MADISONS New York Grill & Bar

The food, service and ambiance was excellent. We will be happy to go back again.

Lucas our server was exemplary. Food was delicious. Environment was perfect.

We came at 7:10 for a 7:15 reservation. We were told we could sit outside immediately or wait inside for 20 minutes. I was told that the reason we had to wait is because we made the reservations on Open Table. We waited until 7:45 for our table even though we requested an inside table. The service was slow. My Lamb Chops were well done even though I asked for them medium. This was not a positive experience and we will not be back.

We came in for a 7pm reservation and were seated right away at a booth by the bar. It was so noisy and since there were table and booths upstairs I asked to change the table. I was told it was for the 7pm reservations which we had. We just got there 10 minutes early. At our table people came in and standing over us using their cell phones and talking like were home. It was awful. My husbands food was ok. My food was terrible and very buttery. I told them it was our anniversary when I made the reservation. Some special Anniversary.

Had what was advertised as a rib eye steak, but it seemed to be an 8oz. bland filet mignon. Very meaty taste.

We had such a wonderful experience Friday we came back again on Saturday! Evan and Stephanie were our servers both outstanding and attentive. Food is always excellent. We come over from the East Coast of Florida a few times and your and Madison’s is the only place we wind up going. Everything is consistently wonderful.

The service was extremely poor. When asked to speak to the manager, he was reluctant to speak with us. We asked for a card and he never had the courtesy to come back to the table. This was a birthday celebration. We will think twice before going back to the restaurant

I enjoyed our birthday celebration Sat. night. Everything was great!

Steak deal was good

Staff is outstanding from the front to the wait staff!

Excellent lunch as always. One of the best lunch menus and venues in Boca.

I had a 7:15 reservation at madisons made thru open table on saturday nite
We arrived and they told us we had to sit outside because during busy times that’s where open table patrons could sit. It was 90 degrees and we did not want to sit outside. They did not honor our reservation made thru your site. We ended up sitting at the bar which did not require reservations
Why didn’t they honor our reservation. We were not told in advance that if they were busy we would have to sit outside because we made reservation on open table

Waiter was terrific, foo delicious,we will come back soon

Sat near open kitchen
Very noisy
It was very disturbing since the male general manager keep yelling at a girl.

Good all around!

We had a delightful late lunch/earlly supper. Just the right time to go to a restaurant. The food was delicious and the service was excellent.

We dine at Madisons frequently and always enjoy the experience. We especially like it because it is not as crowded as some local restaurants.

Consistently good food & service!

Food was good, but not exceptional. I had read on their website about their early bird that included a salad and 2 sides, available until 5:30. When we got there, we were told that they changed it to no salad, just one side, and ending at 5:00. The hostess told me that they hadn’t yet changed the website to reflect the new policy. Not a good business practice.

Beware that the Early Bird Menu posted on the website is not the same as currently offered at the restaurant. The menu on the website says you must be seated by 5:30pm. That has been changed to 5:00pm. We arrived at 5:15pm and were told we were too late. The manager allowed us to have that menu but only after we were scolded and told it was a one time only exception. Also the offerings on that menu previously included a salad and two sides. Now, the Early Bird menu includes only one side and a soft drink. Salad and a second side are now extra. Also the steak, which previously was a New York Strip steak on the Early Bird menu is now the "butchers choice". The server did not know what kind of steak was being served and was unwilling to run to the kitchen to find out. So two in our party gambled and got small petite sirloins. The servers should be briefed on this. Otherwise the food was tasty and served hot. As for atmosphere, we had been warned by friends to ask for a quiet location, and we were assigned to a table quite close to the noisy bar. When we asked the hostess to be relocated to one of the multitude of empty tables in the quiet section, we were ignored. Our server, however, was kind and moved us to a quieter location. The experience was frustrating overall, and I doubt that we will return

The French onion soup was overcooked - dried out, too thick. The green beans were too wet. The steak was great. Service was just OK, not as attentive as it should have been for a nite when the restaurant was not busy.

