Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City
8 oz or 12 oz
Scallops appetizer was amazing. Steaks were cooked perfectly. Service (Joe) was excellent.
Great job and following the actual social distancing rules!
And great food and drinks to boot. Thank you
Amazing my favorite steakhouse ever !
It was my friend’s 21st birthday and they made it very special
Experience with Mastros is always top notch. Nothing less to expect.
Food was excellent, service was even better.
The limited menu was a surprise, but the options were still good.
The outdoor seating wasn't so bad until what seemed like a garbage disposal truck a few buildings away was there working. Just nonstop noise.
My overall experience was great. Would definitely recommend. I came here for a birthday and would come for the next one.
First week of post quarantine outdoor dining. Everything tasted was very good and service was very accommodating especially Rachel who extended herself with her not so shy personality which was completely appreciated. Outdoor space was a good ways from the street and spacious.
Great to have table dining at this GREAT American steakhouse.
Although menu pared down for COVID- kitchen and staff didnt miss a beat.
This is the best steak house I’ve experienced in the heart of New York !
We had pork chops which were fantastic. So many ribs that I had to take them for two more meals. We ordered well done and they were exactly like we liked them. Wine options were wide enough and filled with good choices at all price points. They was a truck removing construction debris a couple of doors down but traffic was minimal as the restaurant is on a side street. All in all, it was outstanding (as was my experience at Mastro's Boston harbor location previously).
Awesome! One of my favorite restaurants in the country.
Outstanding food and service.
The band was amazing
We were scared To come out but it was my husbands 40th birthday
I’m soooooo glad we did
It was worth every dime
We started at the bar and had drinks. We split the large nine in filet which was cooked perfectly and the French fries. Everything was delicious! Great spot!
A welcoming place , great hospitality , food was 100% hot and very delicious .. music was beautiful
We booked for our wedding anniversary. We were not disappointed. Joseph our waiter could not have been more helpful. The steaks were very good and the wine list excellent.
The waitress was very kind and attentive she also serviced us very well
Food was excellent and our server went out of his way to be certain we were taken care of and gave us nice dessert touch for two birthdays.
Great location, friendly servers, and great music! They took care of my entire party with aplomb!
Live music was great! Tuna app was AMAZING!!! Good martini w/ blue cheese olives. Good overall. Would definitely go back again!
possibly the best steak in the NY area.... and the desserts are great too!
Great place!!! New York strip steak was amazing!!!
Food excellent, nice birthday surprise. I ordered a simple drink that took 4 times to get correct so was a bit awkward as i kept sending it back. To be specific, I ordered a dry gin martini up / twist (specifies no olives / no olive juice). They server kept coming back with a martini with olives / olive juice and it truly took 4 times to get correct.
I was understanding but a bit surprised that the server didn’t consider taking it off the bill.
Very nice dinner at Mastro’s food was great service was great. We ate in the main dining area upstairs which was nice. Downstairs seating did not look as nice
Was looking forward to a great steak and was not disappointed. I was disappointed in the loud music. Waitress was excellent and did tell me that "it is a loud" restaurant. Maybe I'm old fashioned, but if I'm dropping $300 plus for a fancy dinner, I want a quieter atmosphere. Food was excellent and service was great. Very pricey which I would have been okay with if quieter. If I want loud music I'll go to a bar or cheaper restaurant, not one I have to dress up for just to feel like I'm at a bar anyway.
We where a party of six on a Saturday @ 5:00pm. Food was delicious!! waitstaff constantly moving plates from you as guest are still eating, lots of interruption, felt rushed. Extremely loud music which caused voices to speak even louder. The lighting was so dark flashlights where given to guest in order to read menus. Prices are very high but expected. If your looking for a calm relaxing steak place Mastros is not the place.
We went for my boyfriend’s birthday. Our server was the bomb! He told us about all the great and popular dishes and let me say he did a great job with that. Everything was to die for. My boyfriend enjoyed it as much as I did. The food was amazinggg!!!! If you love lobster and Mac try their lobster Mac & cheese, the lobster mash was also delicious. Their steak was so good, juicy and tender and cooked just right. I just can’t wait until we go back and eat there again such a great choice. Trust me you will leave there wanting to go back the very next day LOL.
We had An experience this evening. I made a reservation to celebrate my wife’s birthday and noted that we had to cancel her birthday trip to Paris due to the global pandemic. We walk in, Angie welcomes us by name and provides us with customized menus with a welcome to Paris label and a little Eiffel Tower. The service was impeccable, the drinks flowed, the meal was off the charts, and they gave us desert for 4! 🙏🏾. Thank you for making our experience forget about our cancelled vacation for a couple of hours. We’ll be back again very soon!
This place is such fun! I typically don’t like steak places but this is the exception. Not stuffy like most, you can tell everyone there is having a good time and loving the food and atmosphere. We had the wedge salad that was loaded with blue cheese and bacon, fantastic, and the crabmeat cocktail was superb. I asked for a spicy mayo for it that was not on the menu and they delivered! The service was exceptional, and live music was a an unelected plus!
The food and ambiance was amazing! We enjoyed everything we ordered. The staff was very attentive and we will visit when we come back again!
Hookers hanging out in the lobby. Poor culture of people.
Great experience. Waiter was on point and very attentive. Recommend the bone in filet which was amazing. Will definitely be back.
Amazing food, service and atmosphere! Would come back again!
Absolutely loved it
It was our first time at Mastro's and I will definitely go back. I highly recommend this restaurant from the waitstaff to their food.
My son’s birthday
Absolutely loved atmosphere, food and service. Music selection great I just wish it was a little less loud downstairs since i was entertaining customers but overall loved and will return. This location much nicer than the Florida location which just has water view
We were seated next to the band and bar and were told other seating was not available. If I did not make a reservation I would have been fine with the table, but I was disappointed we were treated as walk-ins.
Very nice food. And a lot of food.
We almost exploded because of de quantity of the food.
We had the most wonderful meal and service at Mastro’s. My filet was probably the best I have ever eaten, the lobster mashed potatoes were incredible and the cocktails were very tasty. I definitely will go back the next time we are in NYC
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 459-1222.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City is rated 4.7 stars by 3031 OpenTable diners.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://mastrosrestaurants.cashstar.com/gift-card/buy/?ref=OT4.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.