Shhhhh.... one of my favorite spots in St Augustine. Located on the oldest street in the US- Aviles (pronounced Av-eh-leez) Street. Excellent food, drink and service! Special shoutout to our waiter Jackson did a great job of being attentive without hovering. Locally sourced goodness and inspiring tasty cocktails. Sit outside along the sidewalk or inside and watch the trolleys and horse-drawn carriages go by. Just don't tell anyone- because then it will be harder to get a table. Enjoy!

Great evening! Really enjoyed our time here and the hospitality was fantastic. Our server offered refined and charming service. Definitely check this place out if you’re craving great food and great service!! Perfect for a date night or as a place to convince your parents you’re an adult. All the stars

we started with cocktails —Saturday happy hour prices— they were wonderful. We ordered the Brie. It was out of this world! The raspberry “sauce” with almonds, the crackers to nibble with, the fresh fruit-blackberries, grapes, & strawberries. It was over the too great! I had a small cup of the squash soup and the flavors!! to die for!!!

We decided to order a second brie as we loved it so much! What a wonderful little nook for lunch. Parking was ridiculous so get there 30 minutes early to find a nearby spot. Otherwise, it was just perfect! It’s moved to the top of our list

Outstanding food and drinks. Sitting outside listening to a street performer and people watching made for a great dinner! The vegetable flatbread appetizer was delicious and the Manhattan made by the mixologist was perfect.

We ate inside--no tables for 4 outside we were told--Great service (masked--thank you!) , great cocktails and very friendly staff. Food was great too--just a bit better timing; soups and salads came out with entrees...after we had enjoyed apps. I had chicken (with grits instead of massjed potatoes)--and it was awesome. Others had shrimp and grits and also enjoyed theirs--only problem was NOISE level--fine when we arrived [early, 5:30 ish] but so loud by the time we left we could not hear one another across the table.

Great food. Great atmosphere. The staff was very friendly and we had such an enjoyable time.

Learned about Forgotten Tonic from a friend.
We loved our drinks and dinners!

The mixed drinks were fantastic and the cobia was excellent.

The food and service was excellent everyone was very helpful overall great experience we will definitely be back.

It was absolutely wonderful! We will definitely be returning for dinner again!

So glad we went!! Awesome food and drinks!!! Highly recommended!! A little pricey but well worth it!!!

The food was amazing! The drinks were great! The staff really made the experience the best it could be! Our waitress Kayla was great! Her recommendations were on point. She was friendly and fun!

We sat outside which was delightful!! Their location is superb! They have a great bar! I do feel they could expand their limited menu although my husband & I split 4 appetizers. Everything was good! We will return as we always do! We miss Johnny terribly but wish him well in his new endeavor!

My wife they need our support. Forgotten Tonic won't disappoint!

Very nice place. Food and service was excellent! Drinks were even better 😁 Definitely recommend visiting this restaurant! 6 stars 🤩

We celebrated our anniversary here in 9/25/20. We loved it. It’s a beautiful atmosphere. Our server was great and very attentive. We got the Cajun egg rolls to start and then shared the blackened shrimp and grits Etoufe. It was so great and fun spin on shrimp and grits. Now the drinks were amazing and the ladies behind the bar impressed me With their simultaneous shaking and stirring two drinks at the same time. I will definitely be back.

Absolutely incredible. Quiet and lovely. Our request to sit at the window was granted. Our server was amazing and attentive - even gave us a free dessert to celebrate our anniversary! We can't wait to come back.

Nice small place off on a side street. Decore was very nice, Food was fantasic. Fun cocktails.

Absolutely amazing! Everything about this restaurant is top notch!! Definitely now my favorite spot! Spectacular food, service and ambiance! My last visit was so good that I was afraid my follow up visit couldn’t be as perfect, but it certainly was! Once again exceeding my expectations. Every bite was divine!!!

We visited the restaurant on National Hamburger Day because we had heard they had a great burger! It was amazing and did not disappoint. I would highly recommend.

Forgotten Tonic is a must try! We made reservations for a Thursday night to celebrate my boyfriends Birthday. We were seated immediately & ordered happy hour drinks and the Montenegro Meatballs which were delicious. For dinner my boyfriend got the Filet Mignon which was cooked to perfection and I highly recommend the Pasta Primavera with Shrimp, there was a solid portion of shrimp and had some crispy asparagus on the side! The staff was so friendly and even brought a birthday dessert out! You should definitely try out this place for your next date night!

Went out of their way to make sure we had a good time celebrating a special occasion. Service was excellent!

Wonderful place to go for some pleasant atmosphere, awesome drinks and food.

Cocktails were exceptional and service was spot on! A definite place to return to.

Awesome place to have lunch, dinner or just a few drinks!

Amazing bday dinner! Dribks were incredible and the food was just as amazing!

Out of too many main courses.... NO steak available on a holiday weekend... Meals very good. Just not sure why out of so many items.

Drinks were awesome! Unfortunately, the food was another story. They served me completely raw chicken and my wife had a burger and the bun was pretty much frozen. They were extremely apologetic and we sent both of our entrees back and once new ones were cooked it was pretty tasty. They comped our dinners and one round of drinks so they definitely made up for the problems and we’ll give them another try because of that! We enjoyed ourselves nonetheless.

We went for my husband’s birthday! The food was delicious and the server was very knowledgeable when we asked for recommendations. It was definitely a dinner to remember!

Food was great, drinks were amazing, server was fantastic! Very knowledgeable about menu!!!

Very nice experience on a warm day. Server was outstanding. Cocktail was very refreshing.

The food and service was exceptional

Went for lunch and had a wonderful time. My husband and I sat at the bar and enjoyed the FGT, soup and arugula salad. Everything was great. Most enjoyable was talking to the owner- he was so nice. They practiced social distancing. I can’t wait to visit again. Also the drinks were delicious.

Our table wasn't quite ready @ the time of our reservation so we had drinks @ the bar while waiting; perfect! Hannah, our server was attentive but not overly, perfect again! I had the Cobia on stir fried grains; super tasty not overly Asian tasting & my husband had the pasta Primavera that was outstanding, though the shrimp he added w/ it he thought were a bit overcooked. Make a reservation as soon as you can for this delightful gem in Saint Augustine!

Had a really good meal! Excellent service from the hostess snd wait staff. We will be back! Shrimp and grits etoufee was awesome!

Last minute reservation . It was my birthday ! And they brought a surprise desert with their compliments . Very nice . Also very safe distancing and servers with masks and gloves. Great food . Go you won’t be sorry !

Great happy hour deals. Salads are huge! Food was flavorful.

Great atmosphere and great little spot to enjoy good food/drinks. Vacationing from TN and went because we heard it was a good spot. We made a reservation and got there a little early. We ordered drinks and they were served to go so we walked around while we waited. Would definitely come back!

Atmosphere and ambiance were perfect for a romantic dinner! Good was great, and service even better.

Just right