Heartland Pizza Company

Although it was busy, we had a reservation and were surprised how quickly we were seated and served!

Great pizza and homemade ice cream. The food is fresh and wonderful. The drinks were great too. I really like that they have vegan options too. We had a larger group and they were able to accommodate us very comfortably.

Very good food & great service! Genuinely care about there customers & making sure all is good.

This was our first time here, but we will be back! My daughter has several food allergies and you guys did an awesome job of meeting her needs!

New Years Eve

We were a party of 6 and had a reservation for 6:15 pm. When we arrived our table was ready and we were seated immediately. Our server was friendly and helpful. We ordered three pizzas (two of which were combination pizza). They were all very good. We also enjoyed the IPA they had on draught.
Great dinner.

Pizza crust and toppings where very fresh. The sauce was lacking flavor. If they work on their sauce it could be the best pizza in the area. The homemade ice cream was fantastic. The owner came and spoke with us and was very pleasant

Loved the texture of the crust and the fresh greens on the pizza. I love the idea that it’s all Wisconsin products. Salads are unique and tasty. Service was stellar!

So yummy! Service was awesome. Try the homemade ice cream!

Always a great meal and great service coupled with great coupons! Sign up for their email list, it is totally worth it.

I have to say this has been the best experience. The food and staff were amazing:) Nicest people ever!

My daughter’s friends wanted to throw a surprise for her and arranged the meal for a small group of friends. The rest of our family tagged along to eat while the girls celebrated. We had never eaten there and the food was delicious and the service at both tables was wonderful!

Friends liked food. I didn't. Weird setting. Good ice cream

Everything was great. It was surprising that a restaurant with really fresh and tasty food and drinks was very slow. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone visiting Green Bay especially with kids.

Amazing! Best in town! We love Heartland & they are always so friendly.

Heartland is one of our favorite places to attend for date night and even bring our kids every once and awhile for a special family treat.

The pizza was very good. It was a very busy time, so unfortunately the service was a bit slower then I really would have liked but overall I enjoyed it and would recommend anyone in the area to try the delicious pizza.

Everything was awesome-from the salad to the pizza (which was cooked perfectly) to the delicious ice cream. I was definitely impressed and will be back!

Restaurant week special was fantastic. Our family really enjoys this restaurant!

We happened to find Heartland Pizza and were excited about Gluten Free pizza. We ordered 3 pizzas and have plenty left over for lunch tomorrow

Wait staff was wonderful

I would recommend the food. The service could use a serious improvement in terms of taking 25 min to bring drinks out and there were only a few tables occupied. Bringing out peoples food st different times so no one ate together.

Wonderful delicious food and great service not to long of a wait for the food.

The breadsticks were awesome! The shroom and protein pizzas were good, but way too much oil or grease on them, the oil was dripping down my hand as I was eating the pizza. I also didn’t like the diet soda, I would have rather had Diet Coke or Diet Pepsi.

This was first experience at Heartland Pizza. I wanted it to be special for part of the celebration of my daughters graduation from high school. The staff was very welcoming and attentive when we initially arrived. The issue was in the seating. We were seated next to a family who had NO CONTROL over there children. There daughter was literally running around the table BAREFOOT and was allowed to lay on the floor under chairs and tables. The chaos led to a wine glass shattering on the floor. I was relieved to see that the little girl was not seriously injured, however the glass ended up under my table, as well. No injuries to my family either. I felt the manager/owner should have addressed the family and concerns for the other clientele. The pizza was good, but the ice cream was horrible. We ordered one bowl of the flavor of the day to share. It was slimy, icy and disgusting. At the time, we did not want to complain we just wanted to leave the chaos. You would think SOMEONE would have checked to see if anyone was hurt from the glass at our table as well. It was not a celebratory experience.

No wait for a table. Not sure if we were really on their list for a table, but we got seated right away.

First time there, delicious pizza. Great variety on the menu. Great choices for bottled and tap beer.

