Max's Seafood Cafe
The food was really good and our waitress Alicia was really nice and on point
Always delicious food…served hot and lovely place!
We went to Max’s for seafood and we were not disappointed.
Oysters and fried octopus were great especially the octopus.
My grilled seafood entree with rice and vegetables
was very tasty.
My wife had the Chilean Sea Bass and she really enjoyed her meal.
This is such a rustic neighborhood eatery that oozes charm! The brickwork inside amidst the woodwork and layout of the restaurant was very eye pleasing.
The service was impressive and the staff very accommodating.
Our oysters were so fresh, the Roasted Clams, and soups were all well priced and portions were good.
Max’s can do it all. One had a Chilean Se Bass that was truly awesome, one enjoyed the Freshly Fried Platter and another had one of the best Chicken Parm dinners they’ve had (from a seafood restaurant)!
Deserts and coffee were just as good as the rest of our meals and we will definitely be back. Highly recommend!
My wife and I sat for over 20 minutes before we were ever addressed by anyone. No bread, no drinks, no introduction or “we’ll be with you shortly”. Nothing. The hostess must’ve seen our expressions and asked if any server had come over to our table. We were comped an appetizer as an apology. The hostess then took it upon herself to help us the entire meal while she sat tables and acted as bartender. She was kind and expressed they were understaffed but I did not see any other tables having issues with service like we did. As I said she was kind and apologetic but clearly overwhelmed and couldn’t give us the attention we deserved which is completely unacceptable for the price of this place. I was also given a dirty steak knife with my filet mignon which I had to send back for a clean one. We shouldn’t feel second rate when paying $40+ an entree. Food was delicious which was the only saving grace. We don’t get to go out very often and this was supposed to be a nice treat for our date night, extremely disappointing experience.
Upon arrival, no one greeted us or even smiled an acknowledgement as we stood awkwardly wondering if we were in the right place to wait/confirm our reservation. Another couple was there too so we figured it was ok but it was at least 10 minutes before we were acknowledged with the question, “Do you have a reservation?” Our affirmative response was met with, “ I’m just waiting for some tables to be cleared.” She seemed annoyed, so we thought maybe they were short handed. It wasn’t mobbed but The bar was busy and the small dining room 3/4 full. The place is attractive but the lighting dim in the dining room and it would have been nice if the candles on the tables were lit. The menu didn’t wow but the positive reviews were encouraging. DH found the shrimp fra diavolo hot but not special and my steak with crabmeat was undercooked (red not pink) with the crabmeat barely noticeable and overwhelmed by the sauce and garlic mashed potatoes beneath (they were good.) The roasted Brussel sprouts tasted like every other slightly burnt oil roasted vegetable I ever had. The steak was perfect when they brought it back and improved by being removed from the overpowering spouts. Our waitress was agreeable but appeared stressed & over her head. In the 20 minutes we spent waiting for our table, 3 drinks sat on the bar. After 5-10, she grabbed 2 and delivered them to the dining room but it was almost 20 mins. before the flavored martini glass drink got taken to its owner. She was attentive at the barest acceptable minimum. A second waitress brought my plate back once with the uneaten sprouts and the second time with the corrected steak. She was very pleasant and attentive, she clearly seemed to know how to behave as a server! She seemed Totally underutilized and after we commented, she admitted it was her first day. Clearly they hired her for her skills, they should have let her work. No big deal but Our anniversary, cited in the reservation, wasn’t noticed. The tiramisu was ok.
Great food. Atmosphere was good. Nice quaint place for dinner and chilling.
The food was outstanding. It was the young servers' first time serving and she was trying very hard but awful. I would go back to try again but not on a Saturday night.
This is my second trip to Max's. The food is always very good although the portions are somewhat small. Tonight, they didn't have any tea or iced tea. Not exactly sure how it's possible not to have available tea bags to make tea but since tea is what I drink it was disappointing. The server was very young and clearly inexperienced. She was nice enough, but when she said "we don't have any tea the kitchen just told me", I asked what they had instead and she said "coke, sprite, um.. you know sodas". I asked her to find out exactly and she came back and told me the list which included lemonade which is what I ended up with. The glasses for water were a bit larger than shot glasses, and they filled them when we got there, but we had to go take a water pitcher from the station to refill our own water the rest of the night, and nobody including the server was a bit curious how we ended up with a water pitcher on our table. Mind you, the place was completely empty as we had 5pm reservations. It got much busier by 6pm, so this wasn't a case of the place being too busy. We watched the 3 female servers follow each other around most of the night while we were eating. Another somewhat annoying situation was while my wife was literally eating, the server asked if she could clear the plates. The same happened when my wife was away from the table, they wanted to clear her bread plate, that had buttered bread on it at the time. However, as I said, the appetizers and entree's were very good although the portions were small. We had cannoli's for dessert which were clearly made in house and very good, I was very impressed by this. I will be returning to Max's regularly because if you can look beyond the service, for the price.. it's good food, with very nice ambience.
Deliscious food! Amazing muscles in red sauce and salmon. Yum!
Not up to past standards, maybe because of long layoff.
Loved the atmosphere almost as much as the mouth watering food.
