During the day, Connor was impeccable in his service. The ladies manning the bar in the evening need to be more attentive and engaging with their patrons than just talk amongst themselves.

Staff made a mistake and corrected it right away. Only thing we were disappointed in was when we substituted homefries in our meal for salad and was charged $5. We were not informed ahead of time of this hidden expense. Nonetheless we will be back.

We have been coming to Hemingways for the past 20 years, and never, had a bad meal nor bad service. Consistently experience. My daughter and her family have had the same experience. Always focused on the customer.

Really enjoyed the clam chowder and steak and ale pie. The server was delightful. A nice casual spot in the Village. Will definitely go back.

Always a good place to meet - friendly, choice of upper level ‘sun porch’ or cosy first floor pub style ambience. Food is decent, location fab.

We had exceptional service from Connor - many thanks

Great food and service. Always alot of energy and friendly people. Love the rooftop and the upstairs bar.

Great place to eat, drink and meet with friends or family. Covid protocols were in place so we felt safe. Servers were very pleasant; the food good quality and good value. We were sitting at a table, and to our left were people sitting on the other side of the glass/plexiglass facing us. It did not deter our attention and ability to chat and have fun, but seemed a little strange. The stairs leading up to the upper seating level seems tired and dingy. A new coat of paint might perk it up? My comments might seem a little picky, but I am just trying to be honest. I have been here many times and will continue to come. Great ambience!

The restaurant was accommodating of our need for a main level table when told about physical limitations of a couple of people in our party. The service was terrific, the menu has something for everyone, and the food was great as always.

Love coming to this bar! The staff are wonderful, the service is great and the atmosphere is perfect for drinks with friends or a date!

It was good experience

We had lunch sitting at the bar. It was really fun afternoon, thanks in large part to
the delightful bar tender, April. She's a great sport and was quick to engage in
quick-witted chit chat. We'll definitely be returning to Hemingway's in the next couple of weeks.

Hostess was rude and waitress service was bad

Hemingway’s is always a good go-to for a casual lunch or dinner. I enjoyed the special seafood pie and all in my party enjoyed their food— cheeseburger, fish tacos, seafood linguine, clam chowder.
The upstairs patio is a great place and I really liked knowing that everyone even on the patio had to be double vaxxed.
I am only taking off a star because the service was a little slow and despite asking 3 times I did not get mayo.
However, I completely understand as the restaurant may have been short staffed ( as many are during Covid).
I highly recommend Hemingway’s as a fun casual place to have a nice meal.
Personal note: I wish you would bring the perogies back—- they were SO good!!

Amazing brunch - love the new section :)

The service was great! The food was delicious and came out very quickly. I’ve been here numerous times and they never disappoint!

We were disappointed by the service we received at Hemingway's. Our servicer was disinterested all night long. One of the children at our table asked "why is he so angry?" The parent of the child suggested to her child that people are sometimes like that and the best thing we can do is to react with kindness - perhaps that will change the person.
Our table was located on the patio. (covered by an awning) When it started to rain, members of our party were getting wet. Our server was nowhere to be found. We decided to move to a drier table. In the midst of moving, our server arrived. Telling him our reason for moving (my left side of my body was very wet) he commented "yah, we always have trouble with that table when it rains"
If he knew that - why did it take so long for him to appear?
Very disappointing - but not out of character (given our experience so far that evening)
We have been to Hemingway's in the past. Each time we have been there - a most enjoyable experience.
Not this time.

Good meal for Saturday lunch

Most enjoyable Happy Hour. Regular customer on Fridays.

My colleagues and I had a really great time. It was vert friendly and helped our team to get to know each other in person.

Excellent service but food no where near as good as it used to be. Salads that used to be awesome now ho-hum. Dried up chicken strips, burnt pecans, etc. Will think twice about going back.

Very disappointed Hemingway chose to,have work done by the patio during the lunch hour. Jack hammer noise was ridiculously loud and annoying spoiled the whole lunch

My wife and I have been here multiple times. For being in Yorkville, The value and food quality for the price cannot be beat. Unfortunately Covid has lowered the volume of people sitting at once but this place will be packed again next summer.

Favorite local pub

Staff were pleasant and helpful. Nachos on a previous visit were not really up to industry standards.

Great food and service! Totally appreciated the check at the door for proof of vaccine. All patrons were checked and nobody gave the fellow a hard time. The roof top patio is amazing with plexiglass dividers between tables.

Since we felt safe, we were able to really enjoy ourselves. Had a terrific server and great food. Will be back!

Food was good, but the service was a little bit slow

There were five of us on a table for four with an extra chair so not a lot of room my food arrived cold I didn’t send it back as they were too busy but an enjoyable lunch

I have been to Hemingway’s few times in the past and always had a good experience, unfortunately not this time! We started with some fries and Chicken souvlaki - it was so bad that I had to drop a review - it was tasteless, dry, overcooked, no salt, and absolutely no other flavour! It was a disaster that we were not ready to order any further! Please fix it, I would like to be able to come back again!

My one complaint. Food was on the cold side. Despite that I will be back.

Excellent birthday lunch outing. The hostess and server were very helpful and attentive to our needs (I should've asked their names!). We got a nice corner table, to have a fun afternoon over some wine and lip smacking food: Shrimp Popcorn (crisp and spicy), Sirloin Strips and our favorite dish - Jambalaya! The perfect accompaniment to some chilled beer. All in all, a fab experience. Our second time there, but we'll be back again.

The omelette was terrible. It was cold and definitely wasn’t 2 eggs. The potatoes were old … leftovers from another day and they were cold. Coffee was also lukewarm. Won’t be going back for brunch. Very disappointed.

My fish and chips were so doughy it wasn’t fried properly. Also we ordered apps and before we could finish they brought out our mains. We had to maneuver in our small table and by the time we get to our mains they were already cold.

The only downside was a made a reservation for the high top and had to sit elsewhere due to excessive guests in the high top area.

Always love this place - let us in early. Sanitized tables and followed safety procedures.
Service was prompt but not too intrusive.

Fab location and patio cat be beat. Every single employee was just terrific and especially our server. And finally the food (fish tacos) just yum. Cant wait to go back

This is an excellent patio. Great place to meet friends for a causal meal.

Not a place for coffee, tea, food in general & dessert. Unfortunately, my family were very disappointed knowing that this restaurant is in the high-end Yorkville. Prefer to go to other pubs for beer and drinks.:(

It’s overrated. Decent spot, no bad at all but not great 😌

First time going… was very impressed! Great atmosphere, perfect service