Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana
The pastas were very good, not over-sauced and you could tell the pasta was handmade. The carpaccio has too thin to cut the amount of thick aioli and thickness of the Parmesan.
Awesome staff with great recommendations.
We make it a point to come here every time we are in Hilton Head. Have never had a bad meal or even a fair meal...the food and service is always excellent. Love, love, love this place!!
We really like Michael Anthony’s. Unfortunately we don’t have the opportunity to go there frequently. Always good food and good wine. Very nice.
Great food and service. Fun place to eat. We really enjoyed an evening with friends. The wine list is also good and sensibly priced.
Excellent service and the food is very delicious. We save going for special occasions . It is a bit on the higher price side, but worth it!
Excellent Italian restaurant.Our family of 4 enjoyed immensely our last evening meal on Hilton Head.The scallops were superb and service was excellent.We will go again the next time we are in Hilton Head.
I've never had a bad meal at Michael Anthony's. The ravioli was mushroom and was excellent. I dined with my wife and 3 good friends. The night was special. Thank you.
We had a nice evening dining for the first time while in Hilton Head at Michael Anthonys.
My salad was good and my special request of GF pasta with garlic and olive oil was good also.
My husbands Tomato Soup special was delicious and his Pasta Special, Ravioli with Mushrooms with a GorgonzolaCream sauce was tops!
The Pana cotta dessert was very good also.
A little pricey for the GF pasta, but otherwise a entertaining meal with a Chris our server.
Wonderful is a word I would use to describe Michael Anthonys. We have vacationed 3 times in Hilton Head and all 3 times we have been giddy with excitement knowing we were going to dine here. They have servers who have been with them for years and that speaks volumes in a industry where servers come and go. Their food is amazing!!! If we lived there, we would definitely be taking the cooking classes they offer. Job exceptionally well done everyone!
We knew it was a little more on the expensive side, but the food, ambiance, and service was spectacular. 10/10 would recommend and will definitely be back. Our server knew exactly what he was talking about with wine and our food concerns, and his knowledge showed when he picked us out the perfect wine in our budget.
I brought 7 golf friends there for the 3rd year in a row. The food and service was excellent as always. Looking forward to next year.
The food and the service was outstanding. The management of Michael Anthony’s was very helpful in establishing my gift card that was sent via email to be used at Michael Anthony’s restaurant. Every year we come to Hilton head Island and celebrate our anniversary at this fine restaurant.
We will be back next year to celebrate our 54th wedding anniversary.
Excellent food and service. The early dining menu is an incredible value.
Overall was very good. The food was excellent
This was a great meal to end our last evening of vacation on and too celebrate my wife’s birthday!
When it first opened Michael Anthony’s was a very good restaurant like most of the south end restaurants it has morphed into an overpriced tourist trap. I can cook a better Zappa de Pesche than my wife had Friday night..
28 year resident of Hilton Head.
Yes come every year when we are you vacation, we will return next time we are on the island. Recommend to all our friends
We are from Philadelphia
Turns out Hilton Head has an amazing mix of mediocre restaurants.
On line reviews were very favorable but we were unimpressed.
It wasn’t bad overall (although the spaghetti was a bit funky). It simply was average
We live in a very small town and our local Italian restaurant is just as good
Save your money and go to Salty Dog
The service was excellent. Our waitress Caitlyn was very knowledgeable of the menu. Made several suggestions of things to Order that were not even on the menu.
Food was delicious portion sizes were large but not ridiculous like you sometimes get with pasta based meals. The pasta was freshly made.
Would definitely return.
Best grouper I ever had in my life
Michael Anthony's is a little hidden gem in Hilton Head. The food, wine and staff are excellent!
Came here on our last night in Hilton Head and we thoroughly enjoyed it. The food was delicious and the service was wonderful. We will definitely be back!!!
Meal and service were excellent!! Jonathan did a great job keeping up with our group, making recommendations, refilling drinks, making sure we all loved our food!! Wish we lived nearby to enjoy this fabulous restaurant often!!!
Amazing!! Loved the simplicity and freshness of the food. Scratch made gnocchi was incredibly soft and cooked to perfection. Highly recommended.
Great food, cocktails, and wine. Always a good dining experience!
If I could give Michael Anthony’s a 10 star review I would! We have never had better Italian food, and we have eaten LOTS of Italian food! The service we got from Chris was unbeatable; we were treated like royalty, yet we felt right at home. We had help with the wine menu (please try their Chianti selections), and great descriptions of the food offerings. All in all, this was a tremendous value and dining experience. We will be back!
Excellent menu choices and superb meals! Our waiter and waitress were more than accommodating and checked numerous times with us during the meal. Would definitely return!
Great tasting Italian food. Asked for a little spicier red sauce it was delicious. Went back next night it was so good.
It was our anniversary! Our waiter was fabulous and the food was very delicious!
Pleasant and excellent food
Everything was great as always.
Excellent meal and service. We read the great reviews and figured we’d give it a try. We were not disappointed and will definitely return next time we are in Hilton Head! Thanks for a great and memorable evening.
Outstanding !!! On my favorite list now every time I come back to HHI !!
Dinner with friends at a most enjoyable spot. Service was great, drinks too (try the Sazarac!), and the food delicious.
Perfect dining experience, start to finish.
We visit Michael Anthony’s on every Hilton Head visit, Most always as our last night reward to ourselves. Food and presentation gets consistently high marks. Sometimes though and it’s not unique to this restaurant we are at the mercy of groups and tables of more than four. We had two servers at our table, one very young and the other more experienced. Oddly, the older was reluctant to make eye contact at all during service— it was the only off putting note of the night.
See you next time,
Old two tops.
Quality ingredients. Impeccable food. Quiet atmosphere. Good wine list
This place did not disappoint! Great food and service! The pasta was home made and delicious. I had a shrimp pasta and my wife had a lamb ravioli dish. Desserts were amazing. Tried the tiramisu and dessert trio. We will be back!