Kellari Taverna

Bartender was exceptional & patient with our wine choice
Service was great food was delicious
everything was well paced can't wait to go back!

Anniversary.

The Greek salad that my wife and I shared was average. The sea bass that we both had also was not the best sea bass we have had and I would rate it a 7 out of 10.

We are from Washington DC and go to the brunch on the weekends. We’ve never been disappointed so we decided that we would try dinner in New York at Kellari. Everyone was pleased with their entrées. The manager even came over at towards the end and offered us after dinner liqueur which we enjoyed!
It also was a great location for all of us to meet up

Professional wait staff, generous portions
Nice layout buffers the busy lunchtime noise. We were treated courteously and kindly.

$23 for a salad of mealy tomatoes, some strands of red onion, and cucumbers with two hunks of feta was not what most would consider value for money. An $18 "farm" salad swimming in dressing was equally disappointing. Honestly cannot think of a single thing worth the check unless proximity to the theater district is your one and only consideration. Very disappointing and will not return any time soon.

I've had excellent experiences with you in the past but 7/10 was truly mediocre. The service was slow and the food not very good at all. The worst vegetarian moussaka I've ever had.

We had a lunch reservation for 4 but were seated 25 minutes past our reservation time. The food was quite good, but this is just not tenable for a business lunch. We ordered the business lunch, but due to the delayed seating had to leave before the dessert course could be served. We were still charged full price.

Reliably good food. Business lunch is a good value for 3 courses and generous portions. Lamb shank was delicious! Very busy/bustling until the lunch crowd thinned at about 2 pm; service was good even when busy.

Nice menu, especially for dieters! Great salads and fish dishes. Excellent service. Will return.

Delicious!

Pre-theater dinner

Terrific salad. Stale bread and a tasteless overcooked lamb shank. Quick service.

Pre-theatre dinner was perfect. Food and service exceptional. We’ve been to Broadway many times; few dining options. Kellari Taverna is the exception. Beautiful atmosphere too.

Server gave me no reason to want to recommend the restaurant to others or for me to want to return as a guest. Hospitality and service goes a long way.

Kellari Taverna is one of our favorite restaurants. The food, service and ambience are dependably excellent.

Food was very good but overpriced. Case in point: mixed appetizer plate had standard assortment but at a considerably higher price than comparable selection at other restaurants.

The food was absolutely delicious. The fig gelato was the best I've ever tasted.

EVERYTHING about KELLARI is wonderful
FOOD amazing.. Service on point.. Ambiance wonderful
Never disappoints

Location was great pre-theater and service was excellent, but it was a bit pricey for the quality of the food - perhaps we just didn't order their best dishes. Would try again, but not rushing back.

Meal was great for everyone. Our server was forgetful and we had to remind him multiple times for drinks and other things. Great atmosphere other than the ac not running properly so it was very warm. Would try again.

Always blown away by the excellent service here. Fantastic.

Making a reservation was easy. The host seated us without the entire party being present which was very nice. The server was attentive. He answered all questions appropriately. We both ordered from the brunch menu which included a complimentary alcoholic beverage. The drinks were fine. I ordered the classic eggs Benedict and my friend ordered the Greek salad. The food arrived quickly. So far so good. My friend described her salad as OK - nothing to write home about. My dish was a mixed bag. The english muffin was nicely done - light and crispy and the ham was moist and flavorful. There was very little hollandaise sauce. The eggs were overcooked. The whites were fine. When I cut into the egg, the yolk was semi soft with NO OOZE. I ate the first egg. Half way through the second egg, I caught the waiter’s eye and showed him the egg. I explained that I WAS NOT SENDING THE FOOD BACK; however, I asked him to speak to the chef/cook. He did mumble an apology for the issue. I have no idea if he spoke to the kitchen staff. Our table faced the open kitchen and I did not see the waiter speak to the kitchen staff about the meal. When the check came, he said he was comping us for our drinks which were already included in the cost of the meal and he did not reduce the price of my meal. The dining experience was underwhelming - nothing terrible but I would be hesitant to have brunch here again or to recommend brunch at this restaurant to friends.

Enjoyed bunch at Kellari Taverna on June 23 (Sunday). Menu was diverse and able to accommodate those interested in breakfast items as well as those preferring lunch. The quality of the food is great, and, if you like lobster rolls, the one offered here is excellent. Fresh ingredients, well prepared. Outstanding service. Staff is always readily available, but never hovers. Atmosphere is excellent - clean and quiet. Not at all difficult to have a conversation. Never feel rushed to order or to finish the meal. We arrived around 1:00 and stayed until we’ll after 3:00. Never an indication from staff that we should “move along.” Would recommend Kellari Taverna for brunch, lunch and dinner.

Pleasant surroundings, good service and fresh, authentic food. Totally delicious.

Took the family to dinner before a show on a Saturday night, great food and service.

I love Kellari’s and it is my go to restaurant when meeting with customers or family. The Manager and hostess are always welcoming, the wait staff is attentive and the food is always fresh and enjoyable. Great bar for that after work stop.

Waiters were great and very attentive. Waiter was very friendly and kind to the lady I was with. The Bartender was a very easy going guy and quite friendly . We enjoyed the evening and will be back!

The food service and atmosphere at Kellari Taverna could not have been better. Their fix price dinner menu is so generous you can hardly believe the value. I strongly recommend going for cocktails and appetizers at the bar , fix price dinner, (saving room for their indescribable desserts), or a fabulous raw bar lunch. The food, service and atmosphere at Kellari Taverna could not have been better.

Great place for pre- or post-theatre dinner specials. Food and service are outstanding, plus very convenient to Broadway shows.

Great place, always consistent. I sat at the bar and the bartender was amazing.

LOVE KELLARI!!

Amazing food and menu. Not much for the price.

Second time going to Kellari Taverna before a Broadway show. The food, service and ambience is perfect.
We will go back on our next NY trip.

The staff at Kellari make diners feel like valued friends. The lunch and brunch menus offer
extensive choices and are among the best values in the area.

Yianni and the staff at Kellari were extremely attentive to making our experience special, including hearing about his family and growing up in Greece.

SIx of us met up at Kellari Taverna for a reunion of sorts, meeting wives for the first time. We had a great time, and the food and ambience were wonderful. We had the assorted Greek appetizers, and everything else was fish. Octopus was superb, and all the broiled and baked selections were excellent. I eat out a lot in NYC. This is as good as it gets.

Good pre theatre menu. Food was good, not great.
But, fine for a quick dinner. Atmosphere was nice & service was very good. Enjoyed the salmon tar tar with lentils & the fish special. Walnut cake was delicious. Good wine list by the glass. Would go again when going to theatre.

This is one of the best Greek restaurants in town. The dishes are delicious and plentiful. The wine list outstanding. Service is great and everyone is very pleasant.

My very good friend & I had theater tickets this past June12th, and we always do lunch before the show. I chose Kellari Taverna because I've admired the look of the restaurant every time I passed by on other occasions. So, I decided to make my reservation for this day. As I had envisioned, the place was fantastic! From the time we stepped in to the room to our departure....it was terrific. All our food selections were delicious & all very fresh. We especially loved the wine list as well. The waiter was attentive but not intrusive. He never missed a beat! As food recommendations, please try the country pie as an appetizer, salmon tartre, both nice size. My shrimp dish was flavorful & my friends pasta, well she loved it. Save room for the dessert people! This restaurant will get another visit from both of us soon....it's now on my go to restaurant list. Make it yours as well.