Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Signature Warm Butter Cake
8 oz or 12 oz
Ribeye Steak, Eggs
Great food! Great service!
Food was great !
Server was moving too fast and speaking extremely fast was hard to hear him .
Noise level was moderate .
Was seated by the bar which was too close to the waiter service station . Had waiters coming by all night with glasses and waiting to use the ordering system practically standing next to my table
Angie was a wonderful server.
I HAD A PHENOMENAL EXPERIENCE. THE FOOD WAS FANTASTIC, THE AMBIANCE WAS NICE, MY WAITRESS, THE SERVERS AND STAFF WAS VERY PLEASANT. THERE HAD BEEN A SINGER THERE & SHE WAS THE BEST. I WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK!
The restaurant was so nice food and service was excellent they even had live talent it was such and amazing night
I ordered a porterhouse medium well and the food was delivered medium rare. The waiter did not come over once during the entire dinner to check on the table, then the guy comes take my plate without acknowledging that the entire steak was rare. And still charged full price. Horrible experience. The lobster mac and cheese was served cold as well. Approximately $600 down the drain
was an amazing experience, definitely would recommend
2nd time going and always super amazing the food and service is great
I went to Mastro’s to celebrate my boyfriend’s birthday. The service was good and they were very friendly when I had to change my reservation time at the last minute.
The steak was flavorful and juicy. The garlic mashed potato is definitely a must.
Would recommend this restaurant!
The vibe was amazing!! Our server Tyrell did a great job giving us insight on the menu. The experience was dope! Sautéed shrimp were amazing the sauce omg!!!!
Excellent food, friendly staff and nice atmosphere.
Steak was seasoned well and melt like butter when cutting
Our server was AMAZING!!! Such a great way to end our vacation. Food was the BEST we had all week and he sent us a complimentary dessert. We will definitely go back!!
Food was great, will definitely go back for food. The service was amazing. They do charge yo Igor every little thing but it’s worth it.
Wagyu tomahawk was good but it's been better. Service was good.
Food was top notch. Great service. Great environment. Awesome experience. If you like high end restaurants, i highly recommend
Several food items on the menu wasn’t available like halibut.
Great restaurant took my wife for our anniversary
Good food, good and fast service.
Loved the food. The waiter was terrific and they did a nice job helping us celebrate our anniversary. It is certainly not a place I could go often on a teachers' salary but overall, it was a terrific experience.
Everything we fabulous
The hostesses are rude. We were a table of 10. They wouldn’t seat us until 8 ppl got there. The service was horrible. You think for a table that spent over $2k they would be nicer. I will never be taking my clients there for dinner moving forward.
I had the best experience ever! I'm so happy I chose Mastro's to celebrate my husband's birthday, we will definitely be back.
Bone in rib eye must have. Excellent quality. Not to mention amazing service.
Outstanding food and service! ❤️
the food was amazing the service was excellent. The live music was a great experience.
I do wish the dress code mentioned on the website and when you are called to confirm reservation was actually enforced. I kept seeing guests not dressed appropriately for the location and I felt uncomfortable mostly disappointed. I was dressed my best and the tables next to us felt like were at a baseball game or a night club. Biggest flaw for such a prestigious place. In addition the tables near the rest room were a distraction of the people going up and down the stairs constantly.
Apps and steak were excellent but service was underwhelming and lacking. Main waiter (Ivan) was not attentive and didn’t fill empty wine glasses forcing us to refill our own glasses. Water glasses were left empty for a long period of time. I’m not sure what happened to the service since I last dined here in 2019…
Highly recommend excellent seating, food and professional 👍🏾👍🏾
We enjoyed our event, it brought back our memories of when we were in LA Maestros a few years ago.
Our evening last night was almost perfect. Cocktails A+, Food A - my 8oz filet was tasty, but not tender. Everything else, which was calamari special, Caesar salad, creamed spinach, tuna tartare, husbands porterhouse, daughters steak, butter cake for dessert, and cheesecake that was given to celebrate our anniversary- all worth it.
Tables a little close, it was a packed full house for a Sat night. Service was attentive with no need for improvement.
We will go back for sure as our tried and true steakhouse in NYC our last visit sadly left us feeling it was time to move on. That visit was prior to Covid, no excuse.
Great birthday evening
Shared a delicious dinner with my family. One of our favorite places. Christian was an incredible server made the meal even better
Amazing place. Service was fantastic and the food was spectacular and perfectly on point
Great food, great service. Broccoli was a little salty but still good.
My family went to celebrate my sons 17th birthday at the restaurant and we had an amazing time. The food was exquisite and delicious. The seafood tower was amazing and delicious. The steaks were made to perfection. I highly recommend Mastro’s steakhouse. Also, the service was excellent and they made sure the experience was perfect. Thank you
A bit noisy and it seemed short staffed but food is so good!!
Wonderful service wonderful food I will definitely return
I visited maestros in Scottsdale and thought that was terrific. NYC location exceed my prior experience. Best filet I ever had, sushi and apps spectacular!!! Theo our server was rock star. And we enjoyed the personal touch of having the chief visit tables to chat. I can’t say enough about our experience! It’s a must visit in NYC.
Greatness overall. Food, ambiance, service were all exquisite.
You can order delivery directly from Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City using the Order Online button. Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City also offers delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 459-1222.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City is rated 4.7 stars by 3482 OpenTable diners.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://mastrosrestaurants.cashstar.com/gift-card/buy/?ref=OT4.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.