It was a beautiful night, so we were glad to eat outside. Our waiter was pleasant and attentive without being intrusive. We had a couple drinks and a tasty appetizer. I had the smash burger which was very tasty. My wife had the half-chicken. She tells me it was tasty, but too large for her. All told a nice dinner at a reasonable price. Great place to stop before a Nats or DC United game (we were on our way to Audi Field).

The service was quite slow and they somewhat botched the promotion menu. The food was great

The wait staff was the only good thing about it. The food was overpriced and highly overrated, and came out with things that weren't listed, things I was allergic to, prompting the manager to apologize for the "mutual misunderstanding." The only reason I would go back in would be to give her a dictionary with the explanation of that phrase, which does not mean what she thinks. Don't waste your time or your money.

We went to Gatsby prior to a Nationals game. Had a reservation for three and ran into two friends outside who wanted to join. The staff asked us location preference and then added two seats in order to accommodate. Everybody enjoyed their meal. Spinach Dip was a real standout. So were the lasagna and smash burgers. Fun location right across from the stadium. Will definitely go back.

Excellent food and service from Emanuel for brunch before the Nats game. Will definitely be back!

Good food, terrible service. We sat outside and were forgotten by waitstaff.

Amazing food, great location. A bit noisy outside, as we were there right as a game started, but we knew what we signed up for. Dessert was phenomenal (watergate cake).

Country Fried Steak and Watergate Cake

Great dining experience pre game. Our waiter was excellent. Our good was very good. We would definitely go back.

All around very pleasant experience.

Very inexperienced server- great disposition but constant mistakes

Happy hour is a terrific deal! Monday night's friend chicken portion is HUGE and the food quality is great! I though the high-ball happy hour special needed more alcohol - one could barely taste it.

a great place to go before or after a Nats game and/or just to hang out in Navy Yard!

One of the best new places in the Navy Yard.

From the minute you walk in, the staff are delightfully welcoming and energetic. The entire ambiance and style of the restaurant is very cool, all done in an art deco style with lots of
black and gold that make it feel extremely chic. The waiters were knowledgeable on the menu, offering perfect recommendations for drinks and food, and the speed of service was fantastic. I’d heartily recommend it to anyone wanting to have a fun night out!

Great place to go before a ball game. It's pretty energetic and right on the main thoroughfare going into the game so there will be scalpers and such in view and calling out requests. May not be good outdoor seating if you're looking for something quiet.

Great first visit before the Nats 2d game. Henry was a superb server.
Smash burger was tremendous.
Finish and stroll across the street into Nats Park

Great time all around!

Good food and good drinks. Large portions. A bit loud. More modern/urban area.

Beautiful view of Nationals park from 3rd Floor! Excellent service from whole staff and especially Shelby. Food was superb! Our new "go to" before and after evening games.

Delicious food and cocktails. Love the decor and theme - BUT, they seem to clash that "roaring 20s" theme with a big-screen sports bar and a large crowd of loud patrons. Kinda kills the classy vibe and makes it hard to talk.

Went to Gatsby with some friends to grab a Happy Hour drink - they have THE BEST happy hour in Navy Yard. The service was impeccable - the drinks were amazing. The indoor decor is so cute - definitely nailed the 20s vibe. It got a bit loud but I think it was due to the Nats fans avoiding the rain. Overall a great experience and will surely be back!

We had a great meal sitting at the bar. Shannon was a funny and attentive server/bartender.

Great service and food. Placed a little close to other patrons making it difficult to hear conversation, but overall very satisfied with the experience.

Our waiter was absolutely horrible!
Very dismissive, not attentive, not respectful, not helpful nor was he polite. He came to our table once without being called and when confronted about his bad customer service, he was unapologetic and nonchalant!

The manager took over our table and allowed us the opportunity to end our night on a good note. Thanks Management!

We sat for about 25 minutes until a server made a visit to our table. As soon as service began it was very great and we had no other issues. Thank you for the nice dining experience.

Great brunch! We live right around the corner and are happy to have a new go-to for Sunday brunch!

Food is great but the service needs some practice. Our server seemed like she had never done it before though she was very pleasant. But what restaurant doesn’t have inexperienced waitstaff these days.

Food and drinks were amazing! our server was a bit rude and standoffish, but everything else was wonderful.

Food was just ok. The serving size of the salmon was really small. However, we did like their hot&sour wings.
Kind of dark outside.

Great drinks but date didn’t go well. But will be back!

The calamari was not crispy at all. The vegetables that came with the calamari was more crispy then the calamari. We planned to eat dinner but after the calamari we ended up going somewhere else.

Table was up 4 flights of steps. Okay but waiters had to walk steps to the bar so drink service was slow. Wife’s initial Vodka and tonic came as a gin and tonic. They cheerfully replaced it. I would have ordered another drink if I didn’t think it would take long to get.

Food was excellent. Calamari was lightly breaded with a tasty flavor. The order included pickles and potato chips? They were a nice addition along with seasoned nuts.

I had the Monte Cristo and it’s was very well prepared with marmalade on the side. My wife had the 1/2 chicken and we split an order of fries/onion rings. The onion rings had delicious breading.

Overall the service was good. Several workers participated in greeting us, serving water, bringing food and clearing dishes. In total (counting the floor manager) we had 6-8 different people stop at our table during the course of our dinner.

Amazing food (choose daily specials), perfect ambiance and friendly staff!

I made a reservation and was sat quickly when I arrived. The server was efficient and the food and drinks were delicious.

I’d give this 5 stars if it were not for the service. The hostesses were awesome and friendly but the server was aloof, wore his mask below his nose? and was generally inattentive. The food was delicious though and the cocktails were on point.

The Gatsby has a great vibe - and we had an awesome view of Nats Park! The waiter and waiter in training were both fantastic, attentive and great personalities. The food was delicious - the poutine fries were to die for! Only issue is we went during game time so parking was expensive - 30$. Would go again at different time for sure.

The food was not very tasty and was loaded with salt. The waitress was not efficient but I’m sure it’s because they include a 20% tip in your bill and so they don’t have to work to hard for tips.

Went there as my first indoor meal after fully vaccinated. It’s been over a year! Picked this place because I love the book/the movie/style. The decor is lovely. Not a large menu and unfortunately our dishes (pastrami and lasagne) were too salty. Fries were great though. I would still recommend for the decor.

Great ambiance and excellent service! Can’t beat the location especially with a baseball game going on.

Service was great and decor is attractive. Food was "okay". Home fries with crab Benedict were definitely "yesterday's leftover" and industrial. They were dry inside and had the taste of being reheated rather than hand cut and cook at order. Disappointing because restaurant has in house bakery/pastry shop. All elements of each dish should be from scratch.