Il Fornaio - Carmel
Open-faced omelet with mozzarella cheese, tomatoes and spinach; served with smoked Norwegian salmon, asparagus, potatoes and caramelized onions
Gnocchi alla Bolognese
Potato dumplings with traditional meat ragu
Gnocchi alla Norcina
Potato dumplings with black truffle, porcini mushrooms, Grana Padano, parsley, butter & cream
Loved the patio room with the beautiful flowers out the window. The food and wine were fabulous!! Will come again!
It's all good all the time! We look forward to dinner and Happy Hour every time we go.
Excellently prepared and plated, fairly traditional Italian cuisine. Everything was fresh and tasty. Decent size portions. Dessert(custard and gelato fruit parfait) was light and refreshing.
We enjoyed our dinner very much. Every attention was made to detail and the service was excellent. Our food was outstanding.
Waited One and one half hour to get cold food and restaurant was not crowded at all????
Carlos is a great waiter. Attends to every need and has a great attitude.
Service was terrible! People who came in after us, were served well before us. We had to ask for our salads twice, before they were brought. My meal was tasteless, I should have sent it back. Very disappointed!
Chicken dish was over-cooked and the sauce made the taste even worse. Waiter seemed to care less and service was horrible.
Love Il Fornaio -
Always great food - had a take out order last night and it was just as good as being there!
A perfect 5 out of 5 dinner. The only negative was the extremely uninterested gentlemen that checked us in on our arrival. Other then that, top notch!
It’s a friendly staff with a fun atmosphere and great food.
The service was very slow, food was horribly over cooked. The building was beautiful.
AT&T. Our server was great!!
The food excellent!! We were in a great corner of the restaurant.
It was small and there was a table with a very lid person. It did affect the ambiance.
Otherwise, all was great!!
As usual, Il Fornaio doesn’t disappoint: food and service are excellent, always seated on time, great ambience
When we head to Carmel for a weekend we usually dine here. The staff is friendly, good service and consistently delicious! The Gnocci the night we went was awesome!
Went here for Carmel Restaurant Week and ended up leaving very dissatisfied. The restaurant appears neglected and the service was on par with ordering at a self-serve kiosk in a fast food chain. Food was mediocre at best.
Best Italian food in Carmel Always have great meal / service
The service was great and really enjoyed the ambiance but the food itself was really disappointing. Presentation wasn’t horrible but it just tasted very poor.
Il Fornaio Carmel is one of my favorite restaurants - I've been there many times usually with mt bridge friends at the Monterey Regional bridge tournament. My friends the Fosters, who have a second home in Carmel also love this restaurant.
I also like several other Il Fornaio's, in Palo Alto and Burlingame, also Rocklin (or Roseville) where my daughter lives.
We had a weekend in Carmel and so happy we chose to come here . It is a beautiful resturant with amazing stafff! And of course the food was delicious!
As always, delicious authentic Italian Cuisine, super & friendly service from the reception to servicing the meal. Great environment for any occasion. Love Il Fornaio, our favorite restaurant. I always recommend it for friends and family with gusto!
Starting to lose their touch. The cost is no longer justifying the experience.
Great ambiance, friendly vibe, beautiful space and lovely service but the food was pretty lousy. Low quality, high volume fare. Bruschetta was cold, mealy, under-seasoned tomatoes. If tomatoes are out of season or sub-standard then they shouldn’t be on the menu. Pasta dishes were very mediocre.
We loved this restaurant so much we ate there both nights that we were in Carmel. Don’t get me wrong, there are a lot of other good restaurants to choose from, but for us the experience, service and the food was so good we just wanted more.
Waited almost an hour after our confirmed booking time for our table - when we asked about our table we were told that it “was not our fault” and it was no big deal because what did we expect on a Saturday night - a little humility and remorse would go a long way. The food was really good however and once seated service was good
The restaurant allows itself to over book badly.
We arrived at 6:55 for a 7:00 reservation.
We were told we would be seated in “just a couple minutes”.
At 7:30 upon insisting to know where we were; we were told there were still three parties waiting to be seated in front of us and that it could be 20-30 more minutes
We discussed with the manager and left.
This reflects badly on Il Fornaio but it also reflects badly on OPEN TABLE.
Open Table has a responsibility to ensure restaurants don’t badly over book.
Shame on Open Table for allowing this to happen.
It was parents 50th anniversary. I included this info in the reservation and informed the hostess at the restaurant upon our arrival. Didn’t make one bit of difference. Our waiter was a gem, but the food was mediocre and the overall experience forgettable. Mostly annoyed the hostess managed to just ignore anything I said and did nothing to make the evening special.
Had the lobster special and it was great. Special included a nice beet salad (or soup if you prefer) and dessert (chose spumoni but affogato was also available). Service was very attentive (lots of water refills). Carneros brut was reasonably priced.
WE went there for dinner on Christmas day. I think it was a long stretch for the kitchen staff, waiters and we ended up with the short end of the stick. We had to send our starters back as they were cold. The presentation of the food was poor. My wife had Caprese which arrived with chunks of cheese and thickly sliced tomato and no seasoning. I had the Vodka seasoned pasta dish which was just acceptable but nothing to talk about.
Needless to say, we did not take a chance with dessert.
We thoroughly enjoyed the meal and the service was great. What more could you ask??
We had a very nice evening on a very busy Christmas Eve holiday.
Have eaten there many times and they were great again
The service was excellent and the food was very good as usual. This is one of our favorite places in Carmel.
Food was good-service good will return
Main course served cool. Soup was warm watery and tasteless. I was offered cheese on pasta after I finished. No forks with dessert. Couldn't believe how coffee was served.
I'm thankful I didn't inform them we were celebrating a special occasion.
I suppose the "New Management" is also new to running a restaurant.
Food was excellent, service was great, and ambience was romantic.
Very nice restaurant. Unfortunately the food was cold and the waiter was not Very good. Did not let my kids order the full menu if I didn’t order it myself, disappeared at times and made mistakes in our bill.
It was Thanksgiving!
Just the 2 of us. The restaurant had a good crowd with positive sounds. It was decorated well.
The staff was attentive and upbeat.
Food was excellent!
My one comment to think about was no gluten free turkey dinner option.
I did get chicken which was excellent.
They did advertise Gluten free Thanksgiving dinner but not in reality.
We enjoyed ourselves and thank them much!!
Great Thanksgiving meal! Everything done to perfection. One of our go-to place for Italian style comfort food.
Il Fornaio - Carmel offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (831) 622-5100.
Il Fornaio - Carmel is rated 4.3 stars by 1589 OpenTable diners.
Il Fornaio - Carmel does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.ilfornaio.com/gift-cards/.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.