Michael's St. Augustine
16oz USDA Prime tender, well marbled and highly flavorful
with colorful cauliflower and passion fruit aioli
served in half dozen or dozen with tropical mignonette
The Fillet Oscar was outstanding and the Truffle Fries !!!
Romantic birthday dinner with great food/service/sommelier
Food and wine list was very nice. The staff was exceptional from the hosts to server. Michael's doesn't show up on best restaurant lists but should
Typically Michaels is amazing but we ordered the 5 course meal with 2 add-ons including the oysters and bananas foster and it wasn't good. Tenderloin was undercooked, Scallop(1 scallop lol) was so-so, Beet salad tasted like dirt. I was pretty disappointed considering I spent about $300 on dinner for 2.
The serve was great she took very good care of us. The food was absolutely amazing and the overall restaurant was beautiful would definitely come back and recommend.
Started off with a bee menu that was ok and nothing spectacular. Another party had a screaming kid they let scream and then run around as they sat there and ate. We go out to high end dinners every week and we’re disappointed in the food. Steak was decent but tough on the outside, strange for fillet.
Perfect place but for lack of cocktails. Everything else was awesome. Best wine selection I’ve seen in a long time
As always, a wonderful night out for dinner with amazing food. The service was excellent. We always choose Michael’s when we’re celebrating anything:)!
Nice birthday dinner celebration! Our meals were delicious, from first course to dessert wine. The most accommodating and lovely waitress - Nastasia Lin. She made the evening even nicer!
The food was excellent. Great service and environment wad very relaxing and comfortable. A must go to for great steaks, pork chops and sea scallops
Top-notch quality and presentation. Great ombiance. Quaint and simple but elegant decor. A must go if you're in the city. Ask for Kelly. She was exceptional!
Birthday Month Celebration-
From the Starters to the Entries to the Deserts the food was high quality and extremely flavorful.
The Wine Selection of Cakebread Chardonnay was spot on topped off by a nicely chilled Ruby Port to finish the dinning experience.
First time dining at Michael’s but certainly won’t be the last.
Highly recommend to anyone that enjoys a uniquely fine dining experience.
Wonderful restaurant! Food, service and dining experience was lovely. We will definitely return each time we visit.
Excellent meal and service. We will go there again!
The salmon in puff pastry could have been tastier. The puff pastry was over cooked, almost burnt, and the salmon was just salmon with no other taste to it. I would've thought cheese or some butter or something would've been added but it tasted extremely bland. It was pretty disappointing. I will say that the charcuterie board was excellent! I would've loved for the server to have been On top of the drinks, in essence wine ordering, more quickly. I think the majority of the people were happy at the table with their meals. I also would've liked to of ordered the five course dinner but we had four people and not all forward agree however if we would've been at a two top, they would've let us do it, which I think is super weird.
The restaurant was awesome! It was quite, clean, and romantic. The tables were pretty far apart which made it much more personal. We did the 5 course chefs tasting. The server was attentive and respectful by not showing up too often. All of the food was perfect and the chef even came out to congratulate us on our engagement. I felt like the price wasn’t terrible but a little high for how much food and wine you actually get. Overall this place is must and we will be back for our 1 year anniversary!
Went for my brother’s 20th birthday and had the 7 course meal it was amazing!
Awesome service and the food from start to finish is amazing!
did not enjoy our night
Service did not meet any standard for this kind of restaurant.
It took at least 15 minutes to be acknowledge by waiter after being seat by hostess.
We order drinks and food in same time. after 15-20 more minutes we ask another server if we could have our drinks. waitress come 5 minutes later with our drinks and said apologies and our food will be shortly. then since we are already seating for 1 hour and ready to order another drink she came back asking how i would like our steak cook. I remind her that I order the pork shop and I ask for pink inside and my wife had order the salmon wellington....after 25 more minutes we received our food. we have seen our waitress 4 time in 2 hours.
One of our favorite restaurants. We love the 3/5 course chef’s selection with the wine pairing
Outstanding food and great service
Excellent mea and wine selection. The staff were very knowledgeable and friendly
Great to finally get to experience this great dining venue
Waiter well informed about menu items and accurately described The items
We went to Michael’s to celebrate getting a new job. We ordered the Five Course Chef Experience with wine pairings. It was fantastic. Everything about this dinner was an experience! The food was superb and the wine was perfectly paired. We thoroughly enjoyed our trip here and plan to come back again. 5/5
One of my favorite restaurants when I visit st. Augustine. Food is always on point and amazing service!
Start to finish it was perfection service was stellar ambience was perfect
The meals were excellent.
We had appetizer, steaks, salmon, chicken & scallops for a party of four.
All were savory and delightful & expensive.
The dining experience was tarnished with an over charge of about $100.00 on wine.
fortunately my wife pays closer attention to the check than I do...
Simple accident in billing? perhaps, but I have my doubts.
I will not go back.
Excellent meal for our 30th anniversary.
We enjoyed the atmosphere and cuisine. A great find!
Our anniversary dinner was outstanding and the chefs recommendations were perfect.
They could be nicer
Loved it. We had a 5:30 reservation. We got there early and they took us. Rustic Italian bread and roasted garlic were delicious. The braised beef bruschetta very flavorful . I had the lobster ravioli and my husband had the rack of lamb. We both liked it very much. I expected it to be more expensive than it was. So we were pleasantly surprised. Neither of us had room for dessert. Would definitely return.
The Chefs special 5 Course meal was amazing. Every course was so expertly prepared, delicious and beautifully presented. We reserved our table outside, overlooking the street, so we had that as our entertainment (and some street noise), but the inside looked very nice too. Service was perfect. We look forward to another visit!
We dined at Michael’s the first night of our visit to St Augustine and both of our meals were amazing. We both had the filet...mine with brandy peppercorn sauce and garlic herb butter for my husband. Our steaks were so tender, we could have cut them with the fork alone. We shared a side of the risotto and mousseline potatoes. Both were very good and more than enough for both of us.
For starters, my husband had the harvest salad and he said it was outstanding. I had the chicken empanaditas appetizer. They were delicious.
Our server was attentive without being intrusive and checked on us frequently.
We were too full to even consider dessert. 😁
We will definitely be back on our next trip to St Augustine.
We had a wonderful time. The service was amazing and the food was delicious. Thank you.
We really enjoyed this place. Our server was great and the food was very good. Would recommend
The host was very rad. My girlfriend got lit on the Bellini
We had a great dinner with a very caring and professional server. The smoked pork chop was huge and delicious. Perfectly broiled. The dessert selection was not appealing to me (everything had cake in it)...but everything else was excellent.
Interesting and flavorful food in a tasteful and relaxing setting with attentive service.
Michael's St. Augustine offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (904) 810-2400.
Michael's St. Augustine is rated 4.7 stars by 2238 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.