McCormick & Schmick's Seafood - Indianapolis
Book your next event with us
Excellent again. Food cooked perfectly. Server efficient
I love the private booths, and how attentive the servers are. The food is amazing. Highly recommended.
Food and atmosphere was great. Easy dining , traveling for work and was staying in the hotel.
We enjoyed our dinner immensely. The service was just right and the food was delicious. We will be back.
Bread was hard, potatoes were not done. Other than that everything was great.
Even though we used open table for a reservation we still waited over an hour for our table
We arrived at our reservation time of 8:30. As of 9:00, we were still 18th in line for a table. We left without being seated which ruined our entire evening.
Understaff, overbooked, lousy service. I had to wait an hour to be seated, although I had a reservation. The tables were empty the entire time they were not cleaning them as fast as they should have.
New Years Eve - food was great, service was pretty good. Only complaint was related To the chaos in the entryway and reservation was at 7:45 and took almost an hour to get seated
This restaurant is very classy and clean. The wait was an hour despite the fact that we had reservations, however, since it was New Years Eve and I know that is a very crazy time, I won't let that keep me from coming back. The food was delicious, however, I was disappointed that they did not have on the menu that night what I actually came for...crab legs. It was that they ran out, but rather that the menu was different than the usual for the occasion. I do wish I would have known that. The waiter was delightful and overall it was a good experience. I will try it again on a less busy occasion.
NYE and they were under staffed. Lobster bisque was so salty we couldn’t eat it and my lobster was under cooked. 30 minutes to get a drink. We won’t be back.
Was there NYE and kitchen was under staffed - look almost 2 hours - bar was slow, everything was slow. Food was very good - just super slow
Being NYE understandable that it was very busy. Had reservations for 6:30, checked in at 6:22 & was told to wait until closer to 6:30. While waiting several people check in after us and were seated well before our seating time of 6:48. However, the food was excellent and service was a bit slow but very very understandable for athe evening..... Overall a great evening.
Our 37th anniversary New Year’s Eve. We’ve been going to this restaurant the last couple of times. Much better than st elmos
Delicious food, fabulous service, beautiful room!
New Years eve
Used gift card for New Years Eve. Service was good but food was just ok.
I was quite disappointed. The service was very slow, and the food was just warm when we received it (and my husband's mixed grill seafood plate was overdone - so clearly the food had been sitting for a bit before being delivered. Perhaps it was an off night, but I find there are other great restaurants in the area with great fare - at better prices.
Fish was pretty good. I ordered oysters and the waitress never brought them out. Just brought entire and waitress never noticed that oysters were never served.
The ambiance wasn't great. A staff member was dragging a full trash can through the main seating area and our table was wobbly. However, our dinner was very good and our waitress was pleasant an made good recommendations.
The fries were a bit undercooked and therefore limp, but the lobster bisque was delicious, as were the scallops.
Christmas dinner with family
Service for dinner was very slow. We waited 45 min for our meal. Disappointed
Server needed help. Had to wait too long to be greeted, order taken, bread to table (had to ask for it).
Nice restaurant and friendly staff but just good food, not amazing. Sides could use some diversity.
Consistently good-to-very-good overall -- in food, service and ambience. Prices are still at premium level, so value seems fair to good.
Everything was excellent. M&S has raised its game in my opinion. We go for the seafood more than the steaks. We had a large selection of appetizers and I recommend ordering from the bar menu if possible. The fish tacos were excellent. Main courses were well prepared and the food was very good with one small exception - the salmon. I do not understand why restaurants serve a farm raised Atlantic salmon - no flavor period. I had the swordfish which was excellent. Stuffed shrimp was perfect as were crab cakes (we shared a lot at the table). Our server Duane was outstanding. Not only was his service spot on, but he made the dining experience fun. Bravo Duane, you are the man!
The waitress made sure our evening was great.
Everything was excellent. The service was exceptional and the food was excellent. I had the Filet with twin Lobster Tails. Exceptional. The selection of fresh seafood was outstanding.
I was very disappointed in our food and service. I have dined here before and came back because of the great experience. Steak had no flavor for the price and the steak knife was a very very cheap knife
The service was slow. We ordered a bottle of wine before our dinner arrived and the waiter brought it after we were all done eating. The steaks are better at Outback Steakhouse. Would not recommend or go back.
Great menu, great food and a pleasant atmosphere. A good choice for our anniversary.
We had a suboptimal experience with service, mostly not being attentive to drinks or bread; Food was excellent; Restaurant is also too noisy
Initial drink portion was poor. I ordered a Manhattan up and the server returned with a 1/2 glass. 2nd pour was better. Clam chowder was good; clams were very tender. I had the scallops. Served 4 small scallops on a bed of spinach over what seemed like a serving of hash brown potatoes. The potatoes were nothing special; the scallops and spinach tasted great, but the small amount left me wanting more. Overall, I would spend that amount of money at another downtown Indy restaurant; not worth the money and a poor value.
Excellent food. Excellent service. Wonderful evening.
Awesome service, dinner was delicious and the Chocolate martinis are too die for!!
If you're going for a place with great atmosphere this is it
If you want great seafood, for the price, it's average
Service was good at first but seemed it took a long time for drinks to show up (25 minutes)
Waiter was knowledgeable and pleasant but possibly too busy
Husband and I celebrating our 42nd Anniversary. This was our first visit to McCormick & Schmick’s. Everything was impeccable. Excellent food and server was very accommodating. Definitely will be back.
Food was excellent. Oysters were great. Our server was just ok, slow service despite a very small number of diners.