Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Mastro's Signature Warm Butter Cake
New York Pepper Steak
Our table was part-way blocking another room and also by a waiter station. It was a high traffic area and our table seemed to be in the way. Not exactly the feeling you want to have when experiencing fine dining.
We went for Father’s Day, for our first time! We love Preston’s, and Steak 44 so we figured this would be just as good, if not better! The tables are so close together no lie my husband couldn’t even push his chair because the guy behind us was super tall and couldn’t push his chair in. He was so embarrassed and said he was so sorry but there wasn’t enough room, luckily my husband could squeeze in but still pretty crazy for the ambiance of a fancier restaurant to stuff you in like sardines. We got the wedge salad, delicious, the bone in rib eye, which we added the truffle butter too…I’ll be honest without the butter the steak was eh ok, with the butter it was amazing! The mashed potatoes were great too! I don’t know if I’ll come back with Steak44 located pretty close to here, I feel like their overall space and steak is a bit better. It was nice to try something new though, and our server was top notch, he was super sweet to my son, and took time to explain everything to us newbies!
Great service excellent food. Restaurant was a bit warm inside but it was very busy,
I love this place. Its my favorite steak house in the valley!!!
Waiter forgot about the appetizer but by then it was too late. Potatoes wasn’t hot.
Definitely not the classy place I once remember. Girls walking around in bras and jeans. Incredibly loud, late for our reservation, and so hot I couldn’t wait to leave and put the AC on in the car. Definitely expect more from a restaurant that costs over $300 for two people. Food was delicious as always, and our server was wonderful. Other Thant hat the experience defiantly fell flat of my expectations.
Took my wife for her Birthday. We had been planning for weeks to get the Kobe steaks. Mastro's did not disappoint, the steaks were melt in your mouth delicious. All of the food was amazing. We can't wait to come back.
Mastro's has lost its way. Even though reservations made weeks in advance, we were seated in an overflow room with no ambiance, views or patrons to watch. Table was right next to service station leading to interruptions, noise and distractions. Dirty dishes were not cleared timely, in fact, one server just pushed our salad plates to the center of the table waiting for another to clear them much later. After salads, main course took over 40 minutes to arrive, with the waiter eventually and literally pointing at our table with the restaurant manager to offer apologies. A cocktail on the house hardly made up for the unpleasant evening. We will not return.
Fantastic dining experience. Excellent customer service. The meals were prepared to perfection! The scallops were PHENOMENAL. The lobster bisque melted in your mouth. The chopped salad was refreshing. The filet mignon was perfectly seasoned, aged to perfection and cooked exquisitely. The A5 Waygu was this buttery melt in your mouth bliss. Oh the side were amazing. Too it all off with the Fire and Mango elixir for a perfect meal. Oh the ice cream topped butter cake was quite possibly the best dessert I have ever tasted. All around perfect dining experience!!!
I love coming to Mastro's because the food and drinks are always great. I also have several severe allergies/anaphylaxis. The staff always goes out of their way to make sure my food is safe, and they don't make me feel like an inconvenience.
AC was out and the heat coming off the plates made it even hotter. The lobster Mac and cheese was awful.
Lovely dinner as always. Sat near the bar and it was incredibly loud- a little too much in the beginning. Overall love this place and will always come back.
Superb food and drink. Waitress kept upselling us. Everything was great but we ordered way too much food, and at $40 for a side of gnocchi, not worth it. The lobster mac n cheese at $40 is plenty for 5ppl. Some of the wait staff was actually rude when they brought our plates and brought put the wrong entree in front of the wrong people. Also they were difficult when boxing up our many leftovers. Crowded and noisy. I would go back though because the food and drink were so amazing, but I'd rather it was quieter.
Excellent place for a fancy date with the SO. Highly reccommend.
It’s a good experience. The dry aged steak is definitely worth trying. Drinks are amazing.
The food and service was amazing! My only complaint was how hot it was inside.
Poor service. Tables Uncleaned and a mess for 1 hour all around us.
A little to loud for me. The food and service was great.
Loved the experience! Fine dining at it's best. We will return many times!
Food and service were amazing!
The crowd on a Friday evening was less than ideal.
Great bar seating for a celebration dinner. Loved the food and the steaks were cooked perfectly. Thanks for a great evening!
Very pleasant experience, entrees were extremely delicious
Food was fantastic. Filet Mingon was perfect and very flavorful
Just awful. It’s a hotspot indeed. Great to people watch, but overcrowded with poor service, mediocre food, dark and noisy. So obviously people don’t go there for the food or a business meeting. Lesson learned.
Ironically the ambiance grade is low DUE to being too noisy (or energetic as you call it) in the dining room, food was great...service was greatest!!!
Outstanding food and atmosphere!!! Ribeye was perfect. The Mac and cheese is so amazing, The picture I took didn’t come out. Must try though.
Waiter forgot our appetizer order, served our entrees right away. Wanted to have a longer, more relaxed dinner, turned out into a rushed get in, get out dinner. Food was awesome though
Chris our server was awesome. He went the extra mile to make sure that everything during our meal was perfect.
Mastro’s City Hall Steakhouse is an excellent restaurant for any occasion. The steaks are consistently great and grilled to perfection. The service is excellent and the BEST steakhouse in the United States…yes, the United States!
Server dropped food in my expensive drink and did not ask to take it off the bill. Not a big deal but the overall lack of attention and only interested in up selling on special butter or drinks (pretty aggressive) made you feel like you were being taken advantage. Hard to enjoy dinner with a hard sell on you and your date. I will not go back. Steak was delicious however.
City Hall was so wonderful for our son’s birthday! They customized the menu to say “Happy Birthday Carter” on it! The service was fantastic- very attentive and accommodating with special diet issues!
We went for after dinner drinks Monday night and had an amazing time. The butter cake was a bit different than I remember, but it was still yummy! I guess I prefer it a bit more crispy on the outside, and soft only on the inside. We still had an amazing time, thank you
We had the most disappointing experience. We have been to this location and other Mastro's many times, but this occasion was sub-par. The service was below average with the waiter not coming by much and waiting a long time to check on us, the side dishes were brought to the table minutes after already having served the main course and no one served the sides. Instead, they were dropped on the table and not presented in the normal fashion. The tuna tartar did not taste as fresh as usual, the tomatoes in the burrata salad were over-ripened and the filet that was ordered medium, came out closer to well-done. The Manager came over and apologized and took care of the bill so it was handled appropriately and with the focus on customer service that should have been there from the beginning. Sadly, even though it was comped, the butter cake (my most favorite dessert ever) wasn't even as excellent as it usually is. The consistency of the cake was mealy and not as dense or fresh as it usually is and the whipped cream didn't even taste the same.
The restaurant was not busy, but something was definitely off that night.
Fabulous Scottsdale upscale Steakhouse. Great martinis.
Great service. Great food.
Have been going there for almost 20 years have never had a problem
The cosmo and wine selection was very good (but a $20 bottle of wine selling at $60?).
The bone-in ribeye was excellent, but the lobster tails were flavorless and the worst we ever had. The $14 creamed corn side should have been sent back since it was terrible and the lobster mashed potatoes were runny and flavorless. We should have sent the mashed potatoes back too. Definitely not worth $440 for two.
You can order delivery directly from Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse using the Order Online button. Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse also offers delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (480) 941-4700.
Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse is rated 4.5 stars by 4127 OpenTable diners.
Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://mastrosrestaurants.cashstar.com/gift-card/buy/?ref=OT4.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.