Liberty Prime Steakhouse
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Waitstaff wear masks
Creamed / Sauteed Spinach
New Year's Eve Special Menus & Offers
If you cancel less than 24 hours a $50 Cancellation fee will apply.
Came to celebrate my wife’s birthday and was very disappointed. I ordered the bone marrow as an app 10 minutes later the waiter comes and tells me they didn’t have any, he said there were 2 left but they thought it was too small so I replaced it with crab cakes. For dinner I ordered 2 Bone in rib steak and Tomahawk for 2. When the meal came out the steaks were not hot, a little warm at best, side dishes were hotter than the steaks. outside of steaks not charred at all. When I told the waiter that the steaks were not hot he said maybe because the plate wasn’t hot enough. I don’t even think they had the steaks on a heating station after it was cook because the plate was cold. Also usually the 3 steak sauces comes with the steaks but I had to ask for it. Servers wasn’t tentative enough. I came here a few times and enjoyed the food but tonight was just bad all around.
Great food, great experience
Food was mediocre. My family and I each have our own palette from picky to welcoming and the consensus amongst was just that the food was good.
We had 3-4 apps. We recommend the crab cakes.
Entrees ranged from steak to pasta to fish.
The lobster ravioli I would recommend.
The other meals were described as good, nothing more.
Service was great and attentive.
We will not be going back.
If you live in Jersey City, visiting Jersey City, or just riding through Jersey City, and have not been here, ask yourself what have I been doing with my life? The food is outstanding. Fresh, seasoned correctly, and presentation superb. Make your reservation today
Had a fantastic meal. Tuna tartare appetizer, bone in rib steak and cheesecake. Service was great. The aged beef was excellent with just the right amount of seasoning. I would definitely return.
One of the best steakhouse in NJ, I just like everything about this place. The Tomahawk is my favorite
Great birthday meal. Drinks were fantastic, service a bit slow. Biggest complain has to be the 40oz tomahawk to share. Half of it was fat and we ordered medium rare but got closer to medium well. As a steakhouse that should be the last complaint
We've been to this steakhouse once before about a year ago and that time the experience was okay/average but this time in 2021 the experience was better than average. the rib eye was good, the spinach very good, the salad good and the service was attentive. so all around it was very nice (not a home run but close) and the interior is clean with nice seating and surroundings and the only issue is the bar is openly connected to the dining area so the noise from the bar, TV's and conversations, does spill into the dining area so the noise is moderate. we will come here again.
A bit pricey but worth it. Try the raw bar; it’s delicious! I had the Filet mignon and it was perfect! I’ve eaten at Liberty Prime three or four times and never been disappointed.
Awesome experience. Food was great and the service was excellent. The drinks were good as well. A pretty decent to have good meal, the staff communicated and gave the best recommendations.
Very disappointing. Left after a drink and appetizer. The oysters were bad and shrimp over cooked. No one was in restaurant but I was seated facing the door. Would not recommend.
Came out to treat myself after a hard week. Waiter had zero social skills and knew nothing about wine. They didn’t have the wine I ordered- no apology- and no advice on an alternative. Then they didn’t have chamomile tea although it was on the menu. Whole experience felt rushed and not special at all.
Food was spectacular. The steaks were cooked perfectly and were nicely spiced and flavored.
Only issue we had was a few gnats flying around inside, but it wasn't enough to take away from the solid meal.
Always a good meal here
Servers are always great as well
Service sucked. Our glasses were empty with no water refills and they didn’t come by to see how everything was. Hubby asked for “Blue Rare” cooked steak and got medium. For being a steakhouse, we expected to at least get a cooked to order steak. Nope!
Aged steak is something we go out to dinner for often, and this was the worst aged steak I’ve ever had.
It was very tough, fatty and not flavorful. We were doubting it was actually aged at all.
My boyfriends steak was undercooked too.
The service and the sides were good.
This place was great to visit. The service was very attentive, and professional. The food, the drinks, and the environment was on point. It helped that they validate the parking from the neighboring garage. I would definitely go back again.
This was our first time at Liberty Prime and certainly will not be the last! Everything that we ordered, from the appetizers to the steaks were amazing. We may have found our new “go-to” steakhouse in Jersey City.
