Fri, Sat 11:30 am–11:00 pm
Sun 11:00 am–9:00 pm
Great Restaurant- Food very good
Service very good and sat outside looking over the pond!
Waitress, Amana, was great. Appy's were too. 123
We had a lovely dinner outside...perfect evening for it. Service was excellent...and very caring! This is our third time at Gatsby's Landing. The Brick Chicken is GREAT!!!!
Outstanding in every way! The swordfish special was fabulous, spicy salsa and cooked to perfection! Salads are fresh and delicious. Service is great, John, our server, explained every dish in a way that made them irresistible, he's a real pro. And Emily rocks at the bar!
Our server was very good but the food was very bland. We ate brunch for Father's Day. We would have eaten outside but the awning does not cover all the outside tables so it would have been too hot. Everyone was pleasant but the food was a disappointment. First there is no kids menu for brunch. We had pancakes (3 the size of your head) with no flavor at all. They were dense and heavy. We also had french toast. It was a small portion compared to the pancakes (1 piece cut into 3 strips) and so think it was never cooked all the way thru (sent it back once because as soon as I cut into a piece milky liquid oozed out-didn't feel like getting sick from it). Came back very crispy on the outside (hello cook it low and slow don't char it) but still 2 of the 3 pieces were still a bit liquidy in the center. The duck hash was in serious need of salt and pepper to give it any taste. The bread (just 1 piece no bread basket) given to you at the beginning had the most taste. All in all a nice looking place with pleasant service but the food (which is why you EAT out) is just not flavorful.
We went to Gatsby's Landing for Father's Day and were seated at a waterview table. The tables are nicely spaced , so we could hear ourselves talk. Although the menu was limited, the food was freshly made and very tasty. The waitstaff was friendly and didn't rush us out. We would definitely recommend it.
great staff, great food, great ambiance. can't go wrong with this one! French Toast is a must!
Friendly service, root soup a bit bland and duck generously portioned and tasty, even tender mostly, but too sinewy to be fully chewable. Was told it was a hybrid duck. Dessert light and delicious
Good feed and good service. We liked everything we ordered!
Service was slow initially
We celebrated in anniversary here and they brought us a complimentary small bottle of champagne which I thought was very thoughtful. They satis right by the water inside because it was a cool day. We went to ring the week so it was quiet. My husband said the doc was fabulous. The creme brulee was a little cold but otherwise the food was very good.
Thank you for the extra attention and care!!
Wonderful place, great food, friendly staff. Highly recommended. I bring family, friends and clients here regularly.
Overall, we enjoyed our evening here very much. The service was excellent and we were checked on frequently by the server. Chicken under brick was done to perfection and salad delish. Cocktail was just a little too sweet for my taste but otherwise, a perfect meal. Highly recommended!
I have been to Gatsby’s Landing twice and was lucky enough to get John as our server both times. He is exceptional and really makes a great experience at Gatsbys Landing!
Awesome, friendly staff and service! Delicious locally sourced food, delectable cocktails, and beautiful outdoor patio. They took such good care of us - looking forward to returning.
I am never disappointed when at Gatsby’s Landing with family or friends! The atmosphere is elegant and comfortable. The food is fresh, plentiful, varied and delicious! The wine list is terrific. The great service and attention to detail is consistent and pleasant Whether for lunch or dinner, it’s always one of my top choices.
Fabulous, fresh, and delicious!
Always a great meal and service. Always an experience that’s makes my wife and I want to come back. The Cacio Pepe is a 10
Delicious dinner, nice ambience and staff!
Amazing salad selection!
First visit. Went for lunch. Excellent meal. Started with Tuna Crudo. Wonderful. Also had pasta, Cacio & Pepe. Well done! Tasted pasta Amatriciana. Also excellent. Will be going back to try other entrees.
Try the new Spring menu at Gatsby's...it won't disappoint..the rainbow carrots- shaved baby carrots with a ginger rice vinaigrette...different and delicious...husband had the romaine salad with tomato, feta cheese and avocado was so good..this had a lemony vinaigrette.
Fishes were fresh - loved the swordfish and husband had the branzino..perfect meal and topped off with the ice cream sandwich !
Perfect Mother’s Day meal!
Always a wonderful experience here! Great food and atmosphere! Service is always wonderful!
SO wonderful. I have only good things to say. The servers and bar tenders were amazing, and the owner even talked to us about Gatsby for a while. My mother and I are huge Gatsby nerds, so we really appreciated that. He had a copy of Trimalchio on hand!! Our meals were delicious. I highly recommend the Molten Chocolate Cake. Definitely go there if you get the chance!
Limited menu. A bit expensive. Restaurant empty. Used to be a local go-to...
Beautiful outdoor setting next to a quaint duck pond. Plus good, friendly vibe both indoors and outdoors. perfect date night spot.
What an amazing evening. The service was impeccable, the food outstanding as always and the entire staff made us feel warm and welcome. John and Jenna could not have been any nicer.
High quality food.
Pretty good drinks.
Always a lovely meal, great staff, yummy food and just a nice place to meet friends and catch up!!
The food was excellent. Nice restaurant and a very pleasant staff.
The food here was absolutely delicious but chicken was probably the best chicken I've ever eaten in my life that's how good this was the food the service we ate at the bar the bartenders what fantastic had a great time great food great company would definitely recommend and I will definitely be back again
Engagement Dinner for my friends
Wonderful waiter. Great food. Great value.
Gatsby's Landing never fails to satisfy on every level: food, service, and the gorgeous views of the pond (despite being a cloudy, rainy day!)
John was especially helpful this time, displaying an extensive knowledge of every wine listed on the menu, as well as perfect descriptions of all the specials and anything else we had questions about.
One of my friend even asked if part of one dish on the menu could be added to another dish... and was told "no problem!" It was, as always, a lovely lunch.
I’ve fined at Gatsby’s before and I’ve had great meals but they lowered their bar for Long Island Restaurant Week which was a great disappointment.
Great food and service during restaurant t week. Servers polite and professional and allowed
us to stay at our table and socialize as long as we wanted. Appetizers, wine list, and food was
well prepared and delicious.
Food was amazing and server was great