The tenderloin fillet, Nancy garlic bread stuffed with cheese, fresh fish, handcrafted pizzas and herb roasted chicken are signature items off the menu. The bar at Johnny Manhattans serves vintage, classic cocktails and a selection of beers to enjoy with appetizers. The restaurant also hosts private events and parties.
Add $2 each Topping: Mozzarella Cheese, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Banana Pepper; Add $3 each Topping: Bacon, Green Olives, Artichokes; Add $4 each Topping: Fresh Tomatoes, Kalamata Olives
Italian Breaded Tenderloin, Linguine, Marinara, Bell Peppers & Onions
In House Cut "Prime" Steaks
Great food and service
Very very nice place to eat. You will not be disappointed
The entire staff (greeters, bartenders, seater, and waitress) were so fantastic!!
The food: meatball appetizer to start & then 3 steaks (2 ribeye and 1 filet) were phenomenal!!
Steak was great. Upgraded to a load baked potato($6 charge). The “loaded” part wasn’t even worth $2, let alone $6. Ordered blue cheese salad dressing (an additional $3). The amount of salad dressing wasn’t even 1/8 cup.
Overall food was good and would go back. Just be careful of the overpriced upgrades.
As always....Absolutely Fabulous!! We both ordered the Petite Filet, which we have had before, and it was delicious. Our server, Noah, was attentive, polite, and topped off the evening with his great enthusiasm and humor!
Outstanding food and atmosphere! One of our favorite places.
Another amazing dinner!
My husband and I had the herb crusted Salmon and Spinich salad with hot bacon dressing which we thought was delicious. The salmon was baked perfectly. Our son had the large filet. He found that it was seasoned and prepared perfectly. Our server, Noah, was both attentive and entertaining. We look forward to our next meal with them.
Fantastic and friendly service coupled with delicious food!
The atmosphere was nice and the food was good. It’s a great place tucked out of the way. Was surprised to see that some servers wore masks and others didn’t. But we went early enough and the place wasn’t too crowded. I do feel like they did a nice job of keeping people spaced apart. I would go back!
I had the pork chops...I have NEVER had better! I recommend one grilled and the other one breaded.
Dinner and service was AMAZING! We had steaks and pizza. Their pizza is the best in the area and their steaks have the best flavor.
Thoroughly enjoyed the full dining experience at Johnny Manhattan’s from booking the reservation to pulling out of the lot. Food and service was great- it capped off a wonderful weekend. Looking forward to going back!
Food, service, everything was outstanding. Will definitely go back again. Our server, Will, was amazing!
Food and service were stellar. We loved the ambiance and decor of this restaurant. Perfect for a special occasion. All of our courses were above par in taste and presentation.
Portions of food was low compared to price. I had the Lamb.
Everything overall was great and had a pleasurable dining experience.
Always a wonderful, relaxing visit, with great food and great service!
The service, drinks & food were great! We enjoyed our Valentine's dinner.
Just another outstanding meal at Johnny’s. The eggplant fries appetizer were the best I have ever had. The spinach salad with the hot bacon dressing was fabulous. Clean baby spinach with a perfectly balanced dressing. Our entrees were very good but that side of fresh vegetables were unbelievably great.
It was fantastic, it was a very cold day so we were seated by the big indoor fireplace. The food was excellent with a good size portion. I have no complaints about Johnny Manhattans, it’s wonderful.
Was very good. Service was excellent and our waiter was fabulous. No feeling of being pushed out or hurried along.
Slow service, packed restaurant. No masks at all. No social distancing. Food was ok, nothing spectacular.
Great customer service, good food.
I only saw a couple of employees wearing a mask and the restaurant was filled to capacity.
Always an amazing experience. Food was amazing. We had Noah for our server and he always elevates the experience with his knowledge and humor. Can’t wait to come back!
I have been going there for over 20 years. They do not disappoint! When I have friends in town this is where I always take them.
Food was fantastic. Service was great and the atmosphere was relaxing and inviting.
Servers/ staff should really wear masks
Birthday celebration. Staff was wonderful and even sang HappyBirthday
Best meal we've had in long time! I had the scallops and my husband had the salmon. Both were amazing! The service was very good and attentive and I feel the price was just right for what we ordered. We will be back!
Service was excellent but the food was less than desirable. The scallops were fishy, the tenderloins in the Spiedini tasted gamey, and the chocolate cake tasted like it had been in the freezer for a long time and was freshly thawed before being brought to the table. The hot bacon salad tasted ok and the veal meatballs were dry. The table bread was chewy.
Johnny Manhattans has been a favorite go to place for my wife and I for years. Best steaks around, better than Flemings. Fantastic Italian dishes and fresh seafood. We also order pizza for pick up regularly, fantastic pizza. The best reason is their quality of food is ALWAYS consistent.
Patrick D. Clark
Always a great place for dinner, service is always good and food is well worth the trip to Hubertus
Had a great meal and great service
Very disappointing dinner. They were apparently busier than expected and we’re out of quite a few dishes - they have down sized there menu recently so add that to the items they were out of and the menu was quite limited- no fish options
Food was fine. Several of us had the petit filet and two of them were overcooked. We ordered a side dish of asparagus and literally got a dish with six skinny peices of asparagus for $6.00.
Apparently the lamb chops were very good.
Bar service was great
Still a great atmosphere but we were all disappointed in the quality and taste of most items
This was our first time experiencing Johnny’s and I have to say we were pleasantly impressed! Everything about the place was top-notch. It has a old-time supper club vibe with craft cocktails and signature specials. The service was very friendly, attentive and all around just great. We will be back!
The food was excellent as always, but the server asked if we were celebrating something and my husband stated we were celebrating 9 years after life saving cancer surgery. He said he would bring us a dessert to help celebrate, and then he forgot to follow through. My husband didn't finish his meal because he saved room for dessert. We will return, but hope we don't get the same server.
Have always received top notch service and food here. We continue to patronize during pandemic to do our part to keep them open. Only note was lasagna seemed less cheesy than in the past. Small filet and spedini didn't disappoint.
Always good. Wish our server would have worn a face madk.
Johnny Manhattan's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (262) 628-7700.
Johnny Manhattan's is rated 4.7 stars by 585 OpenTable diners.
Johnny Manhattan's does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.johnnymanhattans.com/gift-cards/.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.