Came for my husbands birthday it was completely dead however took 15min just for water and bread
No good steak on the menu we went elsewhere

Love my chicken salad there, but it is always inconsistent. Sometimes, I am overjoyed with the portion, and I end of taking some home for lunch, the next day, and sometimes, my entree salad is so small, that I leave there hungry. Can't figure it out! I always loved this place. My husband loves the chicken and ribs combo, and the same thing happens with his entree. Sometimes they give him a nice big grilled chicken breast, and sometimes, the piece of chicken is so small, it almost doesn't look bigger than a tidbit.
Overall, we like this restaurant because it is bright, love the booths, and love the service!

Great food, great drinks, great staff. For sure an older environment with the majority of visitors being 55+.

Not the most modern architecture as it makes you believe from the exterior of the building.

It is quite the niche experience

Food very good
pricey
loud

Always enjoy the food and ambiance whether having dinner or just happy hour.

It was soo bad I don’t know that we’d really want to go back.
We were seated at a table that had people literally hanging over our heads. The noise was unbearable. We could not talk to each other as the conversations above us were so loud we New what they were talking about.
The waitress was very sweet and understood the problem and we asked the hostess to reseat us.
BUT, instead (we were 6) she seated a party of two at that very large table.
A short while late, while two in our party were still eating their salads, the waitress came to move us to a table in the bar area.
This was a LATE accommodation that really took away from what should have been a lovely evening out to dinner with friends.
MADISONS is a restaurant that we and our friends frequent
I must tell you, we were making plans with two other couples for later this month and when they suggested MADISONS, we responded
“Go without us, we’ll join you another night another place.”
This is a very sad commentary....please, in the future, when you have a party on the upper level, think twice about putting a group of six right under them.
Thank you for letting me be honest....I hope MADISONS can make sure this doesn’t happen to anyone else.

This was a very disappointing experience. I made the reservation a week in advance to celebrate one of our friend's birthday. We arrived and there was large group of people around a table that had been set with a roulette and everybody in that group was standing around it. The sat us right behind the group. They were standing, chatting with drinks in their hands, and making it difficult for the waiters to pass by and take care of other customers, us included. We couldn't have a conversation. They were making a lot of noise. There must have been close to 30 people in that group. Food was god, as usual. Our waitress did the best she could, and we appreciated her, but when we were leaving we asked to speak to the manager. When he came, we told him we were disappointed. That they should have contained the group somewhere where they didn't inconvenience the rest of the diners, but his reaction was not even a 'sorry for your inconvenience', nothing apologetic. He just shrugged and looked at us as if "tough, nothing I could do". Not happy, not happy at all!

The Tuna Steak was amazing and the service was great

The grilled octopus appetizer is amazing - a must every time we go to MADISONS. Great staff and good value. Our party of 6 thoroughly enjoyed the food and ambiance.

Food was good with plentiful portions
Waiter was a bit stiff and didn’t seem to have any answers to questions.
Maybe he was new.
Seats are comfortable.
We ate at 7 so happy hour was over and place was not jammed

Wonderful lunch with great service by Lucas.Very well run restaurant with very good food and service .

Just ok food was nothing special

It has become very disappointing to select some entrees from the menu as they are small sized portions which high price tags. The steaks with bones have been eliminated, the French dip was very fatty, the pork chop (singular) was on the menu as pork chops and priced at $ 33.00. When we questioned it, we were told they do it by weight, so the one chop was said to be 10 or 12 oz. (I forget) - however, it was not quite that size. Our weekly visit (I still love the onion soup) will change and unless the menu changes and other things, our attendance will also change.

Shared the octopus appetizer. So good we fought over the last bites. I had a Beautifully prepared beet goat cheese salmon salad for the main course and my companion a large chopped salad. We shared a rich desert. An excellent meal!

We were pleasantly surprised at the variety of food from salads sandwiches and burgers to steaks and fish. Some of the food like fish was reasonably priced and quite delicious. However, the prime rib sandwich was tasty but quite pricy for the size for the sandwich. The service, however , was outstanding. We had a young child with us and the staff was very attentive and caring

Spairibs and trout. I sent the trout back had a heavy fish smell, I ordered the steak salad with dressing on the side, came with the dressing on the salad. Was very disappointed I. Overall experience

Good but not great, a couple of dishes came to the table and were sent back. Would try again

Server and manager very attentive. Ate outside with happy hour pricing. Steak dinner an excellent value. Inside a little noisey

We had a lovely lunch. There were a lot of nice choices to pick from and we enjoyed our choices. The service was quick, efficient and very pleasant.