Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City
Tyrell our waiter was outstanding !!!
Nick the manager was very hands on and attentive !!!
Unfortunately it was very noisy from the music !!!
One of our favorite restaurants in NYC! Delicious food, cocktails, great entertainment. Perfect place to have a delicious meal and spend the entire evening. The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars is because it was my birthday celebration and my Fiancée told the waitress we didn’t want to be rushed. Every time we needed something we had to ask someone to get her, totally inattentive.
I have been coming here when I’m in town. I was very disappointed at our last dinner. Service needed improvement and food was just ok. For the price of the dinner, I should have received much better service. Since coming here, I’ve notice a decline in the service.
Awesome costumer service
The food was amazing. We were celebrating a birthday. Service was impeccable. Loved our experience.
The food and service were perfection. If there is anything I would change, it would be to make it not so dark.
The experience was unparalleled to any steakhouse I have been to in NYC. Great decorum, amazing service, and the food was outstanding. Worth every penny spent!
Noise level too high. Made for impossible conversation for party of 6.
Our server Ronnie was EXCELLENT! And all the ladies at the hostess stand were very helpful.
Great food, as always. The steak was perfect and the butter cake to die for. Great ambience, and the band was very good. The noise level was on the high side.
Very impressive ace yo eat. The best steak I have ever eaten. Had an 18oz fillet on bone....cut through like butter..yummy.
I would definitely come here again to try more food . Portions are extremely generous. Food comes out on a piping hot plate. Service absolutely first class. Pricy but well worth it. A live band was playing softly in the background. Please dont visit NYC without coming here.
PHENOMENAL! I took my wife for birthday dinner and was quite pleased when she ordered the scallops with caviar and devoured the entire plate. She is a picky eater! The food was absolutely delicious and the portions were big so needless to say we had Mastro’s twice. I highly recommend this restaurant.
Was at Mastros with a co-worker/friend, we shared the Calamari as an appetizer and it was so delicious and fresh, we each had drinks the Whiskey a go go was delicious, we shared the rack of lamb and the lobster mashed potatoes, everything was exquisite, we ended the night with the butter cake and it was recommended by our awesome waiter and he was right it was fabulous. there was live entertainment which was the cherry on top of a great meal. can't wait return! thank you so much to our server and the chefs!
One of our favorite places to dine when visiting NYC. Food and drinks are always AMAZING! Nice ambiance and live music. Great place to celebrate any occasion.
It was good , fine service
Very outstanding service. Food was super amazing and filling. Highly recommend restaurant to dine at. Beautiful atmosphere. Can’t wait to go back again.
It was wonderful experience but didn’t appreciate the fact that we sat all the way by the kitchen door where people were constantly coming in and out. Also, the lighting is way too dimmed. The “Dream Berry” is AMAZING!
1st Anniversary meal.
Great service, huge portions, one of the best steaks ever
Amazing food and service. We were sittings close to the live band, so it was very noisy (although we could still talk to each other). I love this steakhouse, and will continue to come here every time I have the chance.
They continue to impress great energy and food under one roof
The restaurant was very dark - we had to use our phones to see the menu. THAT was my only complaint! Great food, service, & live music. Will definitely come again.
Surprisingly not on par with the other Mastro’s I’ve enjoyed in Scottsdale and Palm Desert. The band was way too loud for a dinner hour, so we were seated in a downstairs dining room. This made service very slow. My steak was cut in thin slices for no reason. It was surprisingly disappointing.
James was great!
When the appetizers came, I think 4 people served the food AND served portions to our plates.
It was crazy and awesome.
Mastro’s is on my Open Table favorites now.
Celebrated our pre anniversary dinner! Our filets were amazing! Love music was on point, great food, great service and good music! Perfect date!
We celebrated our 2nd Wedding Anniversary at Mastro’s Steakhouse on Labor Day weekend. The entire staff along with the manager, Chris Puleo, was amazing. We will be celebrating more at this restaurant for years to come! The live music was top tier on the Saturday evening too!
Beautiful place wonderful food great customer service A+
Good food. Asked for quiet area. Only problem could not hear conversations. Did not come to be drowned out by music.
Outstanding. Everything about the experience was outstanding. We went on a Friday night with live music, which was OUTSTANDING. Can’t say enough. A must go to restaurant. Cheers 🍻
One of our favorites
Joe our waiter was the best I have ever experienced. We sat downstairs and the atmosphere was perfect. Great steaks as always but the salads and sides were fantastic. Could not have had a better time. Thanks for the great time and great food.
We try and eat here whenever in the city. Food and service are outstanding. It is loud and a bit hard to hear, especially with the live music.
Great steak. Cooked perfectly. Nice live music which adds to the experience
Great place for dinner in the city. Food and service are always awesome!
The best tasting steak but very dark inside. Needed a flash light to read the menu and wine label.
Incredible service and quality steaks. The experience was spot on and you feel valued.
Best bone in filet EVER. Prepared with truffle butter and served on those sizzling hot plates was just amazing. Great flavor. Also, the wild mushrooms and lobster Mac and Cheese were spectacular. Definitely coming back! Server Joanna from Colombia was also very attentive and excellent!
Michael was excellent
Erin our waiter was superb
Be ready for a loud meal. The check in was disorganized, the server was polite but not well informed about all aspects of the menu. They have a band playing which was fun but coupled with the open area on the main floor it was loud. Lighting was too low. My wife’s escargot were like Rubber, my $13 baked potato was not hot (butter barely melted) and our steaks were very flavorful but were drenched in seasoning that almost seemed like a light sauce - we weren’t advised of that in the menu or by the server. I have eaten at all the best steakhouse in NYC and nationally as well. IMO if our experience was normal for this chain then this chain isn’t in my top ten. The drink menu was the best I’ve ever seen. The prices are very high even for nyc. I wouldn’t go back. I don’t mind spending money on a meal but the meal needs to warrant it and it didn’t here.