Old school and fun
Always a pleasure to dine at it Castello . The service is friendly food is always excellent lots of choices on the fresh fish which we always tend to have one of them . Love it !!!!!
I love Il Castello - my favorite restaurant - always great food, great service, and great dining experience
Always a great meal at Il Castello. Food is delicious
A little gem in Westchester
I had dinner with my friend. Food is wonderful more than we expected.
Wine was superb and the quick and best service. Thank you Leo our waiter! He is absolutely great!
Excellent food. Cozy atmosphere with lots of regulars.
Il Castello has yet to disappoint. Celebrated our anniversary on a quiet Tuesday evening. Lenny and his staff went above an beyond to make this night special for the two of us. The meal was outstanding and we can’t wait to get back to this hidden gem on Mamaroneck Avenue.
Very good food with excellent service. One of the few restaurants where you can actually speak in conversational voice and be heard by everyone at the table.
The ink pasta with Lobster and clams and mussels was sensational . My husband and I shared the meal . The pasta was al dente.. Leo our waiter was attentive and informative . He suggested a great Savion Blanc wine from new Zealand. My sister had the Branzini with herbs and lemon and was moist melt in your mouth .
Looking forward to returning for another memorable meal.
Valentine dinner. Very good food, service and amiance
Made a same day reservation on Valentines day for 4 people at 7:00. We were greeted at the door with a fine hello and our table ready for us. The service was excellent. Leo and the rest of the staff were friendly and attentive. The food was outstanding. Appetizers were well made and well sized. The entrees were delicious and again not overly large but more then enough for a healthy portion. Dessert was surprising as the Ricotta cheesecake was one of the best I have ever eaten. We will be back
The food here was exceptional from appetizer thru dessert
Our waiter Leo was attentive and always at hand to help or answer questions. He made our evening very special
Always a great meal with great service. Thanks Lenny!
Great food, ambiance and service. Our new go to place for a great meal.
It's a shame, Il Castello food was always delicious but the service staff was very unattentive, it made our last dinner so unenjoyable. There is no excuse, the restaurant isn't that big. We'll return, hopefully, Lenny will improve the service staff.
Great time! The staff was very friendly and helpful and the food was amazing. Will definitely go back!
Consistently fine cuisine with friendly, attentive service. It is our Italian restaurant of choice in Southern Westchester.
We were a party of six. Everyone's meal was delicious. Colorful presentation, smelled wonderful, and tasted even better. The staff is always attentive and friendly. A go-to establishment for us.
I really wanted the swordfish, but they ran out of it. The prongs of my fork were askew. They offered no fruit for dessert. Most fine restaurants offer strawberries with whipped cream. Other than that, my follow-up dish was good.
The dinners we all had were fantastic. The swordfish was outstanding. The portions were exceptional and we all had take outs for the following evening. Hats off to Lenny!
Very much a small local place that caters to their regular customers. In fact most of the restaurant seemed to be populated with regulars. Special Branzino was the best fish I have ever had . . .. however, salad was nothing special, three veal dishes ordered by 3 other diners were not at all good and pasta was to quote my husband, "probably Ronzoni." for the prices go elsewhere for Italian food, if an italian restaurant cannot serve good pasta and good veal then what's the point?
Westchester’s gem. Love this place!!!!
Food was excellent. Quarters were a little tight, I imagine because this restaurant is so popular and-busy they try to accommodate as many as possible and keep the customers moving at fast pace.. We got the last reservation on a Saturday night. The waiters were professional and gracious. Honestly, we felt a little unappreciated and rushed out when our bill came from manager -when we hadn’t even received our coffee or dessert. He was apologetic and offered after dinner cordials when he realized , however message was sent; No lingering too busy! Food was delicious though -guess we were lucky to have reservations on such a popular night
Il Castello!! Excellent every time...
Il Castillo is consistently good and very friendly. The help is genuine and sees that you have what you need or want - I have never had a bad meal!
Consistently outstanding, with delicious food, warm and attentive service, and pleasant atmosphere. Lenny greets you by name and always checks to make sure you are happy with your dinner. Specials are numerous and reflect creativity. Excellent veal dishes; fish is top-quality. Branzino is especially good. Service is friendly; your water glass is replenished often. Valet parking is a definite plus, especially in cold weather, and is efficient. In sum, Il Castello continues to be a gem as well as an excellent value.
We come here the time, and the food,device and attention are always on spot. I always recommend it to all my friends. We have never had a bad experience.
A bit expensive as we all went for the “special”...1/2 lobster, calamari and mussels. But what the hell, it was Christmas eve. Absolutely delicious. And the grassini, the mini breadsticks...a nice touch. Had to order more.
We have been coming here for quite some time since we discovered it. The food is terrific and the staff is so friendly and pleasant. They go out of their way to make your experience perfect. We not only go for occasional date nights but also for special occasions. It is perfect to bring a large family. There is something for everyone.
Wonderful staff, service, food. Warm and convivial atmosphere.
Always good. A local favorite. I can count on Il Castello for good food and great service.
Fantastic time. Great staff. Very attentive. Would recommend for parties of 14 or so.
This Italian food is the highest quality presented and served with professional finesse by a terrific staff.
Same owners also have a sister restaurant in larchmont. Lenny’s which we love as much. Thanks to lenny for making these two fantastic dining choices in the sound shore. Love them both highly recommended!!!!
Lenny continues to make this proper Mamaroneck Restaurant a true gem for classic Italian dining. Listen carefully to the specials as each one is carefully selected based on the freshest ingredients and the chef has a perfected recipe book. Veal Valdostana literally melted in my mouth. Il Castello draws an older crowd compared to his other Restaurant “Lenny’s Seafood and Steakhouse “, but I think the clientele are wise to the slightly upscale dining options here.
Once again a great meal in a great restaurant. Thanks!
We were there for Thanksgiving. A turkey dinner was offered but everyone in our group ordered from the regular menu. The food was delicious! We’d definitely go back!
Always a great meal !This is our "goto" restaurant , that we go to regularly. The food is varied enough to always get a new taste. Service is truly impeccable. And on Mondays, we go to their sister restaurant, Lennys in Larchmont for similar fare, plus prime steaks.
Yep, good food consistently.
The food and service were excellent. The noise level was very high that I had trouble hearing people at our table. The other couple has eaten here during the week and told us that noise is not a problem. We will definitely return but on a weekday night.
Excellent as always! A must if you like branzino fish, set at your table! Great risée wine and very friendly team. A gem in Mamaroneck!