Keeler's Neighborhood Steakhouse

All our meals were excellent! Great bar and drinks as well. Wonderful service and all around great place, we will be back!

We arrived 5 minutes past our reservation. Table wasn't ready so hostess told us to go to the bar and she'd come get us. After 20 minutes we turned to speak with her (literally sitting directly in front of hostess station) and she told us table was ready but couldn't find us. Really? Dinner came out and mahi mahi was overcooked to the point of being burnt. Diver scallops - $34 - was a plate of 4 served atop a skimpy portion of grits and green beans. Steaks were underseasoned. Baked potato didn't come as ordered, either. Manager did come out to apologize. Sent back fish and potato for replacement and got an extra serving of grits. Grits were tasty. Coffee was full of grinds at bottom of cup. We thought we'd be comped on the fish or be given a dessert, but neither were offered. Not rushing back.

Service was terrible
Food was over cooked
Drinks never arrived
Every table had a complaint

Closer to 3 1/2 but giving them the benefit of the doubt. Hubby took me here for my birthday which also coincides with Valentines day weekend. Place was packed but we had a reservation and were taken to our table right away. Wanted a relaxing meal so ordered a couple of their cocktail specials which were pretty good. Our waiter Davon was on point, personable, and accessible without being overbearing or rushing us to order when we just wanted to sip our drinks for a while first.

The menu was varied with not only the typical steakhouse fare but also some interesting starters, fish and sandwiches. They were also offering a special, 3 course set menu for Valentine's day ($70 pp) that looked pretty good too. We opted to order from the regular menu. I had the rack of lamb with the loaded baked potato and green beans, hubs got the baseball sirloin with asparagus and scalloped potatoes. My lamb was fantastic perfectly rare (how I like it) with great flavor. The potato was just OK, nothing special and not very "loaded". The beans were not very good at all. Overcooked and just man. Hubs steak was a tad overcooked and while I thought it tasted good he thought it needed more seasoning. The asparagus was good but nothing special, but the scalloped potatoes were awesome.

The dessert menu was nothing special so we passed, the wine list was very nice with a good variety and range of prices.

Overall a nice experience and we will definitely go again, perhaps for lunch or happy hour to try the sandwiches.

The service was horrendous. The GM had to take over and apologize. The food was cold or overdone. No one at our table typically complain but after we heard other people saying that they would never come back we knew we had to speak up too.

We had the BEST dinner at Keeler’s!
From the first drink at the bar to our last bite of dessert everything was fantastic!
I had the swordfish and my boyfriend had a steak and both were cooked to perfection!!
We cannot wait to go back!!!

the food was cold and steak was tuff and chewy not quality meat like it should have been

our food was rushed out with our salad.
It was very good but I like to relax and have my salad then when I am done bring out my main course

Newer restaurant, so there are a few bugs to work out. but food was really good. Might be a little on the higher price side.

Best Filet I have ever had!! It was better than Capital Grill, Morton's, and Flemming's. Plus Keeler's includes 2 sides in the price versus ala carte at the other places, so it makes the value incredible!! I would highly recommend Keeler's to everyone!!

This is the second time we have gone here. The food is great, service is terrific. The issue is the tables are so close together you can't have a conversation with the person you are with. It's like going to a restaurant that sits everyone at the same table. We were in the room to the right of the bar and they have 5 tables along a banquet. The tables are very small and very close together. Less than a foot between tables. Waitstaff has to squeeze between tables to get orders, placing their back side to the customers at other table. I suggest you get a little bigger table and put less of them along the banquet. I felt like I was going to knock over the drinks from other table when we got up to leave. It's very uncomfortable to be seated like that.

We did not have a good dinner experience. We would not come back for dinner ever again, but will come and try the happy hour. My husband wanted a filet but a pushy waiter insisted he get the NY strip even after he told her he did not care for that cut of meat. She even offered to buy his meal if he didn't like it, of course that didn't happen. He did not care for it and found it chewy and nothing like a filet. They brought him out a black filet, rare inside which is not how he would have wanted it prepared. We were then charged for a 12oz filet when they brought him out a 8oz. My Mahi Mahi was pretty bland as was his filet.
The best part of our experience was the bar at Happy Hour. The bartenders are super attentive and helpful. We looked at the menu while sitting up there and that is when my husband decided we'd do dinner instead of happy hour as he wanted to try the filet NOT the NY Strip. I give it a better score then I normally would because of the bar experience. We will definitely go back for Happy Hour, but dinner, not ever again.

Excellent service, food an ambience Recommending to all my friends. Coming back soon!!

Definitely enjoyed and will return. Happy to have a place of this caliber closer then Durants!

A big disappointment...Place was packed, but the return rate will be interesting to watch.
No need for details, but, in general, the steaks were good, but everything else was mediocre.
That includes the food sides, the service, attentiveness and attention to detail. Too bad. There
are too many BETTER steakhouses around to take this one seriously!

We have been here a few times. Each time service seems to degrade as does some of the food. While we love the convenience, we are finding the procedures to get meals on time for all parties at the table need work.

Very good new restaurant. Had happy hour items for a friday evening. Looking forward to ordering from the regular menu soon

Our first time here. Service was excellent. Food was excellent. We had the Mahi Mahi and prime rib. A perfect Valentine’s dinner experience!

