Very good food, nice dining room. Non-touristy option in midtown.

The food was fantastic.

Big space yet warm ambiance. Everyone was super nice, from the bartender to the wait staff. Loved the Greek fare - and will come back to host a get together in the special events space. Great find.

Great restaurant close to the theatre , we had dinner before a show and I am sure we will do it again.
Service was great and the food was very yummy.

Delicious food, great service and lovely ambiance

Great food and extra friendly service.

It was wonderful! The food was great service was great m! Highly recommend!

Beautiful space, some great personnel. Great table service, weird vibe from management and awkward interactions. Food was tasty but overcooked. Miscommunication with waiting staff made out “to go” (leftovers) being thrown away.
Wouldn’t go back.

Delicious food, fantastic service and great ambiance!

Excellent experience for our group of 7 on a business outing. They accommodated our round table request and everything was great! It ain’t cheap…

The food was delicious. Spinach Pie was light and full of spinach, lamb chops excellent, chicken, fish. It was all good. Service spectacular.

The food was outstanding. The service was great. This restaurant is close to Broadway shows, but not a tourist restaurant. We can't wait to come back on our next NYC visit.

We arrived on time for lunch. But the restaurant was empty. The hotess told us it was closed because of the lack of reservations. But she didn’t call us because of our international phone numbers. Why couldn’t she write us an E-Mail ??? So ashamed for a such restaurant.

Excellent service and excellent food. We hadn’t been there since March 2020. It was still as good as before! Highly recommend!

Wonderful! Highly recommended. Great fish and nice wine list

We enjoyed dining at the restaurant (this being our second visit) upon our return to NYC. Due to COVID the restaurant was not full, thus the noise level was much less than when we visited in 2019. A disturbing situation arose when we ordered a bottle of wine. We were told that the stated price (in the menu) was incorrect and it would be $6 more. We felt this was inappropriate and should have been corrected on the menu vs. putting the waitress to communicate this. We travel the world and have never had this type of situation occur in any restaurant we have ever eaten in. This occurrence definitely detracted from our evening. The management should correct the menu!

Great Greek food. Octopus appetizer outstanding! Authentic flavors. Large portions. Excellent waiter service.

Terrific raw bar and very good overall experience

Greek cuisine in the Theater district.

Everything was outstanding! The service, the food, the atmosphere was absolutely wonderful

Beautiful restaurant. Great menu selection and food was awesome. Attentive service.

Great food and service. Disappointed that they are not currently having their Sunday Lobster special which is still on the open table menu and the main reason for our reservation.

Last Sunday I had my birthday lunch at Kellari Taverna. Everything started out fine. The waitress was friendly and helpful. My friend and I ordered the pre fixe lunch and a glass of wine. The spanokopia appetizer was delicious. After finishing this the problems began. Apparently the waitress was sent to assist at a party in another section of the restaurant. We were all but forgotten. After waiting an unreasonably long time I asked for the person in charge. He was extremely apologetic. Our entrees were finally served. The mushroom ravioli was exceptional. The host offered us different desserts and an additional glass of wine which neither of us accepted. At that point, while the food was absolutely delicious the time spent there was just too long. I most likely will return in the future to give them another chance to prove that Kellari Taverna is the restaurant with excellent food and service that I remember.

Beautiful place and great service. This was our second time back there. We love it.

Dinner here for family of 4 including one picky vegetarian. The kale caesar salad was OUTSTANDING, lobster and mushroom ravioli, as well as one steak, also really really good. I had zucchini kefta for entree, also very good. Halloumi appetizer excellent, truffle fries not too truffly but good. Would absolutely return here.

Luis was great! We had 2 dinners and a lunch. We were not rushed at all. We were treated like we were somebody!

Fantastic food and knowledgeable staff. They were very accommodating. Great fish and meats. Top notch.

We would have given you five stars but the bartender didn't tell us about the Happy Hour prices until after we had ordered our first round of drinks.

Nice, clean, lovely atmosphere. Good food and reasonable.

The restaurant is lovely and spacious.
Tables are generously spaced.
Noise level very comfortable.
Pre-fixe lunch very delicious/generous/very good value.
Service by Elefterios was outstanding: very attentive, engaging and interesting.
Would definitely return, a good experience!
An A+ review!

A true gem!! The food is amazingly fresh and deliciously prepared. Happy hour menu is the best deal in town. The interior design is beautiful. Service is professional and kind. I’m only sorry I didn’t know about Kellari sooner. I look forward to returning!

Food was wonderful !!

Been here many times. Consistently good

Loud, slow, crowded, over priced.

Hostess(es)could listen and care a bit more. Waiter was barely available and drinks from bar took so long that our dinner was on the table before they arrived. Food was tasty with generous portion of dips for bread. the bussers/support staff was attentive.

Outstanding food and service. The restaurant has nice extensive wine list by the glass and bottle. My wife enjoyed the filet mignon with lemon potatoes which she said was the best she's ever had. I enjoyed the lamb shank with mashed and feta. We passed on dessert but were surprised with some Greek cookies to go with our coffees. As the evening wore on, more people arrived and the noise level increased appreciably. It appeared that it is a favorite with New Yorkers and theater goers. Our server, Elefterios K, along with the rest of the wait staff was superb. It's a bit pricey but hey, it's NYC, and it was worth it.

Noise level was terrible. Service was fair AT BEST. Our water glasses remained empty until we tracked down a server. Had to track down a sever to order a glass of wine as well AND to get the bill. A shame as the food was excellent.

Delicious food and beautiful presentation.

Pre fix much is great value. Good location in mid town.

Excellent fresh fish. Best fried calamari.