Gargiulos Tinton Falls
Whiskey & Cigar Evening$128.00 per person
Jun 24, 2021 onlyJoin us for our an evening of tasting premium whiskeys & cigars in our outdoor courtyard. Evening included a buffet, wine & beer, a tasting of 4 whiskeys chosen by our whiskey specialist, and a complementary cigar. Visit our website for more info. Tax & Tip included. Cash Bar available.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Amazing!!!! Fried calamari, riceballs, baked oysters special, crabmeat with endive!!! Delicious!!! Lobster Fra Diavolo, Penne Pasquilina, the tile fish special! This place NEVER FAILS! Amazing Italian food, best in NJ!
This was our first time and we will absolutely be back! The food and service was amazing.
Great service, Excellent Staff, Good Food. I thought my dish needed more flavor. The pasta source and the Chicken parm were kind of blend.
Came to NJ from Buffalo, NY … loved every bite !!!!
The BEST anywhere. Worth traveling to from anywhere. Great food, great service.
Food is always good. Service was slow because of a huge party outside, lack of adequate staff. Music was too loud so people were talking louder than usual. Very noisy!
I found the restaurant through open table first time there. Food was very tasty and service was very good. Parking is a bit of an issue but aside from that I thought the experience was very good
Food is delicious- SMALL PORTIONS. Side dish of broccoli is extra & fit on my SMALL plate & cost $15 MORE! Waiter was very nice & apologized a million times for not being able to get our drinks or dinners out in a timely manner. 4 other tables got up & walked out. I’ve been there once before-before covid & service or lack of, was the same. I believe in 2nd chances.
We weren’t looking for anything for free- we had already paid bill & we’re on way out. When my husband told the owner last time we came it was the same slow or “lack of” service the owner told him GOOD- DONT COME BACK. OWNER was around & VERY AWARE of the bad service & sat at his own table eating, ignoring everything that was going on- I would never give any business a bad review, however anyone reading reviews to choose a good night out should be warned. Like I said, food was delicious but that’s all the positive I have for this place.
Food was delicious and the staff was super friendly. Great menu!
Good food, but expensive for what and where it is in relationship to surrounding area.
Always wonderful with Chef Darryl at the helm! Thanks so much!
First time eating at Gargiulos in Tinton Falls. Excellent dining experience.. Food, service, ambiance was excellent!!!!
We had seafood dishes and the calamari, scallops, and shrimp were cooked to perfection. The dishes were absolutely delicious. The portions were gigantic. We noticed most people had leftovers to take home. Everyone was extremely courteous and gave just the right amount of attention. We will definitely be back!
Great time. Great food. Will be back soon.
We sat outside. Lovely near the woods. Food and service were excellent. Enjoyed a relaxed, romantic dinner with my husband. Can’t wait to go back!!
Food was great, but took a bit long to come out
Over priced. Not to good
Nice trendy little neighborhood Italian Restaurant with excellent food and good service. Salads and Pasta's are great. Only complaint is for the price the Cowboy steak was sub par and very salty. Good wine selection as well. I will be back, will just not get the steak.
Great food and even better service!
We made a reservation for outdoors, not knowing it would be rainy, windy and about 50 degrees on May 29th. The food was great and the staff did their best but it was pretty uncomfortable.
The food was delicious, the management very hospitable. Service, however was slow. Also, the young bussing staff need training and supervision in preparing the table and serving properly. We will return and try again because the food is outstanding and we’d like to sample other items on the menu.
Made a reservation for my parents wedding anniversary. They raved about the food, service and ambience. Highly recommended!
Food was a little disappointing
Excellent wine selections a d a knowledgable Sommelier to assist you. Pleasant ambiance in the tent. Not quite a piazza in Sicily, but nicely reminiscent.
The service was great and so was the setting. The dinner food portions are small.
The food was delicious. We went for a special occasion. I would recommend this restaurant for both a casual dinner with friends to a special evening out. Go!
I cannot say enough about this restaurant. The food is fabulous and the service is just great. Everyone goes above and beyond to make your dining experience a good one. Perfect for dinner with the family, special occasion, business meal.
Best Italian food we have experienced eating out in years. Incredible service, just really great friendly people. Atmosphere is perfect for a romantic dinner!
Very well run restaurant. With quality food and good service
Best server ever! FAITH!!! Food was amazing. Only comment is road noise. Was sitting inside and street noise at times was startling!!
Lovely tent set up for outdoor dining. Menu was limited and expensive. Food was nothing special, and the veal was over cooked. Ate at the original in Brooklyn years ago, and now know why I didn’t go back. I think they may be coasting on the old-time reputation.
My recent college graduate was home for a visit and wanted Italian food. We’ve been to Garguilo’s in Coney Island and have never been disappointed. This visit was no different. Everyone was friendly and polite. The food was amazing. The owner stopped by our table to welcome us and thanked us for coming. I cannot wait to go back!
My family and I always enjoy dining at Gargiulos in Tinton Falls. The food is delicious, the atmosphere is cozy and the service is terrific. You won't be disappointed.
Very loud, rushed by staff, entrees lukewarm and quickly arrived after appetizers. Over priced.
I met my aunt and a cousin on Mother’s Day for lunch. The service was excellent and attentive, the meal paced perfectly and the food was absolutely delicious. Highly recommend.
Keeps getting better. Love it.
As always they never fail to provide an excellent experience. The food is constantly delicious, and the staff cannot due enough to ensure you have a great time. The ambiance is perfect for a special night out, business dinner, or just diner with the family. I cannot say enough about my experience here.
Food and service was great. They also have valet parking.
Good food paired with great service. The wait staff was very attentive and we were not rushed.
Gargiulos Tinton Falls offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (732) 389-9100.
Gargiulos Tinton Falls is rated 4.6 stars by 335 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.