This includes info about cleaning, sanitizing, social distancing, and usage of personal protective equipment. Learn more.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Signature Warm Butter Cake
Lobster Mashed Potatoes
I went there for my 27th Birthday with my father and cousin. Our server name was Theo. He was the best. We had a really good time. Will definitely come back.
The food was bland and in need some flavor. I don’t feel I got my money’s worth.
Let me start by saying that I truly understand that the pandemic is taking its toll on all restaurants and I try to adjust my expectations accordingly. My birthday dinner was a huge disappointment. We chose to eat outside thinking that Mastro’s would do their best to try and create a great great experience for their outside diners. Instead we were treated as an afterthought. Stuck outside in what could only be described as someone’s used backyard furniture. No lighting, no music, no staff, no heater’s and not one manager outside the whole evening. We have eaten here several times and knew what we wanted to order however our waiter could barely spend time outside long enough to take our order. No specials, nothing but constant upsellling. He sold us bechamel sauce for our steak only to bring it with truffle butter instead saying they didn’t have bechamel. No apology no attempt to assist. He was upset when we didn’t order sides and when the steak was removed it took15 min to come back to the table. We ordered oysters and four of them came with little to no meat. Just not what you would expect for a nearly $400 meal. Apparently the waiter doesn’t need the money or we just didn’t spend enough to make it worthwhile. The table next to us who were friends with the busboy got great service. We thought we were doing a great thing supporting one of our favorites. It doesn’t seem to matter to them. If you want to stay open be appreciative of those braving the cold to support you.
Amazing food and service
Only thing I didn’t like that I found it weird they sat everyone upstairs and me and my boyfriend down stairs just me and him I felt a little colorist going on idk not sure but overall had a good experience 10/10
Food was excellent
Great meal! Tequila selection could be much better.
Food excellent, service excellent. Everything great. Have to go back
It’s was my boyfriend’s birthday so we went for dinner. The vibe was amazing the food was superb and the costumers service was 100% fabulous
The server was great and the food was amazing as usual.
The restaurant is entirely too cold and it’s always cold when I go there.
Best food and drinks. The warm butter cake is a must!!!
The food was amazing. The waitress was great made sure we were good at all times
Our server was excellent as was our meal, however, I was disappointed to observe that all guests that happened to be people of color were seated downstairs with ample seating available upstairs. Apparently, this is a thing at this NYC staple, because of this I likely will not be back.
Unfortunate to be in 2020 and still see blatant signs of racism. I'll add that I'm so used to being marginalized that it took my white friend to say why are there only black people downstairs. We went upstairs to make sure this wasn't just a coincidence and there was no presence.
Wonderful! My Godson and I enjoyed the food and drinks and our waiter, Joe. He was exemplary!
ONE OF THE BEST PLACES EVER!!!
BEST WAITER EVER!!!
The whole experience was just excellent! Nothing I can womp main about the food, service, drinks, ambiance definitely worth the money and this is now my new favorite steakhouse.
amazing food. amazing service. live music and quick!
I love the life music, we really enjoy and the food was great.
Great food, atmosphere waiter good service nice music 🎶
The food was great and the Live music was great
Completely understand the Covid challenges however other first class restaurants in the city and even more main stream restaurants have done far better in designing outdoor space not to mention you have the luxury of a grand plaza space to utilize. Given the price point of Mastro‘s I would’ve expected a little more effort in this area.
Also service was by far below par from what I’ve experienced at mastros previously. Table was not cleared of dirty dishes between courses. Dessert menu was not brought but just verbalized to us as “this is all we got”. Had to chase down waiter even though he was in plain sight lollygagging at other tables or at hostess stand.
I think I had very high hopes for this steakhouse. Everyone said it’s the best in the city so I was super pumped to try it for my birthday! All in all, everything was good except everything was a tad too salty and all 5 of us agreed from the steaks to the potatoes. The best part of the meal was their butter cake at the end- delicious!!!
We love mastros. The steak is always delicious. The menu is slightly different, and missing some items we usually get but still great selection.
Great.... especially if you going out on a date
Wonderful food and the area to eat is pretty good.
Excellent food with outstanding service. In this pandemic time, Mastro's was an excellent choice to enjoy an evening out.
Me and my lovely girlfriend had another exceptional dinner at Mastro’s steakhouse .. we love it so much , always leave there full !
I really enjoyed the service. Even though it was outside, everything was great.
This place is amazing. The food , the service .. everything was amazing.
Great, steak was on point and a speedy service
The waiter was not properly wearing his face mask. We had to wait a considerable amount of time to order and the fish (salmon) was tasteless.
It was my husband’s birthday so we went to Mastro’s had an amazing dinner service was good except for us having to ask for a few certain things several times before they bring them and we did wait a long time for food but the food was delicious but very pricey
Came here for my 21st birthday with a few of my girlfriends! Great food, our waiter was so friendly & helpful! Made me consider coming back again the later on this week! Plus the social distancing for outside dining was great. Wasn’t too close to people & all workers wore masks! Thanks for the best 21st birthday dinner, will definitely be back soon!
Mastro's is always a great place to visit. However, maybe its due to the pandemic and needing to increase revenue but I prefer the experience when the dress code is maintained. It goes a long way in ensuring the ambience and experience is consistent with expectations. People wearing hoodies, sneakers or shorts is not what I would expect.
Amazing food Amazing service Will be returning for sure
Loyal customer and never fails . 2 thumbs up
Joe was AWESOME. He kept checking in without being intrusive
Everything was great ! Salmon was kind of bland but overall I was overly satisfied! Great birthday for me !!
Food was amazing! Definitely will be going back soon!
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 459-1222.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City is rated 4.7 stars by 3108 OpenTable diners.
Mastro's Steakhouse - New York City does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://mastrosrestaurants.cashstar.com/gift-card/buy/?ref=OT4.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.