My wife, a friend and I ate dinner at Gallo Nero following a business meeting in NYC. This was the first time we had dined at this Hell's Kitchen eatery and we will definitely return. It is a cozy restaurant with a nice Italian menu and wine list. We each had a different dish and each one was tasty and nicely presented. Staff were friendly and attentive to our needs.
It was a great dining experience from honoring our reservation actually took us about 45 minutes earlier to the last bite except for the host's comment at end of dinner when we were just about to leave and he came to our table and asked us to leave because he had people waiting. I had just paid and was waiting for my husband to return and that actually soured me a bit to this place. All else was great except for that one moment. It should not have happened.
Been many times but not for about a year. Chicken was like shoe leather. Practically inedible. Will have to reconsider whether to give in another try before writing off like so many mediocre theater district restaurants. Very disappointing given how much we’ve enjoyed in the past.
Fine—the people who worked there were so lovely.
We came for lunch during the week—I was a little concerned about the quality since the price was so low on the website but decided to try it anyway. It served the purpose of eating but honestly wasn’t very good — I am not picky or complaining.
I love this place!
Every month when I am in NY on business I go here
Food is great
Service is great
Value is great
Wine list is great
Go here! It’s not to be missed!
Excellent service and the food was great.
A lovely spot. Aside from smaller portion of ravioli (only 5), food was delicious. Service and wine were great. We will definitely return.
Delicious food, good service, and a convenient location for the theatre. Come for the food and the bistro ambience. The table are very small and close together, so don't plan on intimate conversation during your meal.
I enjoyed the meal a lot. Very satisfied for what was served with this price. The only shortcoming would be the portion of food served. It is nice to have a lot in your plate but I feel so bad not finishing such food that I forced myself to eat a little more than I could and that was a suffer. But overall, I like this place. I would go again if seeing broadway shows. We ordered lamb shanks and mushroom Risotto, both taste great! I especially loved the veggie part of my lamb dish. The cranberries( I believe?? Not sure) are so refreshing.
Great, very tight, (in an OK way) with an excellent variety for varied tastes.
authentic Italian, with homemade pastas and a great burrata appetizer; friendly service, too; make a reservation, very popular and close to the theaters
The food was very good. The one negative thing that I would say is that I felt rushed. I still had a bite of my appetizer on my fork, and he took the plate, and served the entree'
Best wine wine bar in wold
Best wine bar ever this place got best wine selection
I tried a new dish, roasted chicken with mashed potatoes - excellent. Nice wine selections.
Service was very good.
Excellent food and service. I can't wait to go back.
Very nice Restaurant. Nice seating area with Wood Block tables. Food was very good and service was also very good.
Thanks Valdamir. It was a great evening..perfect service, yummy food, nice atmosphere.
Food was delicious and the wait staff was very courteous.
Food is delicious. Service is excellent! Wine list, including by the glass very good! Warm and cozy place! Only problem is that the music choices they have made are NOT good!! They being said, I keep coming back !!
Another great dinner ! Love bringing new people to Nero Gallo.
This was our 3rd trip to the restaurant and this time the food really stood out! My cousin couldn't stop raving about the meatball appetizer which SHE said were better than her recipe. She almost ordered them again for dessert. Turns out there was a new chef in the kitchen. She tried to get the recipe but no luck. Our waiter was very attentive; we didn't have to call him over once.
It is now our go-to restaurant whenever we are going to the theatre.
Me and my friend bought a $29 For A Bottomless Brunch For Two (a $76 Value) voucher from Pulsd. Although we did not have a $76 value meals, they automatically charged us tax on $76 and added (mandatory?) 20% tip on the same amount. We ended up paying a lot more than we would without the voucher. I used a lot of Pulsd and other vouchers for restaurants and never experienced anything similar. Otherwise, the food is good, nothing special.
Absolutely pleasurable dining experience.
Pork saltimbocca was excellent--and an enormous portion!
A nice selection of hand made pasta dishes. Gallo Nero is consistently good. The service tends to be a little blasé, but I think if you were in a rush to get to the theatre they would try to accommodate.
Valentine’s dinner with the girls! We had an amazing three course dinner with cocktails, wine, and prosecco. E everything was amazing! I’ll definitely be back.
It was a very good restaurant. We got our money’s worth . It was very noisy as there was a birthday celebration.. in the bill , they helped themselves putting an 18% tip - which is for a party of at least 6 people . We were only 4 . They gave us a slice of a deep chocolate cake .. it was very good bec our food. We’re a long wait
Very good value. Limited menu but good food.
Terrific apps & entrees, reasonable prices, nice wine list, great ambiance, great service. We REALLY enjoy it here!
Don’t miss this place.it is charming. A little gem in the crowded theatre district
Another fine meal at Gallo Nero, this time for Sunday lunch. Brunch also available Saturdays & Sundays. Recommended: Light, fresh corn/cucumber salad, Spinach/ricotta ravioli & eggplant fettucine. Service was gracious & efficient as in the past.
Great staff. Great meal. 5 guys for a biz dinner. All around great meal. Brought over free desert and after dinner drink too. Nice touch. Will be back.
Little off the main tourist area but worth the walk. Great Italian food at a reasonable price. Services was amazing and I would definitely come back
Absolutely Amazing every time! You just can't beat this place from food to service!
Great food, warm atmosphere, attentive staff. would highly recommend
This is a great neighborhood place to go. Folks are friendly, food is good and wine selection is nice. Really enjoy the place and highly recommend it.
Food was good. Menu was interesting. Prices are reasonable.
Tiny, a bit cramped yet comfy Italian restaurant with awesome service. The menu has enough variety to please most without being overwhelming. Wine list good, apps and entrees are nice size portions. Staff and kitchen extremely accommodating, service overall was A+.
Cosy and quiet. Food and service were okay. Wines quite pricey (44$ and up)