Gargiulo's Coney Island
We have a huge dining area, perfect for enjoying a lunch with coworkers or a romantic dinner for two. In addition to lunch and dinner, we also offer private dining rooms that can host anywhere from 20 to 400 people. We also provide catering, so your next corporate meeting, party, wedding reception or event just got a lot tastier!
Book your next event with us
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Baked Clams (8 Clams)
Broiled, Francese, Fried, Marechiara or Recanati
Stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella
Nice place to bring friends. Good food and service.
Went to the Gargiulo's Pizza Garden on Friday night and we could not be happier with the experience. The food was excellent, our waiter was very accommodating, even brining us some appetizers that we asked for that were not on the Pizza Garden menu. The setting is beautiful, it's like being on a mini vacation close to home. If you are looking for a good meal in the summer with a lovely garden atmosphere, this is the place to go!
As always the food at Gargulios is delicious. Not sure why the service was terrible. We waited over 45 mins for our appetizers. When we asked the owner he told us “don’t push your luck”. And he was “the boss”.
We also waited about a half hour for them to bring us the check.
Maybe because of Covid they are working out the kinks. 🤷🏼♀️
Fantastic place, my favorite in NYC. I love that's unique atmosphere and fabulous food.
Never disappoints The food, service it’s like going to your family’s house.
We had a party of six and everyone was extremely pleased with the food and service. We had the hot antipasto which was delicious , the mushroom and asparagus, the fish salad and the baked clams. We threw In an order of fried calamari too! Everything was extremely tasteful. Dinner consisted of broiled filet,shrimp racanati, penne pasqualina.
We were given plenty of time to relax between courses which we really appreciated. Desert was fruit sorbet served in real fruit shells, tiramisu, and cannoli. We even had after dinner drinks. The house was lovely and gave our table a big dish of complimentary fruit. I cannot remember the last time I had such a great night out. Everything was perfect. The food and service were impeccable and we hope to return soon.
Food was the usual, fabulous. But they did not have enough people working as the service was poor. Each individual person was good, but was very stressed. Took forever to get food and drinks, 2.5 hours for dinner total. Had to cancel our second drink because diner was over. Didnt bother having dessert. Will go again, gave them a one time coming out of covid excuse.
My mother wanted to have a great experience and they sure did live up to expectations. The staff was super polite, curious, respectfully giving us our pravicy but still maintaining eye contact checking in to see if everything was okay. The owner you can see going around from table to table checking in on all his customers. Now the food it just melts in your mouth even the bread is a must talk . My recommendations is the steak a must have. Well that takes care of my spectacular visit to this whole in the wall .Btw parking is right in front.
Food was great service was right on target . Clams were fresh and spicy. I love this place
Great food with outstanding service...can't ask for more
have been coming back for 50 years, it's a great place anthony is a gracious host, the food is excellent
Mozzarella, Peppers, and Prosciutto appetizer was not that tasty, very bland. Would not recommend. Mozzarella in Carozzo needed a lemon caper sauce, did not cut it with just tomato sauce. Baked clams were good. Chicken Parmigiana was not that good. Best dish was the Penne Pasqualina.
Service was great. Waitress was friendly and very helpful..We ordered the artichoke and mozz corozza and both were very greasy. Main course was ok but not great. will not be returning,
Chez and the entire wait staff treat you with respect and make you feel like you are part of their family. We had a great time on Father's Day and celebrating my cousin's birthday too!
It’s all a delicious meal and great service. Never a bad experience.
If you enjoy seafood this is the best place to eat.
Always top notch
Unfortunately, was put at a table near the kitchen door and bus station. Too busy and people constantly passing our table.
Server was excellent! Food was average. Went there for old times sake, but a bit disappointed.
Exceeded our expectations! From the valet parking through dinner-Bravo!
Very welcoming, easy-going staff, delicious and fresh appetizers, nice selection of pasta dishes, beautiful, elegant dining room, attentive, friendly service.
Food was delicious as always. Friendly staff.
The service was great! The restaurant was a bit noisy, so it was a little difficult to talk. The food was on the level of a decent Italian restaurant - not bad, but nothing to write home about.
What can’t I say about Gargiulos? It is one of our family’s favorite restaurants. We have shared so many occasions and grown up with the staff that they know most of our menu favorites before we even order! The food is always delicious and desserts even more so! If you’re looking for a delicious Italian meal, it is 100% worth heading over to Coney Island and enjoy all Gargiulos has to offer.
This is our family's favorite restaurant and we have all our parties there. We know everyone and they anticipate all of our needs. The Wait Staff is amazing and Chez is like a part of our family.
Excellent food, service & atmosphere. Definitely coming back!
Birthday. This is a great place to meet up and dine. Service and food were wonderful. We’re glad they’re back up and running
Graduation and birthday
It’s been years since I’ve been there, and it was my mom’s first dinner out because of the pandemic, so this was a bit of a celebration for us. Everything was fantastic! The muscles appetizer was some of the best we’ve had. She had the eggplant rolatini appetizer as her meal and thoroughly enjoyed it. I had the shrimp francese and my husband had a chicken entree - everything was great. And our server (Jerry?) was super friendly. We’ll definitely be back!
Amazing food. Service is a little slow but definitely a culinary experience.
They also have valet parking which is a big plus
Authentic delicious Italian cuisine. Parking lot across the street makes the long trip worth it!
I went to Gargiulos reluctantly after having 3 previous mediocre experiences there.
The quality of the food has gone down in the last few years and the value is just not there. The waiter was cold and provided the minimum of service. I will not go back unless I have to. There are so many other great Italian restaurants in Brooklyn. I think Gargiulos is surviving on their once excellent reputation.
Great food, amazing staff, fun ambiance. Love this place - the BEST!
Loved the seating and was glad they had a full bar. The baked clams are the best choice under appetizers. This place makes a nice filet mignon. Over all I would recommend this place if you want a calm atmosphere to chill with family.
Excellence dining experience
Great restaurant. Food and service outstanding. Great atmosphere
Had a lovely dinner with my elderly mother. Hostess greeted us as we came through the door, was helpful taking her walker while I assisted my mother up the stairs. She seated us without rushing anyone and did the same as we were leaving. My mother truly appreciated her not making a big deal.
Server was pleasant, attentive and efficient but not overbearing or intrusive. Dinner was delicious and unrushed. No pushing to turn the table over.
Quite a nice experience.
Always a good meal,excellent service and over all experience
Emilio was our server. He was absolutely wonderful! We would go back again and ask for him.
old school Italian. nice menu. wait staff fantastic
Service is wonderful! Food is delicious! Very enjoyable evening.
Gargiulo's Coney Island offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (718) 266-4891.
Gargiulo's Coney Island is rated 4.7 stars by 425 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.