This fairly new restaurant by the Keeler family is fabulous, it’s a step up from their everyday restaurant of liberty Station and is a true steakhouse. They have great selection at fair prices and good service. Plus when the weather is good will be a great patio hangout. We will be back...

We were very impressed with Keeler's Neighborhood Steakhouse. The ambiance was pleasing and the food delicious. Our waiter was attentive and had a great personality. There are few dining options in Carefree and this new addition is a winner.
We will be going back soon.

The 2-top tables are very small and too close to neighbors and claustrophobic. If you are going with 4 people, request a booth so it is a little quieter or sit on the patio. Our server was great and the steak was delicious. However, the prime rib was a little tough. It was Valentine's Day so that may have accounted for the noise level and crowded conditions. Also, the prime rib was the last one so that may also have been why it was a little tough. Other than that we enjoyed the evening very much and will go back.

Everything was perfect except that some of the servers need to listen more closely to requests (like no tomato on salad, please). We expect Keelers to get better & better as it has each time we’ve been there.

Keeler's has been open for a relatively short time, and they are still feeling their way to get everything working smoothly. While he did not come to our table, I observed the general manager greeting many tables and welcoming them to the restaurant. Our server was very personable and made sure that all our needs were being met. The tables for two, where we sat, were very close together - literally, barely enough room for a person to squeeze between the tables. We could hear the conversations clearly on both sides of us! The food was good, although there was a time lapse between the salad course and our main course. My filet was cooked perfectly and was a delicious 8 ozs. My husband had the large prime rib portion which he also thoroughly enjoyed, and took some of it home. We will come again and will definitely try their Happy Hour when the weather gets warmer!

Very nice place. We went for Valentines Day. I do not usually like sitting so close to other people but it was ok. I do not eat meat but my husband said it was excellent! Awesome waitress, very knowledgeable. Will definitely eat here again!!

Once again Keelers delivered! It was Valentines Day! We had a reservation early at 5:15 and it was cold and rainy out! We even had thought about cancelling our reservation. Glad we didn’t! They gave us a table and We sat outside by the fireplace with the wonderful heaters going and it was comfortable.
Mike the general manager stopped by to check in a couple of times. Our food was all hot and delicious! We had scallops, prime rib salad, rack of lamb and prime rib! All of our meats and sides were fabulous! I personally love the scalloped potatoes. The manchego cheese in them makes them so tasty! Nice generous size portions.
Brenda, the hostess greeted us and checked in also! As did, Madison our incredible waitress from the previous time we were there.
The friendliness of everyone is so welcoming! We feel like we have friends there! Will definitely be back.
Keep up the good work.😊👍

This is a new neighborhood GEM! Indoor and outdoor dining, and the new upstairs patio will be open soon! The food is wonderful; the people are friendly, accommodating, and attentive. The cocktails and wine selections are perfect, and Happy Hour from 3:00-6:00 will definitely make you happy you went!

Service was terrible.scallops were really small for $34. Hamburger ordered medium came out rare and instead of just cooking it some more. My friend after waiting 25 minutes for his hamburger canceled it because he was no longer hungry and everyone else was through eating. We also asked for separate checks and of course it didn’t come that way. I’m in no hurry to return

Atmosphere is very nice and food is always consistent. Love supporting local eatery❤️

Stopped by a few days ago during happy hour for a drink and something quick to snack on. Had to come back for dinner. Simply fantastic. Had a wonderful meal out on the patio. I wish we lived here because this would definately be a regular spot for us. Don't miss it, make your reservation today.

The food was very good. Trevor, our server, did an excellent job!

It was our first experience and the 4 of us had a fabulous dinner, great service, all steaks were delicious.
So nice to have another great restaurant in our area. We'll be back and we are spreading the word

Wanted to love this place, but it fell short. Ordered the ribeye medium rare and it came out medium well and tough. No seasoning. The sides were good and my wife said the tomato bisque was the bomb. The others at our table said the food was ok. Service was spotty at times. I don't think we will be back as there are many other steak options in that price range that are clearly better.

food not hot, service slow, steak was med as ordered but not moist(rather dry). would give them a second chance as I like the setting

We brought some friends who haven’t been there yet. We had a really nice evening. Even with the cool weather, it was nice and warm on the patio. Great Happy Hour menu.

We went for Happy Hour but ended up having dinner. Staff are so friendly! Services was great and food very good. Can’t wait to go back!

If you want to use their Happy Hour menu, only reserve outside. We made the mistake of making a reservation, first, and asking for an inside table, second. Anything "off the tile" around the bar inside is not eligible for Happy Hour. Unfortunately, we didn't ask to be seated in that area, and we weren't told anything until after we ordered food and drinks, and then it was done in a manner that was quite unlike the friendly service that we've experienced previously here and at Liberty Station.

The food is good and the prices are quite reasonable.

Excellent in every way- food, service and atmosphere. Will be a regular. Best place in town

Nice enjoyable meal.

We love this place! Absolutely high-end steak house quality with 2 big, delicious sides included at a very reasonable price. An excellent addition to the Cave Creek/Carefree area. I have no doubt Keeler's will be around for a long time!

Birthday celebration with friends. We really enjoyed the staff and the food. Greeted by owners, wait staff was great, all our food choices were wonderful. Glad to have this restaurant close by. Making our next reservation soon