My husband and I had dinner at Meat and Potatoes following a theater show at the nearby Benedum Theater. I ordered the roasted chicken and my husband had the dinner special, skirt steak. While we agreed that both our entrees were delicious, his portions were decidedly smaller than mine. I ended up giving him about 1/3 of my chicken, which was fine, since the chicken was a very large portion. We had talked about getting the "Steak for Two," which was a 30+ oz steak, but decided against that. The couple seated next to us did get it, and the cutting board upon which the meal arrived barely fit on the very small, round table. They said it was very good, and took a good deal of it home with them.
It was strange, at first, being seated inches apart from the tables on either side of us, but we found that it was easy to carry on a conversation without being overwhelmed by the conversations of other diners. They don't have a lot of seating, which explains why numerous patrons were turned away if they didn't have reservations. It is possible to sit at the bar and order from the full menu, but those seats were full while we were there.
We had a gift card, and will return to use the rest of the card. I would definitely recommend making reservations, especially on the weekend. I used the "Open Table" reservation option here on Tripadvisor for our recent reservation. I liked the online reservation method since after trying to call the restaurant several times, I couldn't get anyone to answer the phone! But, do keep trying since the food is delicious and well worth making the effort to get there.