Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Sun Prairie
Friday Night Fish Fry$20.00 per personOct 23 - Dec 31, 2020Fried Cod with your choice of a side, includes house salad
Friday Night Fish Fry
Johnny's Happy Hour
We went to Johnnys for a birthday celebration. Everything was wonderful, service, food and atmosphere. Thanks for making out first outing in months very enjoyable.
someone at our table was charged for an incorrect drink they received. overpriced for food you get.
Had a fantastic dinner and our server was awesome!! It was a great night! Cant wait to go again
Hi Katie, thank you for your positive review! We are so happy to hear your experience met the high expectations we strive to meet. We hope you dine with us again soon.
Easily one of the best steaks we have ever had!
My husband and I went to celebrate our 7 year anniversary (and our first date night since our three year old was born) and were blown away by the service and quality. The place was clean, had beautiful ambiance and was nice and quiet. The service was impeccable and everyone was very welcoming and attentive. We ordered the sausage stuffed bread as an appetizer and could have eaten that as a meal it was so good! But the steak, oh the steak! Worth every penny!!
Leah, we are so glad to hear that the meal and service you received met expectations! Thank you for coming in to celebrate with us and taking the time to post your review. Happy Anniversary!
We enjoyed our Friday night date; however, to our surprise the change of the wine list. One of our favorites was increased 10$ since our last visit, our "waitress" was outstanding.
The ambiance was "different" but we love the food and the salad dressing is WOW.
We will be back.
Dennis, we appreciate that you took the time to provide us details of your visit. We appreciate your patronage and look forward to seeing you again!
Server was very friendly, Had the outdoor dining area all to ourselves.
Thank you for sharing your feedback with us, Tom!
Food was excellent as always. I always love going to Johnny's anytime I visit Madison
Kyle, we appreciate your patronage! Thank you for the amazing review, we are so glad to hear that you love dining with us.
It was for my wife’s birthday It was an outstanding night
Thank you for celebrating with us, we are thrilled you enjoyed your evening!
We were seated right away and had a nice private booth. Our waitress was very pleasant and the manager stopped by to personally check on our experience. We'll definitely be returning customers!
Hello! We are so pleased to hear you enjoyed your evening dining with us. We are glad that everything met expectations and we look forward to seeing you again!
Our first date night in a long time and Johnny's was an excellent choice. I was happy with their limited menu options, and was confident that they were taking the necessary precautions to keep their patrons and staff safe. Food was great and the wine, bourbon and scotch selections were better!
Adam, we are so thankful that you both chose Johnny's for your date night! We appreciate the wonderful feedback.
Great service and food again. The only thing was out of the wine you introduced us too the first visit. Paid $9 more for the other one. It was excellent wine and my wife was worth it. Staff explained why and we know they will have it next time.
Dennis, we are very sorry that we were out of the wine that you wanted during your most recent visit. WE appreciate your understanding and look forward to your next visit!
Very slow service. Steak was tough. Food and beverages were pricey and quite frankly, didn't impress me at all. Not surprised since it is a hotel restaurant.
Eric - thank you for informing us about your visit. I am disappointed to hear that your meal was not up to our typical standards. We take pride in our restaurant and we appreciate hearing from our guests if something was not up to the high expectations we strive to meet. Please know that the information you provided us has been shared with our team for review.
All food and drinks were very good. Had sausage-stuffed bread appetizer and Johnny's Minelli pasta (fettucine with garlic cream sauce) and grilled salmon.
Great choices! Thank you for your wonderful feedback!
It was a wonderful time. We celebrated our 19th Anniversary and it seemed special. The restaurant did tables that were social distancing outside & everyone wore their masks to prevent Covid-19, which made us feel safer and relaxed. The ambiance was nice with a nice warm breeze blowing and romantic music playing and the food was delicious. What a great evening !
Diane, thank you for coming in to celebrate your anniversary with us! We are so thrilled everything about your visit met the high expectations we strive to meet. We hope to see you again soon - Happy Anniversary!
Staff is fantastic. Very nice outdoor seating and ambience. Menu selection lacking and not great value. Paper menus quite tacky. Great drink selection.
Update: the restaurant reached out to me, letting me know the paper menus are due to the pandemic. I wasn’t aware of this at the time, but I’m glad to know they are taking these precautions!
Kelly, thank you for providing us your feedback. Unfortunately, at this time we are using paper menus so we can make sure our customers are staying safe with the COVID restrictions.
Birthday great service
Thank you for coming in to celebrate with us - we are glad you enjoyed your experience!
We went here for our 47 year anniversary. The steak was absolutely fantastic.
The server was very knowledgeable, and the service was excellent. We will be going back and enjoy it again.
Dennis, we are so thrilled that you both had such a wonderful anniversary celebration with us! Happy Anniversary!
Loved the outdoor patio.
Thank you for sharing your review - we are happy to hear you enjoyed our outdoor patio!
