Gramercy Tavern

Fantastic!

We enjoyed our starters and desserts. Didn’t love our main dish, chicken and veal

Wonderful birthday dinner. Exceptional food and service!

We had a reservation in the main dining room and decided to do the seasonal tasting menu, one with the wine pairings, one without.
All of the courses were varied, expertly prepared and delicious. We especially appreciated the spacing between courses, which allowed us to not only enjoy the flavor of each course, but also the overall ambience of the restaurant.
The service was outstanding from beginning to end and they easily accommodated special requests.
We highly recommend the Gramercy Tavern!

One of the best there is. Service is impeccable, unobtrusive, and extremely professional.

This was one of mine and my husbands best dining experiences we have ever had. (And we have dined in some great places.) We would definitely return.

One of our best fixed price meals ever! The seasonal six course dinner was great! And the service is the best of any restaurant!

Good was just okay. Nothing special. Overall feels like a tourist restaurant that has seen better days.

As good as advertised. Food is superb, service is outstanding, wine list is imaginative. We’ll be back.

We ordered the lunch tasting menu with wine pairing at Gramercy Tavern. What a fantastic value! The amount of food and wine we received for the price (which already included tip) was impressive. The food was wonderfully prepared and presented and the staff were very flexible to accommodate dietary restrictions and make substitutions as necessary. For the price for the wine pairing (about $50 a person for 5 courses) we were expecting lower-end wines, but the wines were the same quality as that used for their much more expensive dinner wine pairings. I would definitely recommend going to Gramercy Tavern for lunch for a memorable meal at a great value.

🤗 delightful indeed
Thank you very much
Chris

Birthday lunch

How Gramercy Tavern earned its reputation for good (or great) food is beyond me, my husband and our two dinner guests. The chefs/cooks appear to have dumped nothing other than salt on all the food. My entrée was so bad that it got sent back. My appetizer (pasta with Bolognese sauce) was drowning in oil; it was disgusting. At the end of the meal our waiter did the right thing; she took the cost of my dinner off the tab. If someone gave me a gift certificate to this restaurant, it would be thrown in the trash.

Great combinations on the tasting menu. Look to return soon.

The food was excellent and the staff was amazing, especially our server Toni who made our experience memorable and added her personal touch of hospitality.

Way too expensive!

The food was superb. The service was first rate and really attentive. The deserts were impeccable. Gramercy Tavern will remain in my fine dining rotation for many, many years to come!!

Great choices on the menu. Outstanding service. The wine list is outstanding. Arrived early and had a drink at the bar. Very well organized as they transferred my bill and sat us easily.

Reservation honoured 20 minutes late. Place was so busy that main courses were served a bit less than hot! Hostess was dour and overstressed. Could not handle the pressure!!

After reading your cookbook and all of Mr. Myers’ books I had been so looking forward to GT and you lived up to and exceeded all expectations. Our enthusiastic server was a delight!

Our dinner experience at the Tavern's dinning area was nothing short of spectacular.
The food was excellent, but even better was the service. I was there with my son and daughter celebrating her birthday. Our server made sure everyone was happy, he provided excellent recommendations and was very friendly. The food was fantastic and the dishes were both the right potion and executed to perfection. Would love to come here again.

We came to celebrate my daughter, Meghan, birthday and it was wonderful. Carolyn, our waitress, was terrific.
Thank you for making her birthday a treat.

The Grosso Gals

I particularly enjoyed the tasting menu at lunch. Considering the reputation of the restaurant, it was up to expectations. Interesting dishes at a reasonable cost for the kind of restaurant it is. Excellent service, friendly and helpful in a comfortable setting. We liked the idea of the no tipping policy. We will return.

Ridiculous meal—out of sight amazing! Service was impeccable. Our favorite restaurant on our trip!

Good food, beautiful presentation, but did not blow me away. For the price tag and the Michelin star, I was expecting more.

This restaurant never disappoints. The dining room is staffed with lovely people who are attentive, kind and love the food they bring to you. And everything is delicious. This is cuisine in a great setting.

We loved the atmosphere and beauty of Gramercy Tavern. The staff was friendly and genuine. The restaurant was beautiful and the food was just perfect.

Great place to eat worker are super friendly and a great experience

Second time here with my wife. Probably our best dining experience

Just wonderful in all respects. Kelsey is a gem!
Thanks to all for a great experience.

Very welcoming. Lovely service and great food.

Sad to report that after many years going to GT standards have dropped. The food was Average at best on the seasonal menu. The duck was hit but the portion size was tiny. The pasta was sausage and clams a complete miss quality you get at a bad diner. As mentioned portion size are so tiny that my kids left starving - which make it expensive given the 184 for the pre set dinner. Hopefully a one off miss.

We had a most enjoyable late lunch. Everything we ordered was delicious including the relatively inexpensive market lunch menu and the complementary salad.

Great lunch! Delicious food! Kind service!

We are carnivores but look forward annually to the summer vegetable tasting menu. Chef Michael Anthony is known for his prowess with vegetables. The creativity and deliciousness of this tasting menu is testimony to his genius. Not to be missed!

Food and service was impeccable as always at Gramercy Tavern, however that level of expertise does come at a price! I like the "no tipping" policy, but was a little disappointed to find that the only options in the dining room were a three course or six course prix fixe menu. No a la carte options available. I'll be back at GT, next time might dine at the bar where there are more options.

Still remains one of the best! Food is phenomenal and service is fantastic.

The food was good (the chef likes it spicy), but ridiculously high prices for beer and wine by the glass, 3 - 5 Dollars more than Michelin three rosettes restaurant Le Bernadin; staff is strained, maybe because they do not get tips, that's why the prices for beverages are so high - they say.

I loved my evening at Gramercy Tavern! The food was incredible, and the service was terrific. My only critique was the noise level, but considering the architecture and room size it wasn't surprising that it got a little loud. On the upside, the general cacophony covered the borderline pornographic sounds I made while eating the tilefish course!!

Double birthday