Lucia's on the Lake
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
Bang Bang Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp tossed in our house-made sweet thai chili bang bang sauce
Linguini sauteed with spinach, garlic, basil, white wine, crushed red pepper, fresh lobster meat, pecorino romano, topped with a lobster tail
Roasted red pepper cream sauce, topped with fresh lobster meat, grilled shrimp & a seared scallop
Amazing food every single time
Bartender with gray bun almost had to be tackled to get his attention to order a drink.
Food took a very long time to come out. I’ll allow that you are probably short staffed in the kitchen.
Always a great meal and service at Lucia's. A slam dunk for a special occasion or any time! Can't wait to visit again.
Service was outstanding. Food was amazing. I’ve never had a meal that wasn’t amazing and I’ve just about tried everything.
Our waiter Tom was amazing! Food and service always outstanding! Can’t wait to return!
Went for our anniversary dinner and everything was great. Service was good and quick. Food is always delicious and even had leftovers.
Ambiance was excellent with a broad lakeview. Service was great; very attentive to what we were eating / drinking in both supplying and removal without being "salesy". Quality of food was excellent in presentation and taste. Been there several times and never disappointed!
Everything was fantastic! From the service to the food! Our waiter was John! We will be requesting him every time we go! The food was phenomenal!! Can’t wait to go back!!!
Our 3rd time there and will be definitely going back! Food and service outstanding!
Everything was delicious! We had the poached pear salad, roasted vegetable bisque (incredible!), rigatoni bolognese and linguini with lobster.
Food was outstanding as always!!!
We always enjoy dining at Lucia’s. Last night our meal was superb. It was just top notch food and service.
Lucia’s is always great! The service, the food wonderful as usual!
Excellent Dinner ! View of beautiful lake. Excellent Service
Excellent food and great service. I've never had a bad meal.
Lucia’s has wonderful food! It was a great dinner as always at a beautiful location!
Amazing experience! Food was phenomenal. Can not wait to go back!
Fantastic! Our server John was very knowledgeable and attentive. Loved the vibe for a weeknight.
We went for our 25th anniversary and we’re not disappointed, service was exceptional as well as the food. We would not hesitate to return.
Nice table near front window to see water and ready on time of reservation
Food Service Ambience outsatanding
We've been there a bunch of times and it never disappoints. Always excellent service and great food.
Really great food. While pricey, good sized portions. Our server, Thomas was wonderful w my family. It was pretty noisy where we sat, ( we were seated in the bar area). Can get a little tight, and unfortunately some folks do tend to get on top of your table from the bar. We ate w our 11yro daughter. Granted- she's very mature for her age, & we all had a great dinner. Would go again for sure.
Great food and service
Great as usual
Dinner was good… the view is always amazing and the service was excellent.
Fantastic service by Jared, our waiter. He answered every question, made requested substitutions, was attentive but not in our face. Food was excellent. Will be sure to return. Only problem is very difficult to get a reservation - so plan ahead *
A great dining experience as always!
It was my first time at the restaurant and I couldn't be happier.. The food was very good and my server Kate was excellent... the view was beautiful especially with the lake being calm.
I had some out of town guests join me for dinner, they were raving at the outstanding service and incredible food. The owner Jay came over and introduced himself to everybody and thanked us for our business which was a awesome touch. The food is 10/10 every time!
The Meatball appetizer was delish as usual. The salad & dressing were very good (kind of skimpy on the salad mix) My son ordered the Wagyu filet & he is a food connoisseur! He absolutely loved his dish with scallops and asparagus.
I had the filet mignon & it was deliscious & tender. The garlic potatoes & greenbeans , well they also were delish. Chicken Marsala was ordered & enjoyed . Pricey , bill was over 300.00 for the 3 of us. Felt we were being rushed a bit in the beginning, but i think I made them slow down a bit....I made the reservation almost two months prior to the date of reservation. We'll be back.
Our anniversary dates are around the same time, ALWAYS an outstanding evening. Our server, Charlene Keller is excellent, very attentive and friendly.
Our favorite restaurant was a great experience as usual. It's our special occasion go to but this was just a dinner with friends. Going back in a few weeks! Can't wait!!
Our service with John and Bailey was impeccable. Husband loved his Chicken Marsala. Had the lobster linguine and though loaded with lobster lacked a little flavor. Came home and added garlic and some broccoli. Overall a great experience for our first visit. Will be back
Awesome! As usual.
Super loud which we were expecting based on reviews. Got seated early which was nice but server forgot our appetizer and gave us the wrong dessert at first. I was glad we had a gift certificate. Not sure we will be back.
Wonderful waiter. Great food with many different choices. Enjoyed everything that I ordered.
Everything was really great from the hostess, bar people, server and food. The short ribs were outstanding. The spaghetti was ok and everything else was very good!!
We will be visiting again for sure.
Beautiful view, fantastic service, outstanding food! Worth the wait to get reservations. Can't wait to go back!
Service and food was excellent ! A must do on your list !
Service was A+ from the moment we walked in. I must say I can’t remember the last time we have received the service that we received. “Little Tom “ was fantastic couldn’t have a better experience !
Lucia's on the Lake offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (716) 627-9752.
Lucia's on the Lake is rated 4.9 stars by 2704 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.