Margaritas Cafe - Port Jefferson Station
It is a mecca for all types of food. We separate Margarita’s Cafe from the rest of the pack because of our attention to detail.
From the opening of our first restaurant, we worked to create an atmosphere that takes you away from the mundane.
We have spared no expense in acquiring one of a kind decor to surround our customers as they dine.
Every choice of silverware, item on the menu or drinks we create are designed to give our customers the illusion of dining while on vacation.
The only thing missing is the warm summer breezes & ocean waves.
Waited over 1 1/2 hours for dinner that never arrived. Drinks and appetizers were great. We finally paid the check and left without getting our dinners. They took the dinners off the check. Been here many times before. This never happened in the past. Guess they just had a bad night.
What a terrible experience. Waited two in a half hours and received no food. Asked the server and manager kept saying the kitchen is backed up and it would be out in few minutes. Decided to leave. Never in my life have a terrible experience where the manager never resolves the problem or helps in anyways. People who sat after us received food and that just tips off the problem. Probably never but the food ticket in to begin with. So glad my anniversary was ruined.
Fantastic food, great service and beautiful ambiance. Can't recommend this place enough to anyone who enjoys great food, good music and fantastic service.
The food and margaritas are always excellent there. They had dividers between the tables, so the dining was safe. The waitress and staff were very friendly. We enjoyed the live music, a singer with her guitar. Great night overall.
The food is always very good. Had a new server tonight so I am sure things will get better. The meal did not come out all together and we had to wait for the last person to be served.
Great place. Love it.
The service was fantastic. Martina was bubbly, friendly and attentive. The food was good and the drinks were good. I prefer a strong drink, so I would’ve liked my cocktails better if they had a little more kick. The three piece band was awesome, though they- and the music playing during their breaks- were loud. The guacamole was delicious!
Great music, great food, great friends
We went here under the auspice that a Mariachi band would be playing. Unfortunately due to COVID that wasn’t the case. Glad we went and found a new place to enjoy Mexican cuisine. Food was good, a bit pricey but would go back.
Everything was what we expected except for the drinks . We ordered frozen margaritas and it just tasted like flavored ice. We couldn't tell if they put tequila in them.
The menu on open table is 100% different from what the menu is in person. We did not care, but someone who wanted what was on the menu could be really disappointed. The waiter gave us the check without even asking us about dessert. Other than that, it was good.
Food was good service was good. Would definitely gk again.
We go to Margaritas Cafe often. They never disappoint! The food is excellent, the service is great! I highly recommend!
My husband and I had dinner Thursday for my birthday, everything was great. Food was delicious, service was great and the place is bright and clean. I would definitely recommend this place.
Allen, Anna and the rest of the team were excellent in every way. The food was perfect. Thank you.
Food was excellent, the two piece band was a bit loud during dinner with friends
it was hard to get attention of staff to be seated, they were very inattentive once we got our service, food took forever to come out - we got the fajitas and they were cold, ive never have cold fajitas before, but none of the staff had any idea what tables they had and who was doing what - very poor service and terrible food
Very satisfied. Left a large tip!
Margaritas has excellent Mexican food! I particularly like the skirt steak tacos. They usually have live performers on Saturday night and that is always pleasant. My only complaint and suggestion would be to order a pitcher of margaritas because the drinks don’t come out fast. But they are good!
The food is very good. Service is a bit slow, but not otherwise bad. They could sell more drinks if they were faster. But the staff is nice and the food quite good.
The host was great. We reserved a high top table and they didn’t have one. It wasn’t a big deal until they stuck us right in front of the entrance/exit. It wasn’t the end of the world but would have fathered a different table. I spoke to the host and he was a complete gentleman. As soon as the next person left he sat my wife and I at a nicer location. Service was great, the food was good. We eat here often, but was the first time using open table to book reservations.
great service ,food was great,prices very good.Manager was very nice.he keep on checking on us
making sure everything was ine
Went with a Mexican friend who said the food was authentic and yummy. But the band played billy Joel! Very good but not what we expected
The live music tends to be too loud!!! The stage is very close to the tables therefore volume should be adjusted. One is not able to converse.
Friday night at 730pm. We were seated right away, but put all the way in the back by the bathroom with wait staff walking past every 30 seconds. Pretty annoying. Shrimp taco's were great, spicy margs were fantastic and our waiter was knowledgeable. Will def go back again sometime.
A terrific find for a Mexican food restaurant. The food was tasty and well prepared. The service was excellent and the staff attentive and polite.
Alan is a great host. We were greeted warmly and seated our favorite table #17.
Breanna provided us with impeccable service.
Thank you, Margarita Cafe.
I had requested table #17 however they did not reserve it for me, Inspite of the fact the restaurant was not busy!! Disappointing.
Alan was welcoming and our waiter was great.
Love this place. Both food and drink are fantastic.
My vegetarian choice of Poblano peppers was very disappointing. It was over filled with some sorts of greens and I couldn’t even taste the Poblano peppers!! I did point it out to Allen, the Manager.
The Margaritas were excellent tonight.
Brea, our waitress was wonderful.
We go to this restaurant very often. This time the service was very disappointing. The waiter was disinterested, inattentive and bored looking. We waited for our food fir about 45 mins. Without anyone being aware of it when we brought it to the Mangers attention he tried to recover the situation by sending unwanted round of drinks!!!! Wasted since we couldn’t drink them!!!! We will give them another chance!!
I liked this restaurant, the food was good. We arrived and they had our table waiting with our reservation. They however Forgot to bring out the our appetizer, and the music was so loud we couldn’t hear each other over the table.
Margaritas Cafe - Port Jefferson Station does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Margaritas Cafe - Port Jefferson Station also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 642-8555.
Margaritas Cafe - Port Jefferson Station is rated 4.3 stars by 32 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.