This includes info about cleaning, sanitizing, social distancing, and usage of personal protective equipment. Learn more.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
Slow Baked Half Chicken, Okinawan Sweet Potatoes, Broccolini
Grilled Heritage Berkshire Pork, Cranberry Apple Sauce, Jasmin Rice, Spigarello, Olives
Thinly Cut Rib Eye Steak, Cherry Peppers, Onion, Cheese
Great food wonderful outdoor area to dine including heaters would definitely return and recommend
Amazing venue and even more amazing staff! Our waiter was extremely knowledgeable about the menu and was very attentive. Gorgeous seating right on a pond! The food was spectacular and fresh. Can’t wait to return soon!
Ambience, food and service was absolutely wonderful!
The server Emily was amazing. Best service i received at a restaurant in a very very very long time maybe even the best service eve. She was polite, she was informative, she was enthusiastic, she was prompt and most of all she was a true professional . She was fabulous. Thank You so much
Great food and drinks!
I felt extremely rushed. We had a 7:15 reservation and sat down about 7:20. The waitress took our order and went to the back. Within under 5 minutes our appetizer was on the table. It was grilled artichoke. It must have been ready to go and just put on a plate with some sauce brought out immediately. Definitely not freshly made. It was cleared off the table right away and quickly followed by our main course. No sooner finished that and dessert was out. We were out of the restaurant by 8:30. The whole experience was rushed. There are probably fast for restaurants that would have taken longer.
Great anniversary dinner during the pandemic! Socially distant done property. Food was excellent. Ambience was great overlooking the water.
We will definitaly go back. Everything about it was great!
Food and service was fantastic. I was a bit disappointed in the ambiance. We were seated at the last table outside by the parking lot and our view was of a trench digger in the pond. Not ver romantic but we made the best of it.
Waitress and staff very attentive
Really nice place for an awesome date night
Prices are not proportionate to the quality of the food. The crab cake was very dry. The clams and octopus were nothing special and the branding was flavorless. The watermelon martini was good. I wouldn’t return.
Food was ok, lamb was undercooked but outside was burnt. Same goes to the sliders- the beef patty and bun were burnt! Even McDonald’s could grill the patty better than that.....The view was nice but tables were not 6’ apart and outdoor seating space was cramped! I looked forward for the dinning experience but was disappointed.
The restaurant was busy as it was a beautiful day. The outdoor seating is first come first serve. I had put in my comments when I made the reservation that I would like outdoor seating because I have a 4 month old baby. It did take 40 minutes once we arrived for our reservation for us to get a table outside. The manager was very helpful and accommodating, but we still had to wait quite a while.
Once seated, the atmosphere, service, and food was all excellent.
Overall, one of the worst dining experiences I and my family have had. Staff was rude, and particularly condescending at times. Food was mediocre at best, when we got food finally served without any hairs or other foreign objects. Staff fought in front of us, and stood by our table not to do their job and wait on us, but rather to hear what we had to say overbearingly. I never plan on going back, and I suggest you pick another location to dine.
This was a great place to have lunch. They had outside dining with the view of the pond. The waitress was very attentive and nice. We had the special of the day appetizers (a crab cake on a fried green tomato and pepperoni flatbread) and it was so delicious!
Everything was well. Excellent staff and service.
Our reservation was at 730pm. We came in around 720pm. They then told us we would have to wait an additional 30-40 mins for an outdoor table even though I requested it. We ended up waiting 10-15 minutes at the bar. (Not bad) Our server Noah was on point with food recommendations, polite, courteous, and provided great customer service! The outside area was nice except there were so many bugs! I actually do not recommend sitting outside. The little flying bugs were everywhere and the candle they provided did not get rid of them. The light from the candle attracted them even more. But, dining outside naturally comes with bugs. We had the crab cakes and watermelon salad as an appetizer and they both were SO delicious. For the entree, I had the spaghetti cacio pepe with chicken. It was creamy and delicious. My boyfriend got the NY Strip and did not enjoy it or the sides. He said the strip tasted burnt instead of flavorful and the potato casserole side did not have much flavor either. For dessert we got the tiramisu, I 100% recommend it. Very tasty! All in all, the restaurant was nice and Noah was great!
Outdoor seating was comfortable. Service and food was OUTSTANDING, Fresh, and Delicious!!
Can’t wait to go back!
Views were good, food was meh and a bit overpriced.
A little pricey but lovely setting and service
The food is outstanding! Everything was perfectly prepared and served beautifully. The service was fast and friendly. We loved it.
Excellent food & service!! It was an intimate environment! We had a wonderful meal and even better cocktails
We went with friends and had a great time!
Great food and service! Will definitely be back.
Beautifully served 3 course lunch that was so delicious from beginning to end.
We enjoyed our dinner at the Gatsby’s Landing. The only downfall was having to wait 40 minutes for the outdoor dining..
The location and food were definitely good. Our only complaint was the raccoons that were near our table. One raccoon killed a bird right in front of us. I understand that we are right next to the animals natural habitat but for the amount of money we spent and not being able to enjoy our meal, made us not want to return again. The tables outside are right up against the lake and the animals can easily come right up to you. The raccoon could have rabies and therefore there is no telling what it would do to a human.
The Cheese Steak sandwich was out of this world flavor! I loved it.
Clams casino was a little under cooked.
The food was bland.
The lamb chops were under cooked and the issue was resolved after 3 attempts of sending it back to the kitchen.
my entire party finished eating by the time they finally got my dinner properly cooked!
We sat on the back deck facing the duck pond, saw many turtles and a duck. Food was good.
Absolutely wonderful service and pleasant atmosphere with nice decor. Unfortunately, food was bland across the board and drinks had no flavor.
Our server, Amy, was so sweet. The portions were huge! Everything at this restaurant is fresh and delicious.
Cannot recommend enough!
The entire staff were outstanding, very friendly and helpful. The restaurant was very clean and took extra precautions to keep everyone safe while social distancing, the water view was a nice surprise. Everyone (6 people) enjoyed the food very much. I would definitely recommend Gatsby landing and will defiantly be going back!
I love this place. They have. an intimate setting that is great for any date night. I highly recommend it. The food was delicious and the service was wonderful.
Pretty relaxing environment.
Food is not great but pretty good.
Good service and good atmosphere. Unfortunately, the food was not good. The gnocchi and squid ink dishes were very bland and the ingredients in each dish did not blend well together. The sangria was pretty bland as well. My wife and I would not recommend this place at all. Very overpriced and disappointed we wasted our hard earned money on a crappy meal. Spend your money elsewhere.
First time at this restaurant, really enjoyed the food. We had brunch/lunch there and all of the dishes we ordered were great. The service was wonderful as well.
Gatsby's Landing offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 277-2318.
Gatsby's Landing is rated 4.5 stars by 664 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.