Enjoyed our outdoor seating! Our server was amazing. Started out with Italian Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms that we’re very flavorful. Our entrees were Parmesan Crusted NY Strip Steak and Cedar Plank Salmon, both were savory! Capped it off by sharing a slice of the Limoncello Cake - wow!! The lemon, raspberry and citrus were mouth watering. Great date night to celebrate my husband’s birthday!
We are thrilled you enjoyed your meal! We appreciate that you took the time to post your wonderful review. Thanks for dining with us, Karen!
We were looking for a replacement for Flemings and we definitely found it! Steaks were top notch, service was excellent and we saved some money!
Mike, we are very pleased you enjoyed your visit with us! We look forward to seeing you again - thanks for the spectacular review!
Very nice spot with great choices and attentive staff
Dianne, we are glad to hear that both the meal and service you received met expectations. Thank you for submitting your review!
Our waiter Jeremy was awesome. Food hasn’t let us down yet. Wish there was more seafood options like lobster at this time, but I understand.
Jason, we definitely understand your frustration with the limited seafood choices during this time! We hope that in the near future that we are able to get more of a variety again. We appreciate your review and we hope to see you again soon!
Duughters pre-graduation dinner.
Thank you for having your celebration dinner with us! Congratulations on the graduation!
Was wonderful ! Went there for the wife birthday really enjoyed . Food was great and the service was excellent . Waited a little while for the entree’s. But once I taste it I see why? You can’t rush perfection. Wonderful place . Will be going all the time.
William, it means a lot to us here at Johnny's that you choose to have your birthday celebration with us. We are so thrilled that you enjoyed your evening and we look forward to seeing you again!
I had heard many good things about this place and made sure to take advice on ordering the steak. It was 36$ for the 10oz filet and I had ordered it medium.. the first try it can me out purple which was the most rare I’ve ever seen, second try it still was just above rare also..Third try I could tell it was much smaller but decided it would work as I was hungry at this point; manager did not take it off the bill but offered a dessert as we had already closed the bill. I don’t eat desserts so that was disappointing. The soup was really good but be sure to check your steak. Would have liked to see this be fixed in store but it wasn’t.
Hello, we are very sorry that the steak you ordered wasn't cooked to your preference and that we did not handle the situation correctly. I assure you that your feedback has been shared with our executive team so we can use it as a training tool going forward. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
We had a wonderful Fathers Day dinner. Great service.
My linguini and clams was great, but my guest had a tenderloin that was pretty chewy. Not what we expected. We should have sent it back.
Outstanding food and service - will definitely be back as the extensive menu was impressive ad well. A nice birthday dinner...
Food was amazing. Waitress was great, but food service was slow.
Food was adequate for the amount that we paid specifically for taking over an hour and half during a non busy time to receive our food.
Service was great. Our server Jaimie was top notch. Hope to have her again the next time we go.
Jason thank you for the wonderful review. I am so happy to hear you enjoyed everything! I will be sure to share your compliments with Jaime. We hope to dine with you again!
Everything on point. Timing was great for lunch hour.
Me and my fiancé were celebrating our anniversary and couldn’t have picked a better place to go. It was our first time there and the service was amazing and food was delicious as well. We even had our own little private area so it felt more secluded and special. As if it were just the two of us in the whole place. Definitely will be returning again soon.
Thank you for the wonderful review and happy anniversary! So happy you both enjoyed and they were able to provide a romantic night. We hope to dine with you again soon!
Great service began with the bartender and continued throughout seating and serving staff. Food was excellent as expected as we have frequented multiple Johnny’s locations over the years.
Don thank you for the 5-stars and recommendation. I am so happy to hear you enjoyed everything and we greatly appreciate the support!
We came to Johnny's to celebrate my birthday and couldn't have been happier! The staff was great from the bar tender to the waitress. Food was excellant and ambiance was perfect.
Alice thank you for choosing to celebrate your birthday with us! So happy to hear you enjoyed everything and they provided a great experience. We hope to dine with you again soon!
Melissa was FANTASTIC! Great Food.
Thank you for the 5-star review. I am so happy to hear you enjoyed everything! We hope to dine with you again soon!
Ran out of cesar salad...my dish was not to my satisfaction. Wasted my money and time.
Cory thank you for the feedback I sincerely apologize your meal and experience did not meet expectations. I have shared with both management and the culinary team. Again, I appreciate you bringing to our attention.
It is refreshing to be able to have a quiet and private dining experience in this day and age. Food was delicious and appropriately priced. Server was attentive and friendly.
Ama thank you for the review. It makes us so happy to know you enjoyed your meal and experience. I can't wait to share your review with the team. We hope to dine with you again soon!
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Sun Prairie offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (608) 856-4040.
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Sun Prairie is rated 4 stars by 354 OpenTable diners.
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse - Sun Prairie does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://heartofamericagroup.com/gift-cards/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.