Keeler's Neighborhood Steakhouse

Delicious dinner and complimentary birthday dessert.

The atmosphere at Keeler’s is very pleasant, and the food is excellent. Our table was on the outside patio, which is a good size. The service was efficient and friendly. Overall it was a very nice dinner experience.

Great food, service and ambiance- just wish the music was less loud and more dinner appropriate for most of the age group that is here.

I love Keeler's Neighborhood Steakhouse. I live in Carefree and I recommend this restaurant to my neighbors and co-workers. The food is always good and the staff is attentive and helpful. I am a concierge for a local community and make recommendations to Keelers with confidence.

Food was great.

One of the best meals in years. Great food, great service, good presentations. One of the best dining experiences.

First time here but we were disappointed. Very crowded area for Covid items, even if the tables were outside. My husband ordered ribs and I ordered a beef dip. The ribs were cold so we sent them back and when they came back they were all burnt up. My beef dip was not very warm as the cheese was not melted and it was on the wrong kind of bread for a beef dip. Too much hard bread. We did not even get bread on our table before our meal like everyone around us did.

Happy hour trip. 2nd visit to this place and I like it.

There was only 1 problem with the restaurant. They were out of New York Strip, Baked Potatoes & something else.

But the food is always good & people are friendly. I guess they were just extra busy this weekend.

Keeler's is just what you're looking for. It can be casual, or it can be formal. It can be an unbelievable value, or everything you would expect from a fine dining experience!

Great service and atmosphere for our party of six. Lamb chops were a little tough, and the prime rib was average. Our other entrees were excellent.

A great place for cocktails and views but wouldn’t come back with a party of more than four people. We had a group of 8 in the courtyard and our service was terrible and the food was cold. Incorrect orders, mixed up drinks and longer than reasonable wait times for our bottles of wine (which you would think they would want us to drink up). I hope it’s just a bad night as Cave Creek could use a place like this for casual dining.

This was our first visit and took my husband to celebrate his birthday. He ordered the prime rib and I ordered the petite filet mignon - both cooked to perfection. The sides were delicious! Our server was great and we didn’t feel rushed! The ambiance was great as not too bright and nicely decorated. We would love to try the outdoor patio next time! Best steaks we’ve had in a long time! Only minor suggestion is the petite fillet was a little salty. We are already planning on bringing guests back in May!

Amazing restaurant. Very charming atmosphere both inside and out. Busy but not crowded. I’d recommend this for many types of occasions. This will be our new spot.

A very nice evening. Service and food were excellent.

The food was great. My wife and I both had petite filet mignon with mushrooms and asparagus, and split a salad. The food was delicious! Service was a bit slow but ok.

Delicious food. Excellent service.

Crowded, which surprised us in this Covid environment. Not much social distancing and masks seemed optional! We had a table for 6 in a corner, so we were far enough away from other tables, but no circulation!

I split a tomahawk steak, which was $130, a bit pricey, but it was excellent and prepared perfectly. The wine list is very reasonably priced, a bottle of Sea Smoke Southing Pinot Noir goes for $90 retail, they had it for $120, Silver Oak Alexander Valley was $125 (retails $75), so very reasonable markups. Total bill $700 for 6, with nice sterks and a few bottles of wine...a good evening, but not cheap (but we knew that when we ordered!).

Waited an hour and a half for out food.
Noisy inside. Need some fabrics or noise reduction ceiling. Meats were salty.
Waitress was nice

The only thing I was disappointed in was the bread - I recall you used to have bread loaves that were outstanding. The rolls we received this time were not very good and did not go well with our appetizer or pre-dinner wine. I hope you can go to a better roll (Covid?) or back to the loaves you used to have....

Wonderful evening on the roof top of Keeler's! Beautiful views, great drinks, fantastic food, and friendly staff make this a Carefree favorite, over and over again!

One of our favorite places to dine. Food is always top notch, perfectly prepared and served. A nice and friendly atmosphere that is good for any type of dining event.

Our Valentine's Day dinner was a lovely experience. We were seated on the rooftop, which created a special ambiance for the dinner. The service was attentive and cordial, the food was scrumptious. We are looking forward to another special dinner on the rooftop.

Valentines day

Good Valentines Day

Valentines Dinner. Steaks were excellent, vegetables very good, risotto was average. Nice selection of wines by the glass. Bottle prices have the usual heavy AZ markup on them.
Outstanding value as two sides come with an entree.
Will return

Keeler's Steakhouse has become a regular place for my wife and I to have dinner. The food is consistently excellent along with the service. We have never had a bad experience or even close to one. Being located in Carefree, the ambiance of the restaurant is special. I would highly recommend Keeler's as a must stop for dinner.

Randy and Karen Thovson

My husband and I went there for Valentine dinner. The food was good along with the service. I rated this restaurant a 3 1/2 stars......it just wasn’t that outstanding to me to give any higher rating than that.

First time eating here and it was horrible! This was supposed to be a nice dinner for Valentines Day but it was the opposite! The only thing good was the cocktail lol. The service was fine aside from our waitress who was not thrilled at some of the questions we were asking. Seemed like she was judging us. The food was terrible and I mean terrible. WOW! I don’t even know what to say but do not eat here. We got the filet mignon, medium & Oscar style. The crap was fishy and tasted like they put it in a blender and poured it on top. Then we got mushrooms and Brussel sprouts. The mushrooms tasted like they came straight of a can. Not even exaggerating!!! The Brussel sprouts were hard and they didn’t even bother to cut the stem off. We also got the shrimp scampi and the shrimp tasted very chewy but they were a good size. All in all this was one of the worst places we’ve ever eaten at. We did not bother to tell management as we felt they would have not cared. STAY AWAY and go down the street to another steakhouse!

Fantastic service and cocktail selection.

Great place to go for a drink or dinner. I was very impressed by the quality of food and bar options. Usually restaurants would have one or the other. The price is a little on the high side but the service is great and I’d rather pay a little bit more for good service and good food versus bad service and good food. Great place to go on a date and have a conversation. There are sports being played but I wouldn’t consider it a sports bar at all. Definitely will be back.

Service, food and ambience are always top notch and we would recommend this restaurant

Great food staff is excellent went on a windy night and dined up top on their terrace. Very accommodating

Setting and area was beautiful
Food was good but i kinda expected more

Food, service and cocktails are always wonderful. We eating at Keeler's!

Delicious food fantastic service! We will certainly be back!

Amazing!! Always is and the food always comes out perfect!

Too loud and noisy. Difficult to have a conversation at our table. Do not recommend this venue.

My husband's prime rib was so tough that he barely made it through 1/2 of it.
Very disappointing. My sea bass was delicious although the menu said mashed sweet potato and I was served yukon gold. The green beans we too al dente (too hard).

Great food, steaks and fish were cooked perfectly, tender and juicy. great service