McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Filet & Stuffed Shrimp
Perfect Pair, Steamed Vegetables
Lobster Mashed Potatoes
Excellent service. Food was on point as usual.
Our service provider was great, personable, helpful and engaging. The food was ok, not exceptional and the space has a great vibe/noise level.
This was our second time eating at McCormick & Schmick’s. The food was delicious and the service was amazing. Our waitress recommended the Tito’s Cherry Mule and I’m so glad she did. It is by far my new favorite drink! I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone that enjoys seafood or steaks. You won’t be disappointed.
Very nice ambience and vibe for a reasonable date night. Food was well above average and the devour Indy menu was a bargain.
Very disappointing dining experience. Server, Krystal was fine but 59% of the food was terrible. Cold mashed potatoes, over cooked steak. Fish with zero flavor and dry overdone brownie.
The Lobster Bisque was amazing! One of the best ones I’ve ever had!
Also got the smoked old fashioned and it was good, but not as good as I expected for the price.
Overall great visit and I will definitely go again!
First time dining here and we will certainly be back. Food and service was excellent and good value.
The food was very good. We bad the calamari for and appetizer. My wife had a chicken dish they serve and she really liked it. I had the lobster tail with a shrimp dynamite on top that was really good. Although they only gave me four pcs of asparagus. I could have used more of that. It also came with roasted potatoes that were good but I'm really a roasted potatoe kind of guy. Overall it was good food and a nice atmosphere, with courteous employees.
We went early (5pm on a Friday when downtown was very quiet) but this place was great because tables are well spaced, staff is excellent, friendly, great service that isn't too disruptive to table conversation. Food was excellent. It's pricey so that's why I marked it down one star for a good value. Definitely a spurge for the fiscally careful.
Duane did a great job as always. One short on wait staff so the manager stepped up to make sure things were going well.
It was outstanding! Our server was very informative and our compliments to the chef!
Food was delicious!
Cheese cake tasted like if was in refrigerator uncovered or old
The servers were wonderful. Thank you for that on a lovely date night away from the kids! A cozy atmosphere, plexiglass between the booths, and a delicious calamari appetizer. The salads were perfect. The main courses were a bit bland for our taste, but the other parts of the experience made up for it.
Great staff. Steak was excellent. Truly enjoyed our evening
Good food and good service, very enjoyable experience!
We went for a fabulous McCormick & Schmick’s lunch in Indianapolis on the day that the College National Championship game was being played there. We could hardly believe how incredible our dining experience was on such a busy day. The person who greeted us was so outgoing and friendly. Judy was our waitress and so great. She helped us select the most wonderful options. Don’t miss out on their shrimp cocktail, Cobia and fish and chips which were so delicious. Thank you for your kind hospitality. This is a 5 star place to dine in downtown Indy.
I got the stuffed crab and shrimp salmon and it was decent. I had to add salt and pepper because there was absolutely no seasoning on it. The sides were horrendous. I had mashed potatoes and seasonal veggies… Once again, absolutely no flavor or seasoning and the potatoes were a bit watery. I got a berry berry Mojito and it was decent. Definitely not worth the money. My date enjoyed his food, however.
Our server, Wendy, was very engaging and attentive!
The sea bass is the best I’ve had anywhere and their stuffed shrimp wrapped in bacon also great
Our food was well prepared and Bradley was an excellent server.
Nice ambiance, good service, average food at more than average prices.
Host and server (Diego) we’re on point. We enjoyed ourselves. Recommendations on food and drinks were spot on. Thank you Diego for making our New Years dinner an awesome experience.
Good food. Slow service (due to Covid probably).
Excellence! Before we arrived, I called to request that I would be responsible for paying the entire bill. The lady was extremely understanding and helpful. We pulled it off without a hitch. Arriving, we had a nice table, and our server Bradley was there to greet us immediately. He was very attentive and helped me decide on my dinner selection. I had never tried Cobia before, he explained it to me to a tee, Sold! It was absolutely delicious. My father in law ordered steak. And he likes it extra well done. (Unfortunately hockey puck style) And it was perfect to his liking. Our appetizers were great and everyone was very pleased with Bradley and our meals.Thank you
It was just ok
It was very that they put happy birthday on our means for my cousin but nothing else was said about her birthday. I would come back a again but not in my top 10 favorite restaurants.
Our steaks were prepared perfectly. The service was excellent.
It was okay. I was expecting it to taste better considering I went because I was told the food was awesome.
At the end of our progressive dinner, we ended our night here with dessert and cocktails and was very pleased! The butter cake was the pick of the night and was highly satisfying!
Overall was a good experience. Waiter was kind and informative. The steak was phenomenal and cooked perfect. Since this is a seafood restaurant we had high expectations for that particular food. The lobster was pretty tough and rubbery. I would return but only for a filet in the future.
Service and atmosphere was very nice. Disappointed in the oysters Rockefeller, I’ve had this many times and it just was not cooked properly. The entrees were ok, drinks were great.
Will probably go there again at some point but they need to step up their game, there’s to much competition to be average at that price point
I haven't been here for quite awhile and was not disappointed. The food was excellent, reasonable and Landon, our waiter, was attentive but not hovering and had good recommendations. They also make a killer Old Fashioned.
Hostess welcomed us for our reservation promptly and seated us in a nice booth. Bradley, our server, was excellent the whole time. He was courteous and efficient. My husband had the filet steak and said it was very good. I had the stuffed salmon, from the Prix Fixe menu and it was delicious. Both of our proteins were served with mashed potatoes. Mine was also served with green beans/carrots, so I shared those with my husband. Hubby had the salad and I had the delicious clam chowder. We each had the New York style cheesecake with raspberry topping. The ambiance is really nice at this restaurant. We have been several times and will go back. Nice job, Bradley!
The food was uninspired and lacked seasoning. I don’t think boiling a lobster tail in salted water and serving it with plain melted butter with no lemon with breasted potatoes rises to a $61 price tag. Fortunately, our server, who was starting her job that day, was fabulous. I liked that all the staff was masked. Please provide them with N-95s, though.
Always a good experience and delicious food. The New Year’s Eve menu didn’t disappoint.
Food was not good - cold when should have been hot.
Shrimp in shrimp cocktail were rubbery.
Lettuce was brownish and wilty in ceasar salad.
Our server took the cost of the shrimp cocktail off of our tab, but we still spent almost $200 for a meal worth much much less.
Very disappointing and has caused us to not ever return there.
Everything was fine. Disappointed on the scaled down lunch menu.
Great food and great staff!
The food was great and so was the service! I sat in the bar and Duane served me, he was great!
You can order delivery directly from McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis using the Order Online button. McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis also offers delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 631-9500.
McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis is rated 4.4 stars by 3780 OpenTable diners.
McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.