since they renovated and apparently renovated the menu. The "loaded fries" were anything but loaded. They were a giant disappointment. Fries coated with thick canned cheddar cheese. Hardly any bacon. Pizza was not as it was before either. It was good, but it was so much better when the 2 older gentlemen made them. Did not see them there. Bar was slow and 1 bar tender doesn't even wear her mask right. Seating was not spaced out, especially around the bar. Server appeared to be new. She did her best, but definitely needs more training. Likely will not be back any time soon

It sucked.. made reservations thru open table, actually got a confirmation email the day before.. Dec 30.. which I replied, we were going.. got there and they were COMPLETELY CLOSED!!! No warning.. no nothing from open table or mikes.. ON NEW YEARS EVE, let alone.. that was iur experience..

For the most part, everything was great. Our only complain was that they seemed understaffed and that it took about 15 minutes before someone even took our drink order. Our waitress seemed to be essentially on her own to cover 4-5 separate tables, some of which having large parties, so she seemed overwhelmed. Otherwise, food and drink were great and not overly expensive.

I would the pricing was ok but the service wasn’t great. The night we were there the band was really good, we unfortunately were outside and it got chilly. Wish there was sides on the tent because it was chilly and breezy.

First timer, great location, great food, waitress was amazing! Prices were perfect, atmosphere, all good!

Smokers outside and thus smoke drifted into area near the bar.
Many guys standing outside area without masks and closely congregating

went for happy hour - outside. It was a nice time.

The place is newly reopened. Booking through opentable worked - no wait. Our wine pour had to be redone, a salad was missing it’s chicken, and we were missing silverware to start but all small things and easily correctable. Service was a bit slow but not bad. Food was great. Good atmosphere. Was a regular patron before lockdown and fully intend to return on a regular basis in the future.

Food was terrible and service was awful.

Food was not as good as how much it cost. Drinks were not made right and very watered down. Ambiance was not what I would think a bar grill would look like.. weird with a pizza shop in middle by bar. Was not happy or impressed at all.

Our service was the disappearing waitress. It took her forever to get us something and bring it back to the table. Our food all came out warm not hot and we got the spinach dip and it tasted like they changed the cheese to a powdered cheddar cheese. Mikes used to be our favorite place.

Mike’s had a sorely needed renovation and it looks great, cleaner, brighter and the changes work well with the charm of the old building. Love the open ceiling in the bar area. Nice new and expanded outdoor seating set up. Service was slow, but our waitperson was pleasant and apologized several times. New menu items and some of the old stuff too. Tried the new brussel sprout appetizer, came out in a small black iron skillet but was cold, not room temp.but cold. Took forever to track down server to ask to have them heated. After being heated they were better, but not great. Had their onion soup which was very good, kale salad with grilled chicken (another new item) which was ok, and a side of their “seasoned” fries which are lacking in seasoning. Mikes still has good beer list but wi es were limited and “meh”. Feels like they are still working out the kinks I’d their renovations and menu challenges and serving the inside and outside patrons seamlessly. Will try then again in a few weeks.

The new redesigned Mike’s is beautiful!! My husband and I ate in the bar area and the atmosphere was really nice. The food and service was awesome. We can’t wait to go back!!

Service was excellent- we had Jordan- excellent server - food was good - had Cobb salad was good - not a fan of the lettuce they used but... weather was great - ate outside - had entertainment - a person playing the guitar and singing - was good

We sat outside. It was a cool night be we were prepared. We were the only customers oustide. They wanted to sit us outside of their permant deck, under a temporar tent. I asked to be seated closer to the buidling and near to TV. Hostes felt she needed to explain why were being put way out in the tent. She complied with our request. However we sat for about 15 minutes and no one came to be our server. My husband had to go inside and find out why. Communication breakdown between hostess and server. The food was the same as usual. No specials. Often I like their specials. We will go back because it is a favorite but hope things come together a little quicker.

Great Food, Great Service and Great Atmosphere.

Service was slow it was busy. Food was mediocre. Stick with bar foods not great entrees.

Great environment and great food. Service was slow but you could tell they were just new and needing to find their flow. Overall good experience

The Ribs are excellent! Others in party had the burgers and said they were excellent as well. Highly recommend for a nice laid back casual dinner.

Everything was fine but our server seemed a bit non attentive and pre-occupied.

Very nice to have a nice dinner and quit for chatting

The pizza was delicious. The service was good, consistent even while the comedy show was going on. The prices were good.

Great service, food was delicious, nice family friendly atmosphere, price is unbeatable! Definitely will be back!

Our waitress was sat with literally 5 tables all at once. She was so overwhelmed which is understandable. No one was really helping her and our service really suffered for it.

It was very very loud. We sat in lower level and it was pretty cold too. They even had a space heater plugged in. At 630 they ran out of all house white wine? Blamed it on an earlier banquet? How can you run out of white wine on a Saturday night....

I ordered the fish tacos and got 2 small tacos. Not worth the $..

Nice place.

Food, beer & service were very good, but cold temperature detracted from entire meal. Understood it's a stone building, but get heat in back room or more space heaters. No intention of returning until spring.

Went for lunch on Sunday. Decor is a bit outdated but it's comfortable and relaxed. Food was good and there's a large menu. Good value. Good service. Decent beer selection.

Good place for a casual meal and a drink or two.

Seated right away. Sat downstairs in a great room. Our waitress Ana was spectacular. Food was served quickly and was outstanding. Great place as usual !!!

Restaurant had a nice ambiance with the stone walls and multi-room layout. We were there for lunch. Food was very good and a good price. I had the Take Two lunch with lobster bisque (good, but a bit spicier than I expected) and the french dip half sandwich (excellent!). I was lunching with three others and everyone was very pleased with their meals. The person that got the sweet and spicy chicken was extremely pleased and vowed to come back again for it. Service was good with the waitress very nice about our special requests, but food took a bit long to get to the table. The restaurant was not crowded, so it was a bit surprising how long it took. We weren't in an hurry (holiday lunch), so not a problem for us. Overall, we all would like to come back and try the dinner.

Great place for American-style food. Our server was very attentive and friendly. Food was good and nice portion sizes. The restaurant is a little cold (in temperature) since it’s in an old building. Great ambiance though!

Quality is deteriorating.