H2O: Seafood & Sushi
This is my go to place for a great sushi and seafood. The popovers are superb. I have never had a bad meal here and I will come back again as I have many times over
Love H2O - my husband and my go to restaurant for birthdays, anniversaries and just when we want a good meal in a classy restaurant.
Excellent as always. Food and wine were awesome. Keep up the great work
Was my 70th Birthday. My children took us to dinner. Food was great. But was extremely cold asked few times if could turn off air. They did when we finished then was too late Also very dark could not see food I had lobster thermdor was really good too many mushrooms no lobster & daughter hasd filet Mignon Wellington was supposed to have mushrooms none.
Food and service was good
Dining room temperature was too cold
Great, just a little expensive for the area
Excellent service by our waiter Timothy who took very special care to make sure our food allergic don’s meal was safe, delicious and perfect. Very impressed. And the food was incredible. Bartender was excellent as well.
Waiter Stephen was nothing sort of amazing. Made our Mother’s Day, will definitely be coming back again.
We felt that the bus boys provided better service than our server. He forgot to bring us spoons for our coffee, it took a while to get the popovers and a second round of coffee. My mother ordered the baked Brie and it did not come with bread and our server said he would get it but never did. If we actually waited for the bread, we would never be able to eat the Brie. The baked Brie does not taste good once it’s cold so I recommend that there should be bread with the plate. We asked our server for a steak knife and he never got it for us. One of the gentleman’s who brings out the food quickly got us two steak knife (after we asked our server 10+ minutes ago). I don’t mean to be rude but I receive better service in East Islip than this location.
Had to wait past our reservation. They made up for it and it was a great meal.
New York City Prices, but that came with New York City level of service! I was able to get a last minute reservation for 7PM on a Saturday. We arrived ten minutes early, checked in and had a drink at the bar. Bar staff completed the customer they were already with and then helped us politely and professionally. The table was ready fairly close to reservation time and we were seated. The wait/table staff was very nice and informative. All dishes including appetizer, dinner, drinks, dessert and coffee were great and the meal flowed smoothly.
Only issue was when one of the bus staff passing by the table lost a dish from another table causing it to hit the floor and splash up along booth we were in and along side of my wifes clothing. When other staff member saw this happened he quickly apologized, cleaned up the mess on the floor and booth. My wife was a great sport about it, didnt fuss and went to the restroom and cleaned up, didnt do any permanent damage. We didnt make any other complaint about it since it was an accident and the staff member responded quickly and appropriately.
Waitstaff and kitchen delivered a great dinner. There was a bit of a wait between appetizers and entree but otherwise all was good.
Very consistent. Food is always good and service is equal to the task
New England Clam Chowder only OK. Gritty and bland. The lobster roll was very good however since I’m from New England, I was not used to it being warm. The french fries were awesome.
As always food was great..Server was attentive..Timing was perfect for a quiet dinner....
We were there to celebrate my boys birthdays, requested a round table, if possible. Got it. Waitress was fantastic from beginning to end, addressed the boys, was very knowledgeable and very sweet. We all remarked how incredible she was. Food was wonderful. Loved, loved it but the service is really what made it such a memorable occasion.
Great food and great service. Even mom was happy and she’s hard to please!
Always very good food and very good friendly service
Food is always amazing here and the service was great ... Always have good specials also
Great restaurant week and daily specials! The wine pairing for $40 a person is nice deal!
Fabulous dinner last night. Took advantage of Restaurant week menu. Great value. Our waiter Eddie was so attentive. Love the popovers. Branzino’s crusty skin and moist inside was delicious. Sushi was great also.
The best one can say is that the dinner was as we expected and have experienced in past visits
We love H20. Last night we took our family for my husbands 50th Birthday. The food is always excellent and last night our service was exceptional. A+
Place and service was nice. The food was good but nothing spectacular. Ok place for price.
The restaurant week menu was incredible. I got it with the wine pairing, which was a phenomenal value. Their sushi is so fresh and delicious as was my salmon. Our server, Brittany was on point all night.
Everything was wonderful which is what we have come to expect here.
Spoke to the manager regarding his staff. They were the absolute most polite, sweet and engaging group of young men and women that we have encountered in a very long time. Excellent service, excellent food, excellent experience. Thank you H20!!
Food was excellent as usual. I was there celebrating mine and my daughters birthdays.
always a nice experience at H20 - delicious food, excellent service, welcoming staff!
Food was good ...resturant week options were satisfactory. Service is ALWAYS outstanding! Staff at H2O is always top notch...noise level was a bit trying but with it being resturant week it's understandable...all in all enjoyable....thanks for a great evening!
It was my birthday and the food and service was excellent. I was even given a gift card as a-birthday gift by the manager. I can’t wait to go back
We went during restaurant week and added the wine pairing. You start with pop-overs (which more restaurants should do) and proceed with an appetizer, main dish, and dessert. All for only $40.00, not including tax and tip. It was a wonderful meal (get the cheesecake for sure) at a great value!
We visited H2O for the Long Island Restaurant Week. We tried the spicy tuna sushi roll, crispy skin salmon and New York cheesecake. The wine pairing for each dish was on point, and totally worth the price for three glasses of wine at an extra 10$. The tuna and salmon both were fresh and extremely well put together to say the least. The only downside was the cheesecake - it did not match up to the appetizer and the entree. AND, THEY SERVE THE BEST HOT BREAD AND CREAMED BUTTER. I also love the coziness of the ambiance. It is one of the best restaurants in Suffolk county, hands down!
Always pleased with our experience at is restaurant.
Our waiter was attentive and warm. Great food ! Thanks.
We chose H2O for our Easter dinner. I knew it was going to be an expensive experience, and I hoped the food and service would match what we were going to spend. We were not disappointed. The waitstaff worked as a team. They were pleasant, attentive and professional. The worst thing that an upscale restaurant can do is provide great food, but have diner quality service. Although the clean lines of this establishment and the presence of booths and tables with no table cloths can suggest diner, everything else says fine dining including the beautiful cloth napkins. My entre, scallops over fried rice with a kimchi vinaigrette, was superbly cooked and beautifully presented. My wife's entre, a branzino fish filet over asparagus and grape tomatoes, was also superb. The background music was present, but not intrusive or distracting. I have been known to request a decrease in volume at other establishments. We will eat at this restaurant again for a special occasion.
The grand sushi/ sashimi platter is wonderful! The popovers are fantastic! The lobster roll rivaled those of Maine & New Hampshire. We celebrated our anniversary with a delicious meal & terrific service.
Enjoyed another Wednesday Wine Pairing, great value! Loved the scallops and the Creme brulé, the appetizer reminded us of high end tater tots...but still tasty...
We brought friends that were blown away with H2O's sushi! We had such a good time on a Tuesday night sitting in the lounge. Justin took perfect care of us and was very attentive. We brought our
thoughtful "snowflake" card that is so appreciated. It is that kind of customer service that keeps
us coming back to H2O. Making another date to sit outside and enjoy the outdoor fire ambiance
very soon. Only thing I miss are the crab legs~ Love H2O
Our server, the team and food was excellent!