I met friends at liberty prime for brunch! The food was excellent and everything was enjoyed by each of my friends!
The food was amazing! The server was very nice and patient!
I've been eying this steakhouse for quite some time now and finally decided to try it out to celebrate my engagement. From the point we walked in, to the point we left, there was nothing short of amazing. The food was beautifully presented and flavorful. Drinks were delicious and tasty. The service was outstanding as well! Amazing all around and we will definitely be back!
Beautiful restaurant, great ambiance and service but the food... must say we were quite underwhelmed. Appetizers like the octopus and the tuna tartare were good. However the main courses left a lot to be desired. The steak, while cooked perfectly, came to the table cold at room temperature. The sides were not good, especially the truffle mac and cheese (Mushy noodles and just very bland). Desserts were okay (Chocolate cake was decent, coconut creme brulee was only "coconut" because they put flakes at the bottom). Probably wouldn't dine here again. Can't recommend to others unless the food improves. NYC Overpriced but not meeting those expectations with what was being served.
The good is amazing. The staff is always pleasant. Couldn't say enough good things about Liberty Prime.
I took my boyfriend here for the first time for his birthday and it was excellent. The steaks were perfectly seasoned and cooked just to our liking . Our server and the staff were very kind and accommodating. Our server brought out the dessert with a candle and wrote on the plate wishing my boyfriend a happy bday as well as two complimentary glasses of champagne for a toast. We were able to take some great pictures and made memories that I will cherish forever . So thank you for a wonderful night and dinner , we will be back .
Celebrating a birthday! The food was excellent quality! The waiter gave us outstanding service!
This was not my first time at Liberty Prime but it will be my last, sorry to say.
The waiter constantly stopped by the table and rushed us through the meal. Once we ordered the apps and then entrees, the food seemed to come in 5 minutes, which just felt odd.
None of the food remotely justified the price, most especially the filet. It was completely average and lacked taste. Most especially for the money….
I had notified the hostess that there was a birthday in our party and was told they could do something nice. At the end of the meal, they simply brought the check. At which point I simply paid and left.
I would not recommend this restaurant, which is disappointing to say. NYC prices with subpar food and service.
For Mother’s Day.brunch.
The quiche was spongy and green. My wife did not care for it
The service and food was excellent. Our waiter gave some great recommendations on the best items on the menu. Will definitely come back.
Great fancy restaurant, amazing food, upscale prices, lovely interior decor, and good service.
KC for two can't be beat, potatoes au gratin, and onion rings. : )
The food was so good and the waiter made great recommendations. Definitely planning to go back soon!
The Food was delicious! The staff was very attentive even when I had to call on the phone to reschedule the timing they were understanding and helpful!
Service and ambiance was outstanding. The food left me with something to be desired.
Apps and soup was ok but when you order a medium rare steak and receive a medium well for the price we paid. Big thumbs down!
Really inconsistent and uneven throughout the meal. The steak itself was fairly good, but was badly overcooked, a medium-rare hitting what many would call medium-well, and the sear turning into more of a char at points, lending a bitter, burnt taste to a very good cut of meat. For drinks, a supposed Passion Fruit Mojito was glorified lime juice with ice and was practically undrinkable. Bread was sweet and too soft and tasted like a store-bought roll. An appetizer which was said to come with goat cheese had no cheese to be found, and supposed cheddar mashed potatoes were similarly lacking in our delectable orange friend. The meal was frankly unacceptable for the price.
Wonderful waiter, fantastic food and presentation.
The food was amazing. Our waiter Pablo was amazing. Everyone was nice and attentive.
A little pricey and you have to order sides.
The key lime pie was super tart—not sweet at all and you definitely had to dip it in the raspberry sauce... but I enjoyed it.
The crab cake appetizer was very fresh and absolutely delicious—😍
Excilent service throughout our whole time. Server was great ! Food great! Service great! Going again !
We had double rib steak a few nights ago. The quality of the steak was terrible, it didnt taste fresh and tough to eat. Definitely not the best steak house we have been to.
Liberty Prime Steakhouse is rated 4.3 stars by 528 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.