Macelleria Italian Steakhouse

Saturday night service way too slow

Amazing place in Pelham, service from Vinnie was absolutely exceptional. Food was delicious all around from apps to entrees to drinks, and the tiramisu was delicious not sure if it’s bought or made there but delicious. Highly recommend stopping by for a nice meal in a not so overbearing restaurant... 100% better than Benjamin’s - if you were choosing between the two, in all aspects to be frank. Friendly staff, savory steak. Will be back to give the pastas a shot.

It's good go to spot for great food and excellent service. Friendly owners that make you feel like family. Highly recommend this place.

Food was delicious. Overpriced seafood appetizer

The food, wine and services were excellent. We enjoyed it very much.

Just a Friday night out!

Food and service are always outstanding. The Spicy Mussel appetizer was off the charts.

Belated Mother’s Day

We have eaten here several times pre-CoVID and always enjoyed it. On this visit, the cheapest bottle of wine was $75, and there seemed to be on 3-4. Otherwise, $95 and up. This is ridiculous for a neighborhood restaurant in a suburban NYC town. Steak tartare appetizer used excellent quality beef, but it had not been seasoned the way this dish is usually served. Very bland. Scallops as main course were fine, but we make better and tastier grilled scallops at home. Restaurant was full, but the noise was so loud you could barely hear conversation at your own table. Not sure we'll be going back any time soon, esp for the outrageous markup on the wine and the now average food.

I really enjoyed this restaurant, the clams appetizer was very tasty, and you get a pretty good amount.
My Rib Eye was cooked perfectly.
They had really good side sauces to go with it also, but the steak really didnt need it the taste was great.
All the service was on top of everything and Besim was very friendly, funny.
Will be back again soon.

The steak (we split a porterhouse) was fantastic. Shared the scallop and octopus appetizers so it was a great mix of surf and turf meal. The service was professional and fun at the same time. Highly recommend.

Always get a great meal and Tony is the perfect host.

Wonderful customer service. The owner really provided an excellent experience for his guests. Will definitely dine here again.

Food quality was found wanting relative to the premium pricing. Busy Mother’s Day weekend was understandable but we had to spend 2.5 hours to get to main course which is hard to comprehend.

It was good. It was Mother's Day so busy but expected. My family enjoyed the food and atmosphere. 😊

This is our favorite restaurant and the food was prepared with perfection. Not typically a dessert person, but the cannoli is the best in Westchester if not the entire state.

Very nice spot. Service was excellent and although the place was busy when we went, we didn’t have to wait long for anything (appetizers, drinks, main course, dessert). I couldn’t be happier with these guys.

Ambience was very pleasant. Looking forward to eat here again!

Amazing service atmosphere and food. Will be a new regular costumer.

Birthday and mothers day

Good food, good service, nice atmosphere.

Night was very enjoyable the food was delicious

great staff, welcoming and very friendly. came for the steak and lamb chops and they were excellent.

Food is fantastic and the service was perfect! The Pappardelle Short Rib was the best I have ever had! Always one of our favorites! Never disappoints!

Everything was awesome! Service was great and outstanding food.

If you are looking for a quality, neighborhood restaurant, you won't be disappointed.

This is fast becoming my favorite restaurant in the Pelham, Scarsdale, New Rochelle, Larchmont, Mamaroneck zone. Ate inside on a chilly rainy evening. No problem with COVID precautions. Shrimp cocktail appetizer was much enjoyed, but the salmon crudo is outstanding. I order a lot of tuna or salmon tartar when available. This is a different presentation that was just so fine. Chicken martini main course was very good, but the grilled veal chop was even better. Home fries, garlic spinach are very good sides. No room for dessert this visit. But very much looking forward to returning.

We have been coming to Macelleria for two years. This occasion was a dual birthday celebration. Service was good and food was great as always.

Second time at this establishment, first time for lunch. They really do know how to cook here, although a steak was slightly over-salted to this reviewer's personal taste. Sat outside in the tent. Plenty of distance. Service was wonderful. My guest has a sole dish over risotto. It was very good. Garlic spinach and fried onions were very good. House-made meatball starter was very good, and I am not a meatball fan. Pistachio tartufo also was very fine, and neither am I a tartufo fan. (I was being an accommodating host on shared dishes.)

This visit confirmed my initial satisfaction with the restaurant, the food and the service. I look forward to returning.

Service was impeccable and attentive, food was excellent.

Exelent . Exelent

My husband & I had dinner here on Easter Sunday. The food, the service, the ambience was phenomenal. We can't wait to go back again.

VERY REFREASHING. GREAT TO BE EATING OUT AGAIN. SERVICE AND FOOD WERE WONDERFUL

A lovely neighborhood Italian restaurant. Outdoor dining with a heated overhang. Varied menu. Attentive service.

I truly enjoyed my meal at Macelleria. The service from Eddie was top notch. He gave my friend excellent selections from the menu. She had the braised short rib which was so tender. My pasta with veal and truffle was phenomenal. I will be back! Thank you Eddie!

I never knew this place existed so close to my to my home I’m glad I experienced it and I will be back lovely greetings and service my son loved it

Excellent all around! We love this restaurant! Food is excellent, service outstanding’

I went there twice already and each time the staff is super friendly and helpful. The chef definitely knows what’s their doing! You can tell this is a true neighborhood staple! Everyone left happy and satisfied. I will definitely make this my local spot too

Lunch was absolutely delicious, Tony and his staff do a great job of always making you feel welcome and food and service are always excellent.

Edin was amazing. Cannot wait to go back

Always a great experience! One of my favorite places to eat