We have been going there’s for many years always a great meal especially the Thai mussels
Bronzino and salmon entrees delicious. Scallop app soo good! Vodka and cranberry juice weak drink and cran juice was artificial tasting. That was the only negative. Ambiance nice, dark, quiet
This is my first negative review. I felt the need to write it because the situation I encountered was not handled well to say the least. I often dine at Max's because we always had good food and a wonderful experience. For my birthday we went there for dinner. Food was ok. Not what we were used to. Fish was overcooked and the rice was hard. I was not going to write a bad review about 1 bad meal though. The problem was the manager/owner. The waitress was very hurried and rushed everything (ordering/serving etc which is not normal for Max's) but due to the current employment situation I was very understanding and thought that she may be new.
So she served our meals and forgot a side of melted butter to go with lobster. As she quickly handed it over the table, she dropped it and it ended up all over me and in my pocketbook. There was butter everywhere. On my phone, keys and everywhere inside a designer bag. She was not sure what to do so I asked her for napkins. Then she disappeared so I ended up cleaning up the table and floor as the waitress was not around. The manager/owner (Tom I believe) did stop by and ask to pay to clean my purse. I declined because I was angry at the time. I was asked if there was anything I needed. I said sure a drink would be great. Well when the bill came, the drink was on the bill. I thought that they could have at least comp'd my drink considering I cleaned up the floor, my food became cold and I have a ruined pocketbook. We asked for Tom to return to discuss the bill and at 7:30 on a Friday night, I was told that he was gone for the night. So they took my phone number. I was told that he would definitely call the next day. It's been 6 days and, I'm still waiting. I have been treated much better for far less at other restaurants. Accidents happen, how you deal with them is what separates the good from the bad.
Took a little long for service but gave my date and I plenty of time for conversation. Food was fabulous. A true gem of a place.
Nice atmosphere, beautiful building. We both got the lobster bisque which was a little too salty for our taste. Crab cakes were good and Seafood Pescatore was delicious.
Fabulous! Service was slow this Mother’s Day, but out waitress kept checking on us. We loved it!
I love the food here. I had the mussels in red sauce with Linguini. I also had a cup of lobster bisque. Delicious. The only thing was that, in this age of covid, we were concerned with how close we were seated to other tables of guests. We questioned them about it. They just said it's mother's day and we're fully booked. Things that make you say hmmmm.
They did not honor the reservations even tho I received an email the day before confirming. Horrible way to treat people on mother’s day
Amazing, they were short staffed and still did such a good job making sure everything was perfect.
We haven't been been and years and regret it. We are looking forward to going back.
Seafood was just OK and this is supposed to be a seafood place. The restaurant is nice inside but tables are already on top of each other in areas. Wine list is reasonably priced
Service was slow and the portion size was pitiful. . . Over priced for what you got
Out of fried shrimp, so
Everything was excellent
Everything was wonderful. Service was great. Food was delicious
Was disappointed i ordered what i was told was the new name for seafood combination.it came with 1 scallop 1 shrimp 1 small crabcake and half of a tiny mushy tail which i sent back to cook more . It should of been an appetizer sampler not my dinner. Guess I ordered the wrong thing my wife loved her dinner
IF YOU are looking for an EXCELLENT SEAFOOD meal you need to go to Gloucester City, NJ to Max's Seafood Cafe. Every meal is a delight. Soups like Seafood Gumbo are the best and mixed grill terrific. WE always enjoy our meal at MAX'S!
Sad the kitchen was horrible, we had to wait nearly 2 hours for our dinners. Server was very nice, apologized for the kitchen delay. I don’t believe the kitchen staff could handle the crowd. Dinner was average, nothing exciting We won’t be back
The restaurant was very busy on a Saturday night (which is a good thing!) but the entire staff handled it well and with smiles making sure we were well taken care of. Great menu options. Tough to decide what entree to get! The crab dip appetizer was the perfect portion for two people to share. Amazed at how good the key lime pie was! Can’t wait to return! Overall a wonderful dining experience
I love Max’s! Our table had Mussels, Seafood Fra Diable, Filet and Cake Cakes. All which were outstanding! Filet was cooked to perfection and probably the best I ever had.
I love the exposed brickwork. This was was second time here and had a great experience both times. I tried different dishes each time and they were delicious.
Delicious food and great service!
Staff very attentive and food served hot.
Was excited to try a new place out but left disappointed. Reservations were at 6:30pm. Appetizers didn't come out until 7:45 and dinner 8:15. Waitress was hard to locate and when at table did make quick apologies but no manager. No rhyme or reason for tables being served; table of 4 like us sat a good 30 minutes after us but were being served dessert as our dinners were coming out. Other tables like ours were waiting a long time. Food was fine but not worth going back.
They have the mussels down perfect.
We enjoyed all of our meals. I thought it was fairly priced and worthy of a return trip.
Did not get to eat here as they was closed but let us make a reservation very disappointed
Only 2 other tables occupied and service still took awhile. Overpriced for the amount of food I received and for the price I would have thought the meal would have come with a salad. Had to ask twice for salt and pepper. Portions were very small for the price. I will not return nor would I recommend it. Very disappointed.
Max's Seafood Cafe is rated 4.3 stars by 1495 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.