Very costly for the size pizza available. Left Hungry for sure

Great food and great staff!!! Would recommend to anyone. Plenty of space for larger groups :)

Helpful staff. Good pizza. Thee for birthday. Brought plates and forks I forgot. Wanted a zero calorie uncaffenated soda but did not have.

Pizza and sauces were really good. Prices reasonable. Ingredients are all fresh. Will definitely go again

Their appetizers, salads and pizzas obviously use the freshest and highest quality ingredients ... our family loves the Breadsticks (pizza dough twists), signature salads (Winter Arugla & Apple salad is our favorite)and each visit we try different pizzas and have never been disappointed. Great food, great service, lots of adult beverage choices (beer, wines, etc.) and we sincerely appreciate management stopping by our table to make sure everything was good. Highly recommend!!

Could have made better at home.

Used my birthday dinner coupon. But we love going there for pizza and I’m addicted to their breadsticks! The lunch calzones are mouthwatering, hoping they can become a menu item soon. Oh also love the craft beer selection.

We love Heartland Pizza! I love how fresh the ingredients are. The salads are so good and the portions are large. There are plenty of pizza options as well. My kids love the craft soda's and homemade ice cream. I love the wine selection!

Friends had shared how great the salads were- did NOT disappoint! Freshness overload! The large salad was big enough for 2 meals!

We’ve been to Heartland several times, and it never disappoints! We brought some friends for the first time, and they loved it too. We had the AMAZING breadsticks with delicious house-made ranch. Our friends split a small house salad - the salads are ginormous, so prepare to share! Dinner was an Antipasto pizza for them - beautiful fresh ingredients and fabulous pesto. We were feeling very carnivorous so a Protein was our choice. Great balance of the different meats, right amount of sauce and cheese, and the crust is perfection! We had to top things off with their homemade ice cream. Our server was fabulous at making sure we had everything we needed, and she had a great personality. Darin (the owner) makes a point of visiting every tab,e and making sure we’re having a good time. I can not recommend this place highly enough!

We booked a table for 3 for 6pm on a Friday. We got there 15 minutes early and were seated immediately. Since it was our first time, the owner made sure the host went over the menu in detail with us. We order breadsticks for an appetizer and then ordered 2 pizzas. Breadsticks came out really fast and were great. Then the wait began. The waitress felt so bad, she brought us a free beverage. The first pizza finally came out about an hour after we were seated and it was the small sausage pizza for our daughter. It was burnt to the point she would not eat it. About 10 minutes later our large pizza came out and seeing the first one burnt, the waitress took it back. The second pizza was awesome. The only complaint we made was to not bother making another small pizza because we can’t wait another hour. The manager then brought us out 2 pizzas in boxes saying there was a huge mixup in the kitchen and we should just take these to go. Our daughter then ordered ice cream for dessert. While she was eating that, another small pizza came out in a box. This would be the one to replace the burnt one. By now we are ready for our bill. A huge surprise to us, they did not charge us for anything. We did leave a hefty tip as we did not expect a free meal plus all the extra take home pizzas. In customer service, you are not going to get it right every time, but how you handle the bad situations sets you apart from your competition. Heartland Pizza went above and beyond for customer service and therefore we will be back. The reason I gave them a 3 on service is because the manager and waitress were a 5, but on this day the kitchen staff was a one.

Fantastic small business right here in the Green Bay area. Dough sticks with their ranch is a MUST HAVE!! Great flavor of pizza with a wood-burning touch :)

I was very disappointed that when I arrived 5 mins prior to my reservation on Sat, Feb 9 at 6:30p that I was told that my reservation via Open Table will not be honored and I will need to go on the waiting list. We were told that we would have a table in 20 mins so we immediately placed our order at the bar and then waited over an hour for a table and an additional 30 mins for our pizza. The only thing that prevented us from walking out the door on multiple occasions was they provided us each with a couple free beverages. Even though the pizzas and salad we ordered were outstanding ... one of our pizzas was made incorrectly and there was no way were willing to wait for a replacement.