Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City
Music was way too loud. Very difficult to have a conversation. Steaks were delicious and service was excellent.
My first experience was better but overall it was nice
Wonderful evening terrific service and incredible food.
Was brought to my table 10 minutes after reservation time, which is great for a Saturday night in Manhattan. Gave us enough time to enjoy cocktails at the beautiful bar. Service was immediate and continued to be on the money. Started with the Crab cocktail. Nice size portion and very fresh. Had the Kansas Bone-in strip which was outstanding. My wife had the NY strip. Had to send it back to be cooked a touch more, but came back perfect. 2nd time dining at Mastro’s, and it is definitely one of my favorite steakhouse’s.
* side note. My wife left her glasses there and when we called back the next day, they had found them and said they would mail them to us. If they don’t, might have to lower my rating a touch. Lol.*
Best restaurant ever. Going on my next trip to NY.
Great service we was running late and still got seated quickly food was great i love there lobster mash potatoes i wish they still had escargot on the menu but i will definitely be eating here agAin
Love the lobster Mac and sauté shrimp desert was wonderful
was my first time and love every hour of it
I’ll recomer to all my friends and family
Biggest complaint was the noise level on the main floor, both from the live and recorded music, I discovered that there is a large downstairs that was much quieter and would have suited my group much better. The live music was nice, if that was what you were expecting. Food was excellent, really!
They changed the menu, bring back the beef carpaccio
Disappointing service. Will not be back.
The food is incredible but the noise level made it impossible to visit with each other at the table. The band was entirely too loud. There is no reason music needs to be that loud in a place like Mastros. If I wanted to be in a club atmosphere then we would have gone to a nightclub. We wanted an enjoyable, romantic dinner. Our waitress was spread thin and running around trying to help multiple tables. This restaurant should have at least 2 servers assigned to each table. Unfortunately, this restaurant will not be on our list of repeats when we are in the city.
Food, Drinks and Service were excellent. The couple singing was great too. Really enjoyed everything!
Excellent food and service. We love to go back again and recommended to some friends who are traveling to NYC soon.
Our 7 guest had an amazing time overall, the food is delicious the services is top of the line, the live music is so energetic.
Our Server Angelica was very friendly, courteous and accommodating. as always the food is impeccable, music and singers were great and i enjoyed it all. Thanks again
Excellent steak house. The two downsides were the very dark decor (like eating in a cave) and the ridiculously loud and frankly obscene sound level of the music which consisted of blaring hip-hop and house music like we were at a disco. We asked to have it lowered and it was not.
The loud music was a horrible interference with what was a competently cooked and served upscale steakhouse meal. Luckily, live music came on later which was performed at appropriate sound levels and featured better song choices.
All in all a fair to good big city steakhouse meal. Better decor and appropriate sound levels could propel this restaurant to very good/excellent, but I doubt they will take the advice. The management certainly didn’t listen when we asked them to turn down the horrible noise, oops, we mean “music”.
The wait staff is very excellent, btw. And the desserts, especially the signature house dessert, are fantastic.
Amazing in every way. A memorable meal for sure. The only minor complaint is that we didn’t taste crab or truffle in our Alaskan king crab and black truffle gnocchi. The rest of our meal was so outstanding that it didn’t really bother us but it was a bit puzzling. Excellent courteous service.
Two dinners at Mastro’s in the last two months. The first was fantastic. Everything from food to service to ambiance was top notch. Overly impressed and happy. The second, even better then the first. Sat upstairs so had live music and everything was just awesome. Del Frisco’s used to be my go to steakhouse in NYC, but Mastro’s now stole that spot. Thank you Mastro’s.
Will never sit in the basement again
Excellent staff. From the hostess, the waiters . Great food & excellent presentation.
We have eaten at Mastro's in other cities and were expecting a good but not great evening. The NY restaurant was terrific. Great food. Great staff. They had a 3 piece music group who performed a wide array of music at a pleasant volume and with superb talent. That was a real bonus. Wine selection was unusual so we asked for help. There was no attempt to up-sell us and we were recommended a wine that fit our taste perfectly. We will be back.....often! Great job!
We had the best time! Everything was perfect. The food and drinks are definitely very pricey, but you know going in.
Era la sera di capodanno e nonostante questo sono stati velocissimi e precisi e la carne e’ davvero buonissima sopratutto il filetto !!!
We went for NYE and from beginning to end everything was fantastic. Great atmosphere, music, service and food. Our waiter Ronnie made the night extra special with his upbeat personality, smile and outstanding dining suggestions!
Great service and great food.
Waiter was really good and informative
It was a bit pricey for a family of 6 but it was New Year’s Eve
I think they could look at a discounted set menu in the early evening to entice families in.
But overall no real complaints
This meal was the best steak and side dishes in NYC!
It was amazing in every way.. and the live music was superb!!
Ronny was a great waiter!!! Amazing food and experience
Rachel was great and she also brought us a price of cake with happy anniversary!
We love this place!!
Everyone from the hostess (Jamie) to the waiter (I believe was Jasper) amazing. Such friendly and funny personalities. Our waiter knew his cuts of steak well and was well versed in knowing the menu. We really enjoyed ourselves & would definitely return. I highly recommend going hungry and booking a reservation.
Will be back. Fantastic in all areas. Wow!
Excellent food. Tim was great
First class experience and the food was phenomenal.
Our dinner was delicious. However, the wonderful food was somewhat overshadowed by our server who made it her number one goal to up-sell on everything. She even tried to talk our 11 year old into a more expensive appetizer. After we intervened and said no, she charged us for the up-sell anyway. We did not discover that until getting home and reviewing the receipt. I have called twice now asking for the manager and STILL have not received a callback. Disappointed.
Amazing all around!!!
I love the food and the atmosphere. The pricing is kind of on the high end but it’s worth it for those great drinks and the great peppercorn steak
Food and service was outstanding as usual. Mastro’s is always a great experience
They can’t do more for you at Mastro’s. Food is well prepared and presented. Sat us downstairs. Nowhere as nice as the upstairs. Prices should reflect eating in the basement.