Joe & Joe Nyack, Italian Eatery
Originally established in the Bronx in 1940, Joe and Joe is a family-run, neighborhood restaurant specializing in classic Italian American cuisine.
The legacy continues with Joe and Joe Nyack – a modern eatery serving up classic dishes with a fresh take.
Great local place to eat. Had a very good dinner. Service is friendly & attentive. Owner makes you feel welcome when you arrive. Highly recommend.
The eggplant was 5 inches tall. Delicious. Couldn’t finish. Anthony waiter chased me into parking lot with my leftover! Who does that anymore! Little pricey but then again it’s Nyack. Definitely give it a try, our third time there & we will be back.
Great time, great food, great service! Went back for lunch the next day!
The food was phenomenal, the ambiance just perfect.
Very friendly staff from the moment we walked in the door. Our only regret was forgetting to take home our leftovers. Will definately come back.
Excellent food and service
Host very accommodating to our needs
Plan on re-visiting
A gem in Nyack
Spicy shrimp appy along with baked clams were to die for! Good looking young pizza guy 😜 was able to customize my thinny thin crust margherita to perfection. Owner asks customers about their experience. Staff are eager to answer questions & if unsure will check with chef. No guess work. Definitely give it a try.!
Last minute dinner plans. Made a reservation on OpenTable super easy and was seated at a hightop in a modern eatery that was fun for Saturday night
We always enjoy our meals at J&J, we've been going here for a year as its close to family in Suffern. The food is always delicious and the servers (and chef) are attentive and personable. We will definitely be back!
First time eating here and thought the menu had a great selection! Enjoyed our food and will be back to try other items! Nice ambiance as well!
Love the local dining experience! ❤️
Always a great dinner. Specials and the regular menu...the service is excellent- from the hostess to the wait staff and bar manager. Delish deserts!
Great service, food. ambiance & prices. We were welcomed as soon as we stepped in the door. Not only did our server check on us regularly, so did the owner. All the staff were friendly which made it an even better experience.
Mare, we appreciate you taking the time to give us such a great review. We are so thrilled that you're time with us was enjoyable and hope that this will result in future visits. Have a wonderful and Happy New Year!
We dined at Joe & Joe for Christmas Eve dinner. Normally, our family celebrates Christmas Eve at home so I was skeptical, but Joe and Joe’s made us feel like home. Very welcoming and service was excellent. Food was exceptional!
Thank you so much for taking a chance on us on such an important time of year! We are thrilled to hear we were able to exceed your expectations and hope you come join us again very soon!
First time at J & Js and would
recommend it to anyone looking for a nice time. We enjoyed our food and the dining room was well lit.
John, it was a pleasure serving you and your family. I really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us. We hope you'll come and see us again soon. Happy New Year!
My salmon was $25.00. It was served on a small plate, and it was over cooked. I asked for medium rare.
The noise was ridiculous, there was a party in the back room. I wasn’t sure if I was at a night club or a restaurant.
Waiter was nice.
Excellent restaurant - every bite of food was perfect. We loved our waiter and his recommendations were great, too. We'd like to pick up this restaurant and move it to our city.
Everything was great! The service was outstanding. The vegan meatball parm over spaghetti squash was delicious. We will definitely come back to dine at this fine restaurant.
I went to to try out the food for restaurant week with a good friend and everything we ordered off the menu was great and will definitely be coming back again.
The wait time between courses was longer than it should have been. They “lost” one of our entrees and comped us with dessert on the house for our troubles. Food was very tasty, and the menu featured many options for vegetarians, including Beyond products.
Always a great dining experience and the specials are always intriguing and delicious. 5 STARS !!
Tried Joe & Joe's during Hudson Valley Restaurant week. Loved it! The owner, Anthony, sat us and was so friendly and welcoming. Told us his whole history. Felt like we knew him for years! Food was excellent. Had the Arancini and Burrata Salad for appetizers. The Burrata was so fresh and tasty. Arancini were crispy and cheesy and the marinara sauce was excellent. For dinner, we had the Stuffed Shrimp ala Anthony and the Chicken with Broccoli Rabe. The shrimp was absolutely delicous and literal stuffed with a piece of prosciutto (no breadcrumbs) in a scrumptious creamy mushroom wine sauce. So good! The potato croquette was very good as well. The chicken breast was delicious and served with spicy broccoli rabe and cauliflower mashed potatoes. For desert I had the Italian Lava cake, which was just okay, not really a "lava" cake, more like a chocolate cake with chocolate "mousse" and whipped cream. My husband had the pumpkin cheesecake which was really creamy and appropriate for this time of year. Anthony let us try 2 slices of their pizza. It was delicious and we will definitely be returning to try their pizza! It's thin crust make with the finest Italian flour and cheeses. Felt like I was back in Italy. They have a few different varieties of pizza on the menu. Can't wait to try them! Their regular menu had a nice variety of some classics and some unique choices. That's what we like. Something for everyone! Overall, a great experience and can't wait to return to try other things on the menu!!! May be my new favorite restaurant in Nyack!!
Ample parking...Delicious food and scrumptious Martini menu, but the thing that puts Joe & Joe's ahead of the rest is the ambiance...the warmth and friendliness of the host and waiting staff. We had a wonderful first visit and will definitely be returning!
Love the food. A great place to hang with your girlfriends or significant other.
My new go-to. Great food, kind staff and very clean.
The entrees were just ok, nothing special. Neither my husband or I were thrilled with our selection. He had the lasagna and I had the stuffed shrimp. The sauteed fresh vegetables that were served with the shrimp dish was excellent and tasty however. Service was excellent.
I will Definitely be back. Everything was excellent.
Nyack is lucky to have this restaurant in the community.
1st visit there, we sat outside b/c it was beautiful, but there were not enough servers outside even though it was a quiet Sunday night outside, the inside was busier. The food was very good, we will definitely go back again but when the patio begins to get more crowded, additional servers should be sent out there.
Always enjoyable and great food!
It was lovely eating outside on the patio. Plenty of parking. My seafood fra Diablo had plenty of excellent shrimp and clams. It was topped off with fried calamari an unusual touch. Only problem was the sauce was kind of bland. My wife’s meatball parmigiana (excellent) in marinara was much tastier. Overall a good experience.
Food was good, waiter was trying but it was packed and food took a while to come. Loud and difficult to have a conversation.
I do think I would still go back and see if it's better on a slower night. I love the food, interesting menu and all was tasty. (A bit pricey but still worth it)
Sat outside on a lovely night. Food and service were great! Will definitely go back and recommend to others.
Food was amazing! The staff is friendly and attentive. The drinks were creative and refreshing. The atmosphere is warm and inviting! I would definitely recommend for any occasion.
Also booked our holiday party in the private room in the back.
The place is amazing
My friend was late for our reservation, but it was not a problem; the staff could not have been more gracious. I enjoy the rare restaurant where patrons are not sitting on top of each other. And the food was amazing.
Can't wait to go back. We always visit our Nyack friend and make a point of dining at Joe and Joe. Best calamari ever and the pizzas are the best. Great service by Kaitlin and we wish there was a Joe and Joe near our home on Long Island !!
Joe & Joe Nyack, Italian Eatery offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (845) 535-3888.
Joe & Joe Nyack, Italian Eatery is rated 4.6 stars by 75 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.