I was looking for a place to have dinner in Jersey City, and am so glad that I found Liberty Prime on Open Table. First of all, the restaurant is absolutely gorgeous. The tables were all nicely spread apart, so I felt completely safe. I started with the lobster bisque - which was out of this world. I then had the mahi mahi with a red pepper risotto - simply amazing. I finished with the banana bread pudding, which was delicious. My server Adrian and the rest of the staff were all fantastic. Terrific dining option in Jersey City.

We went for my boyfriend’s birthday dinner and everything was amazing! The seabass and ribeye were our entrees. We also had tuna tartare, grilled octopus, lobster mac, and creamed spinach. Best seabass I ever had! We will definitely come back.

The service was awesome and glad to have a local place for great steak and seafood.

Liberty Prime never fails us.. the best filet mignon !

Delicious food and even better service!

My husband and I ordered the Tomahawk steak for two. $140.00, the taste was good but the fat was overkill! The service and ambiance were outstanding though and the drinks were delicious! Would still go again

We booked Valentine's Day dinner at Liberty Steakhouse in Jersey City. We arrived at the time of our reservation (6pm) and were seated in a back corner away from most of the other diners. We asked the staff to send over our waiter multiple times and by 6:30 our waiter had not come to our table so we got up and left. They didn't even bring water over in 30 minutes for a restaurant that's supposed to have no more than 25% capacity...

I have been here many times before and unfortunately tonight was one of the worst experiences I’ve had. Food and service subpar at best. Very disappointing to say the least. I will not be returning.

Very good and great service.

My experience was great!

The whole experience was amazing. It was a birthday celebration. The waitress was excellent in explaining the dishes and recommending new items. Food was cooked as requested and tasted excellent. The appetizer was beef with brie more than amazing.
after dinner they surprised us with a slice of cheese cake and a candle for the birthday person.

I always wanted to dine at this restaurant since I moved to jersey, I went on a first date and chose this restaurant and that was the best idea. We had a great time and the food was delicious. We will be back the eat again.

First time here and I was completely blown away by the service and food. Nadia our server was so attentive and accommodating. We never had to ask for one refill! We celebrated my boyfriend’s birthday here and it was the perfect gothic ambiance. The NY style cheesecake was to die for. The manager on duty gave us a quick tour of the space after as well. We will definitely be back :)

The food here was outstanding for the price and our server was very attentive! Best bread ive ever had! Perfect birthday dinner date night.

Everything was amazing, I had no complaints. I’m looking forward to going back soon.

This restaurant was a first time for me and I loved it! From the service to the food and drinks, it was wonderful! The only con I would have to say is that the octopus we ordered was a little bit over cooked, but otherwise everything else was top notch.

Food was to good ,kept getting sent back on my birthday should be a special day it wasn’t that special.I didn’t even get my waiter name but he short with curly flowy hair Spanish

Great food. Went for NYE with a group of friends the service was great! It was a prefix menu and had great options on it.

Pre-fixed New Year’s Eve dinner was so-so and over priced! Not what I expected!

NYE was cute here. A bit pricy & service so-so but overall a good experience.

food was very good, service was lacking, since it was New Years Eve, our waitress rushed out food out so fast, My husband said something, considering the bill was $400 which was ok, DONT RUSH US OUT!

The food wasn’t great. Wine was good. Their service was very helpful but we felt rushed NYE night.

Easily the best dining experience of 2020. Beautiful Thanksgiving feast, every bite delicious. Wonderful service.

This place really made my holiday. My yearly Thanksgiving large gathering was cancelled for obvious reasons, so I went out to eat for the first time ever on this holiday. Liberty Prime could not have made me feel more at home. The manager, Ivan, greeted me at the door after the friendly hostesses checked me in. He personally walked me to my seat to make sure I was comfortable & liked the location. My server, Diana, quickly helped me navigate the menu & order my first cocktail. The bartender, Alex, personally came over to make sure it was to my liking, & happily assisted Diana throughout service. The food was outstanding & literally tasted like my aunt was cooking in the kitchen all day. We were so stuffed, Alex happily had our desserts packed up to go. This will be my new "Go To" place when I want to feel at home when I can't be.

I had a delightful time. I will definitely go back again.

We went for our anniversary, we got drinks seafood and a steak to split, desserts and coffee..everything was tasty and fresh

We had great service and really good times. Would recommend the liberty prime to others. It

The food was excellent, the service was attentive but a bit casual for the level of dining. Ex: we had to request things that I would have expected to be automatic - replacing small places, steak knives, bucket for wine, etc.

We started our evening with below average martinis. The tempura roll was uninspired and should have been served with ponzu sauce. Our salads were drowning in lemon juice and the side dishes were cold. The steaks were uninspired, dry as a bone and with zero seasoning. The only saving grace was our server’s humor. My reservation noted a 50th birthday celebration which was never acknowledged. We exited the restaurant with not one employee in sight. It was as if they had all gone home. Liberty Steakhouse is not worth your time or money. Do not walk, run!

I was not pleased. My petite filet mignon was luke warm and did not have a sear. My glass of wine was also delivered in an unclean glass. I had to return it for a glass without someone else's lipstick on it.

We were a bit nervous regarding the other varying reviews we read. However, the food was amazing, the service was on-point, and the ambiance was very fitting for a special occasion. I’m glad we got to celebrate a birthday here

Took 3 times to get our steak done correctly.

Food was good - my boyfriend and I ordered the kansas city for two and it was more than enough for us to share along with 3 sides. Also, the service was attentive. They also surprised us with a glass of Prosecco for my birthday.

The staff was very accommodating when we arrived and seated us at a better table. It was the birthday of one of our guests and they sent a complimentary dessert to celebrate. Liberty Prime is by far the best steak house in Jersey City -- looks like there have been some staff changes, but the services was still really good and the food is excellent. They seemed to follow safety protocols, too (took our temperature at the door, always wore masks, tables were distant). We had such a great night, it felt "normal" again.

Birthday dinner with the family

Nice quiet place. The food was very good along with the service. Definitely will attend more often, and would recommend.

Had a wonderful dinner! Delicous steak and the best creamed spinach i've ever had. Great ambiance and service!

Steak was ordered medium came out well done. Unfortunately liked the place but going to a steak house and it coming out not as expected ruined the first time experience.

Not one for desert but it was so good thank goodness I wore my sketchy pants lol

Service was verrrrrry slow. Food tasty but not hot

Did outdoor dining. Our server was friendly and attentive. Appetizers were good as well as the dessert.
Unfortunately the porterhouse for 2 and prime rib were both way overcooked. We decided not to return it as we were too hungry plus we hate having to do that anyway. We really had high hopes despite the hit-or-miss reviews, but it turns out they are that way for a reason.

This restaurant is on a lane of its own. They have good food but don’t compare it to one of the finer steakhouses. We also had our wedding reception here a year ago and that was Phenomenal. Our guest still rave about the food. Not sure if COVID had caused some changes in